General & Others What do you love from One Piece?

Kizaruber Eats

THE KIZARUBER EATS, THE KIZARUBER EATS IS REAL!
#2
Hehe,

What do you love about One Piece specifically, it can eb a specific story or a theme,

Personally I really love the theme of freedom shown in Yamato and Kaido's relationship,

You can see what I mean by the theme of freedom with Yamato and Kaido's relationship here! =] : https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/yamatos-fight-is-so-beautiful.60326/
Just replying to bump your thread as it's sadly being neglected, not even the ones who constantly complain about negativity here have shown up to contribute to this actually positive thread curiously and sadly too.

I've got a huge list of what I love about one piece, even post timeskip stuff so I'm gonna get on my PC and really go all out in my actual proper reply to this ideally lol.

Some of my recent posts that actually praise and glaze Shanks and Luffy of all people but also my passionate Brook appreciation thread are examples of things I love in one piece but I have a very diverse (oh no forced diversity, it's woke! Will of DEI!) list of things I absolutely love about one piece, I hope you're ready for the essay lmfao!
 
#4
From the series in general:
- introduction panels carry so much weight it's insane. Even the most mundane character can look ad feel like a million bucks when that intro box is blasted underneath
- island designs
- devil fruits as a concept
- the silliness that switches to dread and suspense on the drop of a dime

From the anime in particular:
- character themes are great. Franky, Sanji, Zoro all have iconic themes imo
- the sound design can sometimes elevate moments to a new level; e.g. the ringing of the Golden Bell - amazing in the manga, but once you hear the bell it just pulls at your heart strings
- the voice acting (related to the previous one); example from the same arc - Noland and Calgara brought me to tears multiple times in that short flashback. Later we got great performances in the Rosinante/Law flashback as well that elevated it further
 
#7
Not story related but despite all the hate OP is my weekly (at least it was before all these non-stop breaks) routine and i like that.

OP reminds me of good and bad times that happened during my life.

Had my first girlfriend during Skypiea arc.
I graduated school during W7 arc.
My father passed away during EL arc.
Arrested for some bs during MF arc.
Graduated from university during FMI.
etc etc
 
#8
One Piece revolves around laughing, feeling good, connecting with your inner child and so on. Most authors can't build stories around positive emotions (which are way harder to work with than negative ones), therefore resorting to dramatic approaches (trauma, suffering, violence...) that may come off as edgy, first; and also mistakenly adult for the inexperienced public.

Not every author can handle heartwarming storytelling the way Oda does.
 

Kizaruber Eats

THE KIZARUBER EATS, THE KIZARUBER EATS IS REAL!
#9
Unfortunately I'm gonna have to give a shorter reply as my back and my internet are both giving me hell right now, gotta love it.

But yeah to reply to the thread properly, I love the unapologetic emotional authenticity of One Piece, where Oda will show characters ugly crying and really expression emotions and their feelings or w/e.

I actually find characters like Kinemon, Kuma, Bonney, Kyros maybe Rebecca too very compelling. I do hate Oda's fetishism for damsels and making girls cry a lot and be helpless but he does write some lovely, wholesome, likeable female characters too as well as male ones too ofc.

I love Oda's eccentricity and sense of humour, he has a very jovial perspective of the world, he kinda reminds me of Robin Williams and the way Oda can really make you laugh one minute then the next cry, the way he can transition between complete goofiness and pure seriousness, horror or any kind of major emotional gravitas generally is commendable.

Oda is extremely imaginative and intelligent, he does copy a LOT from other series but he does put his own uniquely weird charms on things and his worldbuilding is still phenomenal to say in the least.

I always rave on Thriller Bark, Skypeia, WCI, Alabasta, Water 7 etc but even the likes of Impel Down, Long Ring Long Island, Wano (especially Onigashima too), Zou (with Zunesha too ofc), Punk Hazard etc have some really cool, interesting world building and designs too.

Oda has created a series with hundreds of memorable characters imo. When I play One Piece games and I can explore all these islands, play all of these story arcs and relive those amazing moments, actually be part of the One Piece world and play as tons of my favourite characters, it actually makes me really happy, despite all my constant complains about Oda and One Piece and thus negativity on here.

There are lots of really subtle, wonderful, underrated things that Oda does throughout One Piece from beginning to now and in hindsight, I quite like the Hachinosu/Beehive mini arc with Garp, Kuzan, Koby etc a lot now actually, especially after the anime and Toei went so all out gloriously with Garp, Kuzan and Koby too too which always helps.

I really love the backstories Oda writes for people too, he writes these absolutely tragic, compelling, enticing backstories that are so powerful and memorable and easily could be entire stories on their own for other series or w/e.

When I started out with One Piece, I fell in love with every single new Strawhat as well as various characters like Shanks, Mihawk, the Admirals, Smoker, Tashigi, the Supernovas, Bon Clay, Galdino, Buggy etc and a lot of that hasn't really changed even now. They are all like individual and thus absolutely pivotal ofc pieces of the grandest, most spectular jigsaw piece puzzle. All the elements that make the puzzle what it is in the first place and without each piece, the puzzle will be incomplete and thus not truly feel whole or "One Piece" you could say!

Oda really preaches the importance of acceptance despite where you come from, who you are, to not demonise someone for who their fathers/mothers were and thus heritages or who they were associated with or what they look like or w/e. He also preaches the concept of forgiveness, grief and thus moving on, sacrifice and such which are all things I feel extremely strongly about personally and really respect how Oda handles it.

That recent fan letter episode felt like a reminder, a nod to what we love about One Piece, these individual, compelling character stories and perspectives in such a vast, insane, chaotic, complex, nuanced world and a microcosm of what we experience IRL, both feeling like our lives and self are extremely important on a personal scale BUT also realising how our own world, our planet, the universe/solar system, time are so much bigger, powerful, more complex and such beyond what ever we may truly ever understand, explain and truly control and comprehend if that makes sense?

Even though One Piece has changed a lot, there is still that childlike innocence to it and that is especially evident with Gear 5 ofc but also Odas writing and focus on characters like Shirahoshi, Rebecca, Tama, Toko, Momonosuke, Bonney and so on. One Piece is very much a "Peter Pan" style series for better and for worse and I've always been drawn to Japan and anime for those reasons too, that sense of adventure, wonder and escapism as well as embracing the inner child and nurturing it.

Oda manges to interweave hundreds of compelling stories both small and big, grand and simple into One Piece. To do this for almost 30 years too and will be over 30 easily, closer to 40 years by the time its over at least is INSANE and a truly GIGANTIC feat ofc! Monumentous!

Also to add on a side note, I'm so happy the Kuma and Bonney storyline ended so happily. On a personal level, I really love all these adoptive parent storylines like with Dadan (who I adore and think is fantastically witten especially post Marineford too), Belle-mere, Zeff, Kinemon, Kyros (although he turned out to be her actual father ofc), Kuma etc ofc and when he wants to, Oda can really write and draw some heartwrenching, absolutely shocking, unforgettable storylines, moments and panels.

Oda is the kind of guy to make you really understimate him then deliver the most shocking twists/gut punches/horror/tragedies etc and writes like he has lived for even maybe several lifetimes already, that he's an old man (much older than he is now I mean) and has absolutely tons of stories to recount from and such from an extremely long and varied life with many ups and downs, triumphs and losses, many complexities and difficult dilemmas, challenges and moral conondrums etc.

Odas writing is like an encyclopedia itself gained sentience or even the internet and he's just trying to share everything he knows with us as much as he possibly can. It's like seeing a million futures/timelines and trying to recount them all, to tell everyone everything you saw somehow.

Also I asked ChatGPT for some ideas on what makes One Piece so great and this is what I got too, very happy with the results!:

Nuanced, Specific, and Underrated Aspects of One Piece:
  1. Thematic Repetition with Evolution: One Piece often revisits themes of freedom, inherited will, and dreams, but these aren’t repeated the same way each time. In arcs like Alabasta, Dressrosa, and Wano, we see how the theme of freedom evolves based on the context and characters involved. It’s a subtle technique that provides continuity while showing Luffy’s growth.

  2. The Passing of the Torch: The concept of "inherited will" is a cornerstone of the series, not just among prominent characters but also among seemingly minor ones. This is seen in arcs where even small actions, like Zoro’s homage to Ryuma in Wano or Law carrying Corazon’s ideals, show how previous generations continue to influence the new. This idea is felt through symbolic gestures rather than explicit storytelling.

  3. Hidden Character Development Through Silence: Characters like Nico Robin, Zoro, and Jinbei communicate their emotions or backstories without overt exposition. Robin’s silence during her time with Baroque Works, contrasted against her vulnerability in Enies Lobby, is a masterclass in non-verbal character progression. Similarly, Jinbei’s few words often carry the weight of someone burdened by past guilt.

  4. Political Underpinnings and Social Commentary: One Piece deftly explores political corruption, authoritarian regimes, and the nature of governance. Take Dressrosa’s critique of dictatorship or Alabasta’s reflection on rebellion and loyalty. This isn’t front-and-center like a lecture, but Oda threads these themes throughout, giving the series depth beyond its surface-level adventure narrative.

  5. Geopolitical Dynamics and World-Building Consistency: The political system of the World Government, Shichibukai, and Revolutionary Army is built with meticulous detail. Things like the marine ranking system, bounty issuance, or the territorial politics of the New World contribute to a feeling that the world is functioning and alive beyond the Straw Hat Pirates’ adventures.

  6. Non-linear Character Development: Unlike traditional shonen, where characters receive power-ups in a predictable sequence, One Piece excels in non-linear character growth. Sanji’s evolution in Whole Cake Island isn’t just about gaining power but confronting his family and childhood trauma. Usopp’s gradual acceptance of his own weaknesses and embracing his role through smaller moments, like his introspection in Enies Lobby, stand as nuanced character journeys.

  7. Complex Villains with Intricacies Beyond Evil: Characters like Doflamingo, Crocodile, and Katakuri aren’t simply "bad guys." Oda gives them ambitions, philosophies, and pasts that tie into the larger themes of the series. Katakuri’s rigid honor code or Doflamingo’s twisted ideology of control complicates the standard hero-villain dynamic.

  8. The Unseen Story Between the Story: Characters often react to off-panel events that influence how we perceive their motivations or choices. The implications of the Void Century, the elusive Revolutionaries, or even minor events like Jinbei’s internal conflict upon resigning as a Warlord, create a sense of an ever-moving narrative, even when it’s not explicitly shown.

  9. The Straw Hat Crew’s Relationship with Each Other: Unlike other series where camaraderie is taken for granted, One Piece takes the time to explore relationships within the crew. Sanji’s silent recognition of Zoro’s pain after Thriller Bark, or Luffy and Usopp’s bittersweet reconciliation post-Water 7, show their bonds in understated yet meaningful ways.

  10. Symbolism in Character Designs: Character appearances in One Piece are packed with symbolic meaning. Luffy’s scar and Straw Hat, Zoro’s swords with their histories, and Nami’s tattoo aren’t just superficial details but symbols that carry history, trauma, and inherited legacies.

  11. Imperfect, Grounded Reactions to Trauma: One Piece allows characters to cope in flawed, realistic ways. Take Nami’s breakdown in Arlong Park, where she stubbornly denies help until she’s emotionally broken, or Sanji’s flawed coping mechanisms in Whole Cake Island. Oda lets them be human, imperfect, and vulnerable.

  12. Nature as an Unpredictable Force: The sea is more than a backdrop; it’s a volatile, living character in the story. From sudden climatic shifts in the Grand Line to the unpredictable nature of the Calm Belt, the sea embodies both freedom and danger, reflecting the series’ larger themes.

  13. The Concept of “Justice” in Ambiguity: Oda doesn’t glorify a single perspective on justice. Characters like Akainu and Fujitora show opposing ideals within the same faction, creating a gray area that forces readers to question what true justice means. The nuances of marines and pirates make it clear there’s no clear-cut morality.

  14. Food and Cooking as Storytelling Devices: Sanji’s role as the cook isn’t just for comic relief. His cooking symbolizes care, comfort, and gratitude. His choice to feed Gin in Baratie marks a pivotal moment that embodies his values and sets up future dilemmas about feeding an enemy, emphasizing kindness beyond combat.

  15. Parallelism in Character Introductions: When we see how each Straw Hat crew member was introduced, there are thematic parallels reflecting Luffy’s leadership. They are all lonely misfits who find purpose with Luffy, echoing subtle mirroring arcs like Zoro’s with Kuina and Chopper’s with Hiluluk. These echoes reveal that each crew member is driven by similar losses and dreams.

  16. The "Found Family" Concept Reimagined: Rather than overly sentimental bonds, the Straw Hats’ unity is built on shared adventures and mutual understanding, often forged in the fire of intense conflicts. Their quiet moments—like a celebratory drink, a conversation under the stars, or Luffy’s confidence in his crew—show a deeper trust that’s earned, not inherited.

  17. Hidden Lore Hints and Foreshadowing: Oda often includes minute, cryptic details in the background that foreshadow future events or backstories. Things like the "Will of D," the mysteries of the Void Century, and the fleeting mentions of past pirates like Rocks D. Xebec create intrigue and invite theories. Long-running symbols like the "Sake Cups" in the context of promises further reinforce the idea of continuity and inherited legacy.

  18. The Repercussions of Miscommunication: The misunderstandings that arise among the crew, such as Usopp’s departure or Sanji’s behavior in Whole Cake Island, don’t feel contrived but rather reflect realistic conflicts among friends. Oda doesn’t shy away from depicting the messy reality of relationships, where pride and insecurity sometimes overshadow trust.

  19. Art and Humor Reflecting Tone Shifts: Oda uses shifts in art style and humor to signal changes in mood. For instance, Luffy’s exaggerated expressions shift to a more subdued tone during serious arcs, like in Sabaody Archipelago. This gradual escalation of intensity underscores major plot developments and emotional beats without needing words.

  20. Exploration of Legacy and Aging: Characters like Whitebeard, Garp, and Rayleigh serve as reminders of the passage of time and the weight of a pirate’s life. Whitebeard’s death isn’t just the end of an era but a haunting reminder of the inevitable transition of power and the cyclical nature of ambition.

    These nuanced elements make One Piece much more than just an adventure story, offering layers of subtext and characterization that contribute to its immersive and enduring appeal.


@Blax Blah Tysm for this thread, I've been meaning to make the same thread and some others but I've not been feeling as motivated lately for my own personal reasons as you know too ofc from our chats. This was a fun topic to think about and write, so I appreciate it too! We need some goodness like this here and there!


Not giving Kaido or BM awakening :josad:
I feel your pain always Kaibro.

:pepemy::peperain::pepecry::feelscryingman::pepemwai:


Never exploring during the actual Wano arc that Tama was a Kurozumi.
Completely agree with this. Oda could still have done it at the end of the arc especially with Hiyoris speech or in this cover story, but alas.

:emohiyo::zosleepy::tchpepe:


One Piece revolves around laughing, feeling good, connecting with your inner child and so on. Most authors can't build stories around positive emotions (which are way harder to work with than negative ones), therefore resorting to dramatic approaches (trauma, suffering, violence...) that may come off as edgy.

Not every author can handle heartwarming storytelling the way Oda does.
Bruh haha, I was writing similar just now, what a similar coincidence! Brilliantly said in such a concise way though ofc, I could not have said or worded it better myself! Completely agree 100%, Oda has an amazing perspective when it comes to things like this. I feel Hideaki Sorachi with Gin Tama is similar too and even Hiro Mashima with Fairy Tail, I adored these series for similar reasons to One Piece as we've both just mentioned and other reasons too.

Oda is definitely very much one of a kind. As much as I love other series and authors, Oda is just "built different" as the saying goes. Its no wonder he got called a top 10 genius in Japan too!


The idea about the world consisting of thousands of unique islands.

It leaves so much creative freedom and Oda generally delivers on his island themes/designs.
YES! This so much! This is one of the things I love about One Piece so much! Ever since I was a child, I was so IMMERSED and thus awestruck by games like Super Mario 64 and The Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask. Now who made those games.?...Nintendo ofc! And thus the Japanese! Japanese creativity and that ability to enrich our inner children and give us that sense of wonder, absurdism, so much fantastical creativity is just something else entirely! Maybe not even of this world!

I LOVED exploring the worlds of these games and when I got into One Piece and thus also got to try out those games of it, it gave me those same feeling as I had as a child and it made me want to explore and be part of these worlds too!

I have to give Oda so much respect for that. Kishis world building/design is also very good in Naruto too imo but it was kinda held back as Kishi decided against focusing on the other countries and thus the rest of the world, he outright admitted he didn't want to copy what Oda and One Piece were doing and thus limited what Naruto would be like and whaty style of story it was, its direction it would go in on purpose out of respect to Oda and One Piece too.

From the series in general:
- introduction panels carry so much weight it's insane. Even the most mundane character can look ad feel like a million bucks when that intro box is blasted underneath
- island designs
- devil fruits as a concept
- the silliness that switches to dread and suspense on the drop of a dime

From the anime in particular:
- character themes are great. Franky, Sanji, Zoro all have iconic themes imo
- the sound design can sometimes elevate moments to a new level; e.g. the ringing of the Golden Bell - amazing in the manga, but once you hear the bell it just pulls at your heart strings
- the voice acting (related to the previous one); example from the same arc - Noland and Calgara brought me to tears multiple times in that short flashback. Later we got great performances in the Rosinante/Law flashback as well that elevated it further
Amen man, that is such a GREAT point about the introduction panels too, Oda really delivers on that! Its fantastic presentation and I saw a thread on Piratefolk recently praising this too and asking who had the best introductions too. It really makes the series feel more theatrical, epic and spectacular.

I LOVE devil fruits as a concept so much too, such a great point too!

YES OMG, those 3 guys have such AWESOME theme songs and I LOVE the character songs that the VAs have done too! The vocal songs you can find of the VAs doing their own theme songs for each characters like this one for example:


Fujitoras, Doflamingos, Akainus songs go SO HARD! But some others like Namis, Robins, Choppers etc are so sweet! I love the voice actors of Japan especially series like One Piece so much and its funny how some of them are like their OP characters IRL and have such amazing chemistry, wholesome personalities, boundless passion/enthusiasm/energy and such!

Oda meeting Luffys live action actor and that reaction from each other and the hug was extremely wholesome too. The live action cast are spectacular and have grown on me immensely, some of them like Zeff, Mihawk and Garp have embodied their characters so well, (Zeff is Ghost from Call of Duty apparently too!) and seeing their dedication to the role and the effort put in especially with Zoro and Sanjis actors for example or the very undetrated and overhated actor for Arlong (ive been seeing a lot of people slander live action Arlong/his actor elsewhere which infuriates me as I think he was phenomenal) and even though the live action isn't as funny, absurd, goofy, silly as the actual anime (you can only do so much with live action too ofc), I still love the live action and I'm glad for it existing and thus being a thing.

God knows the composer for the LA did a phenomenal job too and hearing We Are included in the soundtrack and also the amazing Aurora doing such an extremely emotional, beautiful and fitting theme song for Nami is so WONDERFUL and far better than how Disney treated Aurora for Frozen ironically!

I could keep going and going but I won't yet haha. Always plenty more I could and may say in future ofc! You guys get the idea anyway and thank you guys for replying to the thread and giving some actual life and feedback to it too! I really enjoyed reading your replies too!

(I'm in a sort of wholesome mood whilst it lasts lmao, however long or more briefly really that it lasts too haha. Threads like this help though for sure! A real change of pace, breath of fresh air for once.)

:BigW::holdw::lusnipe::rosismile:
 
#15
A lot of the characters are very compelling and fun, I also really love the designs of them (for example Enel's as seen in my current pfp), and Oda was surprisingly very great at writing backstories and development for characters.
But even characters who's backstories we don't know yet, like Crocodile and Mihawk, are still pretty interesting and likeable.
And the fight choreography and art in the manga was pretty good, it still is sometimes but not as much as it was back in Enies Lobby or Marineford.
 
#18
- The basic concept of Straw hats sailing around the world having adventures and fun while doing all that.

- Each island offers unique landscapes and introduces dozens of new characters.

- Character designs are crazy and funny .

- Hot babes .

- Oda does not take manga itself too seriously .
 
Top