[FNZ] Role Madness Valentine's Mafia Game: Be My Valentine

[Apollo]

@Apollo

So many details, I missed that.

You might be right, Doc was an accomplice and he got killed by another murderer.

 

[Charlie]

Well, how did Rosa lock the door then ? She cannot use Genji's key. The doctor has no key either.

who says she did?

they literally run out of the building, no mention of opening door

 

[Dr_Professor83]

So many details, I missed that.

You might be right, Doc was an accomplice and he got killed by another murderer.

Problem is figuring out who killed Jessica.

Wait. Isn’t Maria the one who said the guesthouse was still locked? If it was Rosa María could lie.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

who says she did?

they literally run out of the building, no mention of opening door

Someone says the door is still locked when they find Doc’s body

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Maria: Everything is locked up perfectly.

Liar? Covered for her mom?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Rosa kills Doc. Leaves. Maria lies and says everything was still locked. Profit?

 

[Apollo]

Rosa kills Doc. Leaves. Maria lies and says everything was still locked. Profit?

Okay, Rosa and Maria. Who killed Krauss/Natsuhi ?

 

[Charlie]

Okay, Rosa and Maria. Who killed Krauss/Natsuhi ?

Doctor. He needs to kill someone.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Okay, Rosa and Maria. Who killed Krauss/Natsuhi ?

One kills the other.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Doctor. He needs to kill someone.

Doc kills the two servants

 

[Charlie]

Oh wait. Krauss/Natsuhi.

One of them kills another and gets locked in the room.

But i have to agree, it's pretty whack option.

Maybe Krauss is killed by Natsuhi so that they let they live for some reason?

 

[Apollo]

Doctor. He needs to kill someone.

Doctor has no means of locking the door to the bedroom

One kills the other.

A bit meta here, but would they really leave their daughter outside while they are stuck in ?

And of course, no motive I can think of. This is why I think there could be another accomplice who locked the door after the murder.

 

[Ultra]

A few points:
Kamasuwa mentioned Rosa there covered by blood.
Where would Rosa get the keys to get into the guesthouse ?

You know if Rosa walked out after T1 she could have gotten to the guesthouse and just hid before they locked it

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Rosa - kills everyone in T1, Maria lies says she’s dead
One spouse kills other in T2, Doc lies and says they’re dead
Maria - kills Shanon in T4
Doc kills servants in T5/T6
Rosa kills Doc after he lets Rosa in, and Maria lies about locks
Rosa kills Jessica

-
now, question is if Maria can kill Shanon (someone said in Purple she can’t but maybe they are underestimating her)

 

[Ultra]

meaning cuprits are

Rosa, Maria, Doctor and one of Krauss/Natsuhi

I don't see the 8 year old killing anyone

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I don't see the 8 year old killing anyone

She’s clearly a psycho

 

[Charlie]

I don't see the 8 year old killing anyone

i mean, this is 8 years old killing 12 years old or whatever

 

[Dr_Professor83]

But that is the hang up. Also, if she doesn’t kill anyone, then Rosa is clear bc she (Maria) can’t lie if she doesn’t kill.

 

[DoflaMihawk]

This is convoluted as fuck.

Can you think of a way there's less than 4 culprits?

 

[Ultra]

i mean, this is 8 years old killing 12 years old or whatever

We have Georgie saying she can't physically kill in T8, so he would have to be implicated with her. Doubt.