Questions & Mysteries What do you guys think of this? a fourway battle

#1
A 4 way battle but technically a 3 1 v1. shanks vs bb vs luffy vs akainu. luffy barely defeats akainu and is weakened and the same also happens to bb.

so weakened fluffy fights weakened bb. It would be the perfect way for oda to kill 2 birds with one stone
 
#2
Yes, Ive made 2 separate threads on this ( 3 if you consider my Akainu/Blackbeard one as well)
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...piece-but-so-will-akainu-and-his-fleet.43223/

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/its-all-coming-to-together-very-soon.46642/

I entirely believe that post Egghead (or Elbaf), Oda cannot afford providing individual arcs for the remaining Yonko and Marines. All of this will escalate into a giant war that will:

- Have everyone match against 2-3 opponents, not just one
- Those opponents will face each other as well
- And the last groups standing (I.e. Luffy and someone else) will fight at LT.

This may or may include Imu and the WG, because I think its important that the Seraphim pose viable threats to more than just the crew or RA in the end, but all of the allies that will eventually be involved in the endgame. But, that entity may be too big to include here.

Akainu, Shanks, Blackbeard and Luffy (and maybe CG in the future) all have 9-10 members with fleets. Oda doesnt have to go ham including countless allies and kingdoms at that point, just focus on them and the Burned Man (if he's not tied to Elbaf)
 
#4
A battle royale of that scale is too much of a clusterfuck for Oda to handle. He couldn’t even give every major BP a decent fight in Wano.
The issue is thats exactly what he keeps implying in all of his updates to the fanbase.


I argue the finale side of it can last way longer and Oda doesnt need to worry about shit lasting hundreds of chapters at that point because he got to the big war he's wanted to draw for 25 years.


This is why I believe Kizaru and whoever Elbaf's villain is (Burned Man, Rocks, Loki, Elbaf, whatever) are the last "orthodox" villains in the series. After this, its just a massive, multi arc, multi island war until the end.
 
#5
A battle royale of that scale is too much of a clusterfuck for Oda to handle. He couldn’t even give every major BP a decent fight in Wano.
the bb pirates looks so disappointing to be an improvement from wano, imagine going from king to someone who was coughing blood from a nameless body slam
 
#8
I can’t see oda writing that well and it would lower the emotion of luffy fighting each of these men as luffy wont be able to focus on one.

Basically it’d turn into the same shit that wano did with how pathetic law and kid Vs Big Mom was.

Tournament style 1v1s >>>
 
#10
A 4 way battle but technically a 3 1 v1. shanks vs bb vs luffy vs akainu. luffy barely defeats akainu and is weakened and the same also happens to bb.

so weakened fluffy fights weakened bb. It would be the perfect way for oda to kill 2 birds with one stone
Akainu cant wait to act up, Egghead will signal the red alert to it, Mugiwaras are the Marines/WG top threat, think it'll go down in Elbaf
 
#11
Headcanon. Oda has been doing but showing us that ALL 4 Yonko (and maybe Akainu) are the roadblocks to PK, not just one person
There is no chance that BB will be defeated in a 4 way battle no matter how you look at it. He is one of the two ultimate villains (Imu the other) and they are destined to go down in a 1 v 1 against the mc.
 
#12
There is no chance that BB will be defeated in a 4 way battle no matter how you look at it. He is one of the two ultimate villains (Imu the other) and they are destined to go down in a 1 v 1 against the mc.
Nothing Im stating suggests Luffy cant or wont have a full 1v1 during this or by its end. Thats my point.
 
#14
The only battle royal I could see happening is Red hair pirates vs SHs vs Cross guild.
The issue is quite literally everyone has a connection to multiple people with their own agendas. Ive broken it down before but here:

- Luffy has ties to Shanks, Blackbeard and Akainu, for completely different reasons. He is bound to encounter all 3. Then Zoro to Mihawk. Then the entire concept of him and Imu potentially.
- Akainu plans on fighting on all fronts, and who knows what his stance will be after Kizaru. He and Luffy are pretty much destined to clash because of Ace. Ryokugyuu told Shanks its not "time yet for them to fight", which suggests the Marines intend to fight the RHP
- The RHP (rather Shanks) intends on finding Blackbeard AND going after Luffy's fleet members AND meeting Luffy. Shanks has clear ties to the Gorosei and WG.
- Blackbeard obviously intends on encountering Shanks and Luffy. Kuzan still has a lingering plot thread that may tie back to Akainu and the Marines.
- CG's current narrative thread is the 4th RP/One Piece, but Mihawk has direct ties to Shanks. They also seem to be the connective thread to all former Shichibukai (maybe).
- The WG plans on utilizing the Seraphim to combat the Yonko, this is something stated by Kaido. They are also mobilizing the God Knights for the RA. They are also using some massive weapon to destroy whole countries
- The RA obviously has ties to Luffy and the WG.

When you think of it this way, its hard to see how Oda resolves one faction without resolving at least 1 or 2 of the others. Like Kizaru alone is easy because his real narrative threads where with Vegapunk and Sentoumaru.
 
#15
Doesn’t work because Akainu has too much on his side for the other parties in that scenario.
It will inevitably end with either the pirates teaming up against his faction, or the Navy cleaning up the remnants of the pirates.
The battle royale idea works best with comparable forces.
 
#16
It ain't happening

It will be the typical trope :
Shs beat an enemy side on some island/territory. ..move the next

Side battles will happen on different islands
There won't be 4 way battle on one island between top tiers
 
#17
Doesn’t work because Akainu has too much on his side for the other parties in that scenario.
It will inevitably end with either the pirates teaming up against his faction, or the Navy cleaning up the remnants of the pirates.
The battle royale idea works best with comparable forces.
Marines fighting 4 Yonko who are also fighting each other is precisely the thing that works when you factor in that they have to fight everyone like everyone else.
 
#18
Marines fighting 4 Yonko who are also fighting each other is precisely the thing that works when you factor in that they have to fight everyone like everyone else.
As others have said, I think that’s far too much of a clusterfuck for Oda to hope to handle.

Maybe it could be the complete opposite of Wano and Oda ends up pleasantly surprising me beyond expectation, but I’ve lost that level of optimism.
I still think it best for the pirates to resolve things between themselves with other factions coming in afterwards.
 
#19
As others have said, I think that’s far too much of a clusterfuck for Oda to hope to handle.

Maybe it could be the complete opposite of Wano and Oda ends up pleasantly surprising me beyond expectation, but I’ve lost that level of optimism.
I still think it best for the pirates to resolve things between themselves with other factions coming in afterwards.
My only issue with this is Ryokugyuu explicitly stating its not yet time for the Marines to fight the RHP (i.e. possibly extending to all Yonko).

Not sure how Oda would approach it. But i can imagine it being a clusterfuck that lasts 200 chapters unfortunately lol
 
#20
Four Way Battle Royale

Top Tiers

Luffy, Shanks, Teach, Sakazuki

YC1s

Zoro, Ben, Shiryu, Mihawk (CG substitute)

YC2s

Sanji, Lucky, Kuzan, Aramaki

YC3s

Yasopp, Avalo, Crocodile (CG Substitute), Issho


EPIC!!!!

EDIT: Extras

YC4s

Jinbe, Howling Gab, Sanjuan Wolf, Brown Pig

YC5s

Robin, Bonk Punch, Devon, Pink Rabbit

YC6s

Franky, Building Snake, Jesus, Black Horse

YC7s

Brook, Lime-Juice, Vasco, Snake

YC8s

Chopper, Monster, Doc Q, Sheep

YC9s

Nami, Hongo, Laffe, Rat

YC10s

Usopp, Rockstar, Augur, Buggy

 
Last edited:
Top