Controversial Venting Thread - Mafia Edition

[Naomi]

No I perfectly get what youre saying, what do you suggest we do?

to make everyone into npc with no individuality.

 

[RippedCal]

Honest opinion: Does it make sense for me to keep discussing in general? Feels like I'm talking to a wall.

Isn't that what venting tends to be

If you want my advice id say come play ranked at the other place where its more competitive and we discourage horrendous play with game bans

 

[Rej]

No I perfectly get what youre saying, what do you suggest we do?

Its hard to solve such an issue.
The only thing that proves successful, is teaching people the way of town through giving spare ressources to play with and still good variety.

We need a season where someone hosts a mountainous game, or maybe a big 30 player one shot mafia with an open setup and no claim rules enforced. Something where there are 3 vigs each one shot and they have to follow the best PoEs in the game to work it out. 3 one shot cops who have to figure out targets by reevaluating how compatible or incompatible players are.

Variety atp is not only flavour, but utilizing different ways of solving each time and approaching a game. The same approach each gaming and doing mech D2 is jading out players as a result I feel. I also feel it.

 

[Fujishiro]

to make everyone into npc with no individuality.

I think her issue is that some players trolled the game and thus costed town victory but imo mafia just played better then town, Im not saying that town trolling didnt help though.

 

[Fujishiro]

Its hard to solve such an issue.
The only thing that proves successful, is teaching people the way of town through giving spare ressources to play with and still good variety.

We need a season where someone hosts a mountainous game, or maybe a big 30 player one shot mafia with an open setup and no claim rules enforced. Something where there are 3 vigs each one shot and they have to follow the best PoEs in the game to work it out. 3 one shot cops who have to figure out targets by reevaluating how compatible or incompatible players are.

Variety atp is not only flavour, but utilizing different ways of solving each time and approaching a game. The same approach each gaming and doing mech D2 is jading out players as a result I feel. I also feel it.

Yeah the issue is people here do not like vanilla games, they prefer mech heavy games.

 

[Fujishiro]

Isn't that what venting tends to be

If you want my advice id say come play ranked at the other place where its more competitive and we discourage horrendous play with game bans

She was in the other place and left it because town wasnt playing up to par.

 

[Naomi]

I think her issue is that some players trolled the game and thus costed town victory but imo mafia just played better then town, Im not saying that town trolling didnt help though.

if town getting trolled, can't even tell if said player is trolling/solving at the same time.. tells me they never bothered to read/understand the players.

like i can see orca trolling, but i still read him and polar town and vote on orca scum read.

the troll angle is bs.

 

[Fujishiro]

if town getting trolled, can't even tell if said player is trolling/solving at the same time.. tells me they never bothered to read/understand the players.

like i can see orca trolling, but i still read him and polar town and vote on orca scum read.

the troll angle is bs.

Some people have a hard time or cannot be bothered looking through the trolling to find a town read.

 

[RippedCal]

She was in the other place and left it because town wasnt playing up to par.

Maybe she needs to lower the expectations she has for complete strangers playing an obscure game on a niche internet forum then

 

[Rej]

Yeah the issue is people here do not like vanilla games, they prefer mech heavy games.

then prove them wrong, prove that a gimmick game thats soft on mech or even vanilla can become a hit too, there are so many possibilities, the gimmick just has to be that good and fun that it enables the players to enjoy the game and have some change of pace or a variation

I also have so many ideas, but it is like an autistic adhd storm in my brain where never anything sticks and new ideas and shit keeps popping up lol. We need a focussed host who can bring some magic back lol

 

[Fujishiro]

Maybe she needs to lower the expectations she has for complete strangers playing an obscure game on a niche internet forum then

Yeah, I did it and everything feels much better. I used to get mad every game.

 

[Fujishiro]

then prove them wrong, prove that a gimmick game thats soft on mech or even vanilla can become a hit too, there are so many possibilities, the gimmick just has to be that good and fun that it enables the players to enjoy the game and have some change of pace or a variation

I also have so many ideas, but it is like an autistic adhd storm in my brain where never anything sticks and new ideas and shit keeps popping up lol. We need a focussed host who can bring some magic back lol

I mostly focus on RM and SRM but you can try your hand on light games, my Fire Emblem Game was a gimmick one and I feel it was a success overall setup wise.

 

[Rej]

I mostly focus on RM and SRM but you can try your hand on light games, my Fire Emblem Game was a gimmick one and I feel it was a success overall setup wise.

one day when I have a clear head for that for sure kek

 

[Dr. Watson]

Have I played a different game than the rest?

Wanted to avoid calling out names but:
Orca, Polar, Juice, Naomi, Watson, AM, Jaguar, Reloaded, Alexis were all town and none of them did town any favour.

k what could i have improved

 

[Dr. Watson]

i dont think you have ever immediately been able to read me as town, i legitimately think part of this perception is i simply come across inherently scummy to you?

some others do not have this perception of my play, which is why i mention it