Role Madness Too Many Doctors (Game Thread)

[Flower]

Okay, Fuji and YTW aren’t a team either.

 

[Flower]

If Hime‘s scum probably just clean house with my PoE.

 

[Crowned Witch]

Trying to make sense of the wagons:

@Fujishiro Why did you vote hime?
@Ali v2 @York @Red Night What are your individual reasons for voting Mango?

 

[Fujishiro]

Trying to make sense of the wagons:

@Fujishiro Why did you vote hime?
@Ali v2 @York @Red Night What are your individual reasons for voting Mango?

I town lean hime but I don’t feel great about her dropping off the face of the earth after her whole early interactions regarding the plan

Was thinking the same bestie.

 

[Flower]

Michelle
York
Alexis
Ali
Yoho


Daniel
Orca
Fuji
Ugh…Ratchet
Hayumi
Ekko
AM
Nibel

Crowned
Stargate

Mango
Hime
YTW
RA
Polar Bear

Moved Nibel a tier higher.

 

[Fujishiro]

Moved Nibel a tier higher.

I said yo is likely town.

 

[Flower]

I said yo is likely town.

What does this have to do with Nibel?

 

[Fujishiro]

What does this have to do with Nibel?

In your reads list hes at the bottom.

 

[Flower]

In your reads list hes at the bottom.

Yeah. He seems like a carbon copy of Overlord.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Yo Tan: Already more involved than the entirety of Overlord, so could be Town.

Atleast your reason for reading me were activity, so PoE make sense but you put me in scum leans.

Ratchet had also agreed with your early game read of me. Yet jumped to vote me instantly.

Actually don't mind these reads, though I disagree. The Yo Tan read is worthwhile, think your hime read is pretty poor (not saying you have to read her town, but your reasoning for her to be scum amounts to her having a belief and arguing in favour of it which is already a townie trait when scum are going to be looking to play safe, and then you've also completely failed to consider whether her mindset ever made sense under the assumption that she had no idea mafia had to skip an action to kill).

 

[Flower]

...Okay, I know I just said I'd ignore this, but I really think you're barking up the wrong tree here.

I played a game with scum!Ratchet, and they were way more subtle about their partners there. No way all three of them pair themselves so closely together as scummates.

Okay, this is probably Town for Star.

 

[Crowned Witch]

Moved Nibel a tier higher.

I'm now below Daniel, Orca and a few others somehow?

You think Polar Bear might be bussing RA by having voted him?

 

[Flower]

Issue I have is that usually the guy screams I AM TOWN!! to me with his posts, but I think here him going against me is probably just a good sign and shows he has his own head.

 

[Flower]

I'm now below Daniel, Orca and a few others somehow?

You think Polar Bear might be bussing RA by having voted him?

Yeah, Polar does bus.

 

[Red Night]

I have a plan to make us both rich if you buy a Switch 2 for me.

I don't trust you...

 

[Red Night]

I'm now below Daniel, Orca and a few others somehow?

You think Polar Bear might be bussing RA by having voted him?

Clearly the kind of player who could bus

 

[Flower]

Crowned, Fuji isn’t happening today. Place your vote on a wagon that’s more likely to happen please.

 

[Ratchet]

Atleast your reason for reading me were activity, so PoE make sense but you put me in scum leans.

Ratchet had also agreed with your early game read of me. Yet jumped to vote me instantly.
​

The post you quoted literally says that I disagree. I said it was worthwhile, as in it's not unsound reasoning. But the very first sentence says "I disagree with your reads".

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Anyway because @Flower needs the help, I have a perfect solution to her plan's flaw, that being how we nominate a target.

My solution is KINGMAKER.

That's right. Every day, we nominate one person to choose who we all pile on tonight. If they die and flip town over the night, we lynch the King the day after, and nominate the next one. And so forth. Until we reach a point in the game where it's not tenable.

This encourages scum to consider bussing and presents a fair shake for all, which makes it more agreeable for people to follow than just some random people deciding. For day 1, we either lynch an inactive or we no lynch, I need to work out the numbers around that if it's worthwhile.

That is fun but how could that possibly give us W?

A town could end up choosing a townie? Getting lynched next.
While a scum could bus, and get town support. Mislead players ahead n lynch a town, then claim he ended up wrong this time. That's Chaos not game winning strategy.​

 

[Ratchet]

That is fun but how could that possibly give us W?

A town could end up choosing a townie? Getting lynched next.
While a scum could bus, and get town support. Mislead players ahead n lynch a town, then claim he ended up wrong this time. That's Chaos not game winning strategy.​

That can happen, sure. The watcher can catch scum by reporting who doesn't target the Kingmaker's target. But sure town can be wrong. And if town are wrong then they get punished for it.