What a disasterclass beginning for this day. Plenty of town died during the NP (I'll have to look through those WUs for more info), then that Rat-Nat face-off was terrible.
1-We know Ratchet can only be affected by top posters at all, its something we know for a while now. Nat with her post-restriction couldn't have actually had that go through to Ratchet. By mech, Ratchet shouldn't be Queen at all.
2-Ratchet wasting that kill on Nat for her accusations is a terrible play. Even if she was 99% scum, we have people who are 100% scum like TAC. Who escaped via another game removal while the kill went to Nat. That is a valuable killshot wasted on a strong town role.
3-I don't think Ratchet is scum at this point either, the all-stars ability does NOT state that Kaido gets to know the alignment of his chosen all-stars. Even if we believe that the ability was tampered with, point 1 should still apply. Much like how the Flower-Adam "Nobody" thing happened when Charlie revealed it.
4-To further reinforce point 1, Nat was targeted by Ratchet with a kill, which according to her and the written ability should've given her a refill. Something she said she didn't get.
I think this was just a gamble from Nat to try and out Ratchet since she scum-read him, with Ratchet being rather impulsive in his judgement.
I don't want to see town mislynch or get rid of another strong role. Atp we should focus on the already outted ones. TAC and Mango are removed, so unless someone can bring them back we have to look for new lynches.
Not sure why town seems to ignore Ultra is scum as well, but I want to look into other suspects before settling my vote on him.