General & Others What do you guys think off the Native Genocide tournament as a concept

[zzShinichi]

A fairly wholesome activity, after living in the states for a year I'm all for this

You get exercise, experience, education, and you're helping out the country they come from since they aren't a drain on the resources anymore.

If you did this with a few of those Baltimore gangs you could make enough to pay for that entire bridge that just collapsed.

 

[JoNdule]

Well the fact that there's a genocide tournament rape child murder and torture and Luffy is to dumb to understand it and so uncaring that he'll never mention it just make me feel detached from it

As long as Luffy is having fun, that's all Oda care for

 

[Herrera95]

I think it is purposeless and adds little to nothing into history. WG really fighting a kingdom and making it to submit would make more sense

 

[RayanOO]

or why not making a game but more like God valley being a tournament place where CD or Holy knights are fighting different opponents (slaves from different races etc) in an arena, gladiator style etc

 

[Borasey79]

If the powers now governing the world treat humans as insects, openly hunting them down, raping and killing them, I think it renders the whole Ancient Kingdom deal less black and white. Rayleigh said that after landing on Rafter, the SHs may reach a different conclusion than the one the Roger Pirates came to. But how can you reach a different conclusion than the "we need to defeat the literal demons now controling the world" unless the AK, too, was demonic in origin?

 

[Johnny B. Decent]

I think I would have gone for it bring 10 years annually, if not more. Doing it every three years seems like it would chew up a lot of islands.

 

[DavyJones]

Human hunts happened IRL, I see no reason why the WG wouldn't have them. IF ANYTHING, it makes perfect sense considering how they view non-CDs as less than human.

"We already knew they were evil why more focus":

Because a large contingent of the fandom refused to believe the Celestial Dragons raped their slaves, and Oda had to literally bring it into the main story for them to accept it. Not only do they genocide- it is a regular occurrence. Ohara wasn't special.

So clearly, we DIDNT know how evil they were.

 

[zenox]

goldy pond incident is what i can say

 

[IsaziSempi]

I can't say I hate the idea just hate the way it came about. It's silly reveals like this is why we haven't seen the straw hats training and fighting and getting better. I mean other than Luffy the straw hats have about one fight a piece. Also it's a cheap way to make Luffy relevant strenghtwise among the big three and dbz.

 

[Thaidakar]

Unnecessary display of muh evil WG.

What I still don't get is, the WG itself isn't a bad thing. Just remove the obvious and unnecessary injustices and treat people somewhat decent or give them a feeling of doing so, and everything's fine.

Such truly unnecessary activities just bring the mob together and creates more and more revos.

It's almost like they want people to revolt. The general concept of the WG with all its forced atrocities makes them seem very artificial and surreal.

 

[Cruxroux]

It's One piece world of Population control because Nika Took all the condoms

 

[trav]

It made the WG seem very inconsistent.
Its pointlessly cruel. And why do they not do it more often against any nation that rebels?

Right now the power balance in OP is weird to nonsensical.

 

[Buusatan94]

Oda has already made the Celestial Dragons and WG cartoonishely evil to an absurd degree, nothing new or necessary.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Unnecessary display of muh evil WG.

What I still don't get is, the WG itself isn't a bad thing. Just remove the obvious and unnecessary injustices and treat people somewhat decent or give them a feeling of doing so, and everything's fine.

Such truly unnecessary activities just bring the mob together and creates more and more revos.

It's almost like they want people to revolt. The general concept of the WG with all its forced atrocities makes them seem very artificial and surreal.

It's almost like in real life

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Unnecessary display of muh evil WG.

What I still don't get is, the WG itself isn't a bad thing. Just remove the obvious and unnecessary injustices and treat people somewhat decent or give them a feeling of doing so, and everything's fine.

Such truly unnecessary activities just bring the mob together and creates more and more revos.

It's almost like they want people to revolt. The general concept of the WG with all its forced atrocities makes them seem very artificial and surreal.

These are unafffliated nations it would be different if this was to a nation allied with the WG

 

[Thaidakar]

These are unafffliated nations it would be different if this was to a nation allied with the WG

Does it matter? It's still an unnecessary activity that certainly does not contribute to build a lasting empire.
I'd rather pay mercenaries to cause terror and mass murder in unaffiliated nations only to come up as the saviors afterwards and then claim those nations.

But they actively support cruelty and propagate that those fodder inbred CDs with 1,5 brain cells are rightful gods. The WG is breeding their own revo soldiers and gives them to Dragon's pitiful excuse of an army. It's not realistic at all.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Does it matter? It's still an unnecessary activity that certainly does not contribute to build a lasting empire.
I'd rather pay mercenaries to cause terror and mass murder in unaffiliated nations only to come up as the saviors afterwards and then claim those nations.

But they actively support cruelty and propagate that those fodder inbred CDs with 1,5 brain cells are rightful gods. The WG is breeding their own revo soldiers and gives them to Dragon's pitiful excuse of an army. It's not realistic at all.

oh yes it is