General & Others What’s your Rating for One Piece on a scale of 1-10?
- Thread starter pg13
- Start date
Depends what you want to compare it to. Only other shonen series or all kinds of literature?
Compared to shonen only: 9.5/10
Compared to all kinds of literature: 6.5/10
OP is quite a bit repetitive in its structure as it goes on. Story itself is solid, but also clearly a rather simplistic shonen story (not comparable to seinen works or other works of literature).
However, it's just a damn fun read and I love the overall world/atmosphere itself.
In short: Just don't expect a masterpiece of storywriting, then you'll have a very fun time reading it.
Compared to shonen only: 9.5/10
Compared to all kinds of literature: 6.5/10
OP is quite a bit repetitive in its structure as it goes on. Story itself is solid, but also clearly a rather simplistic shonen story (not comparable to seinen works or other works of literature).
However, it's just a damn fun read and I love the overall world/atmosphere itself.
In short: Just don't expect a masterpiece of storywriting, then you'll have a very fun time reading it.
H
Your current rating for the One Piece series?
To me pre-timeskip is like 9.
Post-timeskip up to Zou is 6.
After that is 1.
So (9+6+1)/3 = 5,333... So it is 5.
Post automatically merged:
If you have pre 10 and post 8 then it makes a 9 overall not a 10.
And if you have 6 for Wano I wonder how much you scale the others arcs to make it 8 post skip.
Like I said, the best parts of a series will always overshadow the worst parts for me. The greatness of pre-time skip overshadows the decline of post-time skip.
For post-time skip, I love Dressrosa, 1st half of WCI and the Reverie, so they’re doing all the heavy lifting. Wano is simply the worst part of it, but it doesn’t stop me from liking the rest.
For post-time skip, I love Dressrosa, 1st half of WCI and the Reverie, so they’re doing all the heavy lifting. Wano is simply the worst part of it, but it doesn’t stop me from liking the rest.
