Character Discussion Vice captain Jinbe

#23
SHs don't have official ranks but Oda will not change the crew dynamic, it'll always Luffy and then Zoro at No. 2 but Jinbei can be the de facto advisor and strategist of the crew which is like a Vice Captain.
 
#27
What happen if i say,that there's no VC on the crew?.It's so simple they're all friends they doesn't work like any other crew.They always going to follow the best choice whoever says it besides we can't consider Luffy like a serious captain
 

Finalbeta

Ging Freecss stan
β€Ž
#28
He is more of an advisor at this point. Zoro is the vice-captain. Debating this position is the same as debating X is SHs captain.
Even the databooks showed how Zoro is a "Vice Captain like" swordsman.

Moreover, I still remember how different pirates Zoro came across showed their awe for noticing that Zoro was not the captain and genuinely admit they would even have thought that he actually was, and also asserted, because of his strenght.

So that's even beyond "vice captain like".
 
#32
Jinbei too perfect too good. Why Oda failed to create new fishman character to join the crew??

Zoro more focused on disciplinary, Jinbei motivation, Sanji strategize and leading.

Pick and choose
I actually agree with this.

Zoro is more good with handling what should happen with crew members. Thats cause he can seperate his emotions from the task at hand.

Whilst Sanji is more good at leading people because of his charisma and perception. Whilst Zoro just runs off or would just get lost.
 
#33
@Albino πŸ‘‘ Pretty sure this is your 5th thread on the same topic and it got covered each time.
There are other ways of getting attention...
I surprisingly dont think it is
:sanmoji:

It aint like its a that controversial take. Jinbe is definitely more than suited for the role from what weve seen of him

It aint even like i said hes the second strongest after luffy and it'll stay that way. Mainly cause i don't believe that. Zoro, sanji, and potentially yamato if he joins will all surpass him imo when it comes to strength
 
#34
I surprisingly dont think it is
:sanmoji:

It aint like its a that controversial take. Jinbe is definitely more than suited for the role from what weve seen of him

It aint even like i said hes the second strongest after luffy and it'll stay that way. Mainly cause i don't believe that. Zoro, sanji, and potentially yamato if he joins will all surpass him imo when it comes to strength
so instead of the crewmate thats been around since like chapter 3, that has been called first mate and vice captain by other characters inverse, jinbe, the one who joined like 900 chapters later, is the vice captain all of a sudden?

Its not a controversial take, i agree. its just a stupid one
 
#36
so instead of the crewmate thats been around since like chapter 3, that has been called first mate and vice captain by other characters inverse, jinbe, the one who joined like 900 chapters later, is the vice captain all of a sudden?

Its not a controversial take, i agree. its just stupid one
Jinbe can do everything zoro could and then some when it comes to the role. Zoro will grow stronger but other than that nothing really puts him over jinbe when it comes to leading and advising.

Jinbes been with luffy since the 500s on and off. Aint like he a new character that first appeared mid way wano
Each time hes been with luffy and the crew in the new world alone hes had to heavily take charge
  1. In Fishman island when it came to the hody situation
  2. In wci when it came to allying with capone and then leading the sunny team with luffy and sanji away
  3. Even now on onigashima neither zoro or sanji has done something he didn't when it comes to straight leading
    • Hes with sanji leading luffy to kaido
    • Zoro, franky, and him all essentially said the same thing to drake and luffy
    • He didn't randomly leave the crew to get lost or go on hoe patrol. Tho both admittedly lead to good things
    • And man at least worked with the crew to get big mom out
 
#37
Jinbe can do everything zoro could and then some when it comes to the role. Zoro will grow stronger but other than that nothing really puts him over jinbe when it comes to leading and advising.

Jinbes been with luffy since the 500s on and off. Aint like he a new character that first appeared mid way wano
Each time hes been with luffy and the crew in the new world alone hes had to heavily take charge
  1. In Fishman island when it came to the hody situation
  2. In wci when it came to allying with capone and then leading the sunny team with luffy and sanji away
  3. Even now on onigashima neither zoro or sanji has done something he didn't when it comes to straight leading
    • Hes with sanji leading luffy to kaido
    • Zoro, franky, and him all essentially said the same thing to drake and luffy
    • He didn't randomly leave the crew to get lost or go on hoe patrol. Tho both admittedly lead to good things
    • And man at least worked with the crew to get big mom out
why does it matter that jinbe worked with luffy before? He is only now in the crew, that was my point.

he is the helmsman, get over it. Also i'll wish you luck in overcoming your zoro obsession
Post automatically merged:


imagine trying to argue against the manga smh
 
Last edited:
#38
why does it matter that jinbe worked with luffy before? He is only now in the crew, that was my point.

he is the helmsman, get over it. Also i'll wish you luck in overcoming your zoro obsession
Because you acting like hes brandnew. Man has interacted with luffy and the crew long before he joined and that doesn't mean nothing

Yes and him being helmsman doesn't mean he cant be more than that. Tho i dont think he or anyone would ever really be officially considered vice captain of the crew. Maybe usopp if his lie became true but even thats a stretch

Its not about being over zoro its that jinbe is just fitting for the role.
I dont think anyone in the crew besides luffy has shown anything that puts them above jinbe when it comes to strength specifically. At the same time if they aren't already due to enma and the raid suit i do think zoro and sanji will surpass him

Zoro and sanji fans love using jinbe to show how the other is kicked out of the top 3 but not admittedly jinbe still has better portrayal than both of them
:kayneshrug:
 
#39
Because you acting like hes brandnew.
i specifically used the term "join", so no, this is just you talking out of your ass.
sniper
I dont think anyone in the crew besides luffy has shown anything that puts them above jinbe
irrelevant to what we are discussing here
Zoro and sanji fans love using jinbe to show how the other is kicked out of the top 3 but not admittedly jinbe still has better portrayal than both of them
so speaking about things that have nothing to do with what i said is productive how exactly?


Man this is really fucking sad
imagine trying to argue against the manga smh
 
#40
i specifically used the term "join", so no, this is just you talking out of your ass.

sniper

irrelevant to what we are discussing here

so speaking about things that have nothing to do with what i said is productive how exactly?


Man this is really fucking sad
Even if just joined 10 chapters ago his tine as an unofficial strawhat mattters just as much

Yes i know usopp is the sniper of the crew. Zoro the combatant, chopper the doctor, etc. The crew doesn't have a vice captain

Ok..

Honestly i just misread your last sentence. Aint that deep


:okay:
 
Top