Character Discussion Top 5 worst written characters
- Thread starter Shiroyru
- Start date
Unfortunately good guys even generic and uninteresting will on average beat villains in popularity polls, Carrot being in the top 8 is a prime example why polls shouldn't be taken seriously 
Like at least be consistent
Most people like Kaido, I'm not saying most people have Kaido as their favorite character and that's fine, do you think polls are an objective way of determining which character is better than the other considering Carrot ended up in the top 8 just because she's a cute bunny?
Saying Kaido doesn't have any depth is just blatant lies, I fully expected him to be just a generic juggernaut with no honor, yet he surprised me by being a more developed character than anyone could've expected.
Saying Kaido doesn't have any depth is just blatant lies, I fully expected him to be just a generic juggernaut with no honor, yet he surprised me by being a more developed character than anyone could've expected.
I literally caught a guy making shit up about his backstory, shit that contradicts the story
Like, if you like Kaido that’s fine but you have to own up to the fact that most people don’t think he’s well written.
Out of millions of fans? That’s like not even 1%
you keep pointing to the mythical Kaido fan who thinks he’s well written, when again I keep pointing out that even outside of this community there’s heavy critique for him. If you want to think of yourself as some intellectual because you understand something most of us don’t by all means go ahead. Just don’t pretend like you’re in the majority
Like, if you like Kaido that’s fine but you have to own up to the fact that most people don’t think he’s well written.
Out of millions of fans? That’s like not even 1%
you keep pointing to the mythical Kaido fan who thinks he’s well written, when again I keep pointing out that even outside of this community there’s heavy critique for him. If you want to think of yourself as some intellectual because you understand something most of us don’t by all means go ahead. Just don’t pretend like you’re in the majority
Doffy speaks to people for some reason.
The thing is, it's fair to say that Doffy is the more complex character with a longer backstory, but that was expected, from the moment he was introduced everyone expected a trickster such as him to have an interesting backstory.
Kaido on the other hand was infamous only because of his fighting power, most people expected him to be just a simple minded juggernaut without any complexity, surprisingly enough that wasn't at all what he is, unexpectedly he got more depth than most people anticipated and that works well for a character like Kaido.
He is fairly complex and has a detailed backstory, but is definitely overrated, he didn't do anything groundbreaking in terms of character development or backstory, I have no clue why he's the best OP villain for so many people.
The thing is, it's fair to say that Doffy is the more complex character with a longer backstory, but that was expected, from the moment he was introduced everyone expected a trickster such as him to have an interesting backstory.
Kaido on the other hand was infamous only because of his fighting power, most people expected him to be just a simple minded juggernaut without any complexity, surprisingly enough that wasn't at all what he is, unexpectedly he got more depth than most people anticipated and that works well for a character like Kaido.
Post automatically merged:
He is fairly complex and has a detailed backstory, but is definitely overrated, he didn't do anything groundbreaking in terms of character development or backstory, I have no clue why he's the best OP villain for so many people.
Croc has zero backstory chapters but is easily a top 3 OP villain because how oda wrote him in the present. Having the Alabasta royal guard drink a suicide drink to grow stronger to fight him then for croc to just avoid the fight cause it’s more fun to watch them die in vain is fucking peak villainy.
Doffy is easily better written than Enel LMAO. Enel is cool but he’s pretty shallow as well
Croc is a toss up I don’t even care to argue. The difference in aura is because Oda went with a different storytelling structure with Croc. Where Croc was always one step ahead of the good guys, Doffy started the arc with his back against the wall, and has to scramble to get back in control
Croc is a toss up I don’t even care to argue. The difference in aura is because Oda went with a different storytelling structure with Croc. Where Croc was always one step ahead of the good guys, Doffy started the arc with his back against the wall, and has to scramble to get back in control
It shouldn’t be hard to understand why people love Doflamingo more than Kaido.
Doffy is not an inconsistent mess like the fish. It’s as simple as that. He may not be as complex as some fans try to act like he is, but he’s entertaining and remains the driving force of the arc he’s featured in.
Kaido besides being a mess was also a backseat driver for most of Wano. He spends most of the time reacting to his co-villains taking the initiative.
Besides being strong he just doesn’t have much else to offer that’s of interest.
Doffy is not an inconsistent mess like the fish. It’s as simple as that. He may not be as complex as some fans try to act like he is, but he’s entertaining and remains the driving force of the arc he’s featured in.
Kaido besides being a mess was also a backseat driver for most of Wano. He spends most of the time reacting to his co-villains taking the initiative.
Besides being strong he just doesn’t have much else to offer that’s of interest.