Questions & Mysteries What if Kidd beat Shanks , Law beat Blackbeard, and Luffy beat Kizaru ?

[AkainuTheGrimReaper]

Let say if oda draw Kidd beat shanks, law beat Blackbeard, and luffy beat kizaru as result .
How the fanbase react as oda want to draw captain trio rival beating top tier battle in 1vs1 fight ?

Post automatically merged: Mar 1, 2023

I would say it is bad writing but let peopke discuss if actually happen .

 

[Sugoi]

the fanbase hates admirals, so they would like luffy beating kizaru
the fanbase loves yonkos so they would hate kid and law winning

thankfully oda doesnt care about just doing what the fans want

 

[PurpleSwordsman]

Why discuss about smth that won't happen?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Why discuss about smth that won't happen?

People discussed ZKK for years, let people discuss, it's a forum.

 

[PurpleSwordsman]

People discussed ZKK for years, let people discuss, it's a forum.

Well yes, but that was done as a theory after all, so from that pov it's not a problem.

But this here is nothing.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Well yes, but that was done as a theory after all, so from that pov it's not a problem.

But this here is nothing.

This is a very very unprobable theory, just like ZKK after the king fight.

 

[PurpleSwordsman]

This is a very very unprobable theory, just like ZKK after the king fight.

A "what if?" it's a theory?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

A "what if?" it's a theory?

I am not really interested in discussing semantics, but I would broadly say a weak yes.

 

[Mr. Tuna Sandwich]

the fanbase hates admirals, so they would like luffy beating kizaru
the fanbase loves yonkos so they would hate kid and law winning

thankfully oda doesnt care about just doing what the fans want

Speak for yourself!
Admiral Gang > Yankers

 

[milluki]

Luffy beats Akainu and Kid beats Kuzan next.

 

[The Buddha]

Luffy defeating kizaru would be normal

But Kid defeating Shanks would be the maximum decline of Oda and it would make me laugh a lot

The only one who possibly doesn't have a chance is Law but because the plot is in favor of neckbeard nothing else

 

[Herrera95]

Post automatically merged: Mar 2, 2023

Luffy defeating kizaru would be normal

Defeating Aokiji, Greenbull, Fujitora, Akainu would be normal.

Not Kizaru.

 

[BigAmmi]

And Buggy PK

 

[Paperchampion23]

Let say if oda draw Kidd beat shanks, law beat Blackbeard, and luffy beat kizaru as result .
How the fanbase react as oda want to draw captain trio rival beating top tier battle in 1vs1 fight ?

Post automatically merged: Mar 1, 2023

I would say it is bad writing but let peopke discuss if actually happen .

It would be pretty terrible considering all of the narrative build up these 2 actually have for One Piece vs Law and Kid have very little outside of being Luffy's allies. That said, its not happening anyway lol. I could be the biggest Yonko hater/Admiral shill ever, and Id still say the same shit.

 

[JoNdule]

Law won't beat Teach
Impossibke due to narratives and plot

Kid and Luffy on the other hand have chances to win

Luffy definitely wins against kizaru
Kid might win If he gest adcoc + another PU or lil help

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

story dropping stuff
Blackbeard and the admirals are two top reasons I still read one piece

when villains simply dont seem that exciting
the story is done.

 

[NAMELESS]

story dropping stuff
Blackbeard and the admirals are two top reasons I still read one piece

when villains simply dont seem that exciting
the story is done.

I hope Shanks turns out to be a villain after all.

 

[TEACH D TEACH]

2 of the 3 wont happen for sure, Shanks and Blackbeard are too important for the plot and Law and Kidd cant compete with Luffy without some HEAVY reinforcements, so they will be stopped here

 

[NAMELESS]

2 of the 3 wont happen for sure, Shanks and Blackbeard are too important for the plot and Law and Kidd cant compete with Luffy without some HEAVY reinforcements, so they will be stopped here

yeah,they are fighting just to give road ponegplyphs for the real antagonists.

 

[R A I T E I I I]

Luffy will beat Kizaru. He showcased he can catch lightning. He will catch kizarus light form. I think it's the only character able to defeat him bar Imu.