Current Events What would you rate Wano so far? and how does it fit in with your ranking of all the arcs in OP?
- Thread starter KINGKONGGUN15
- Start date
Wano 5.5
Story and Themes- 8/10
Execution- 3/10
Overall- 5.5/10
1. Alabasta 10/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 10/10
2. Skypia 10/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 10/10
3. Water 7 10/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 10/10
4. Enies Lobby 9/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 9/10
5. Arlong Park 9/10
Story and Themes 9/10
Execution 9/10
6. Sabody 8/10
Story and Themes 6/10
Execution 10/10
7. Marineford 7/10
Story and Themes 9/10
Execution 5/10
8. Impel Down 7/10
Story and Themes 6/10
Execution 8/10
9. Thriller Bark 7/10
Story and Themes 8/10
Execution 6/10
10. Zou 7/10
Story and Themes 4/10
Execution 10/10
11. Dressrosa 6.5/10
Story and Themes 9/10
Execution 4/10
12. Reverie 6.5/10
Story and Themes 5/10
Execution 8/10
Story and Themes- 8/10
Execution- 3/10
Overall- 5.5/10
1. Alabasta 10/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 10/10
2. Skypia 10/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 10/10
3. Water 7 10/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 10/10
4. Enies Lobby 9/10
Story and Themes 10/10
Execution 9/10
5. Arlong Park 9/10
Story and Themes 9/10
Execution 9/10
6. Sabody 8/10
Story and Themes 6/10
Execution 10/10
7. Marineford 7/10
Story and Themes 9/10
Execution 5/10
8. Impel Down 7/10
Story and Themes 6/10
Execution 8/10
9. Thriller Bark 7/10
Story and Themes 8/10
Execution 6/10
10. Zou 7/10
Story and Themes 4/10
Execution 10/10
11. Dressrosa 6.5/10
Story and Themes 9/10
Execution 4/10
12. Reverie 6.5/10
Story and Themes 5/10
Execution 8/10
Well the ranking depends on my mood so it might be diffrent from the rankings i posted before anyway
1: Water 7 + Enies lobby
2: Alabasta
3: Jaya + Skypiea
4: Marinford
5: Shabody
6: Dressrosa
7: Reverie
8: Zou
9: Imple down
10: Arlong Park
11: Thriller bark
12: Wcl
13: Fishman island
14: Wano
And the rating would a 4/10
Absolute dogshit
It had a few nice chapters with the time travel and Oden flashback ( atleast the middle part with Wb and Roger ) and also the outside world inbetween the acts but the rest is garbage
1: Water 7 + Enies lobby
2: Alabasta
3: Jaya + Skypiea
4: Marinford
5: Shabody
6: Dressrosa
7: Reverie
8: Zou
9: Imple down
10: Arlong Park
11: Thriller bark
12: Wcl
13: Fishman island
14: Wano
And the rating would a 4/10
Absolute dogshit
It had a few nice chapters with the time travel and Oden flashback ( atleast the middle part with Wb and Roger ) and also the outside world inbetween the acts but the rest is garbage
Last edited:
Not only is it too soon, but the whole thing has to be re evaluated once it finished because are things we've already seen that don't work without the full picture.
So far I think it's the best arc after Water Seven though. Better in many ways, just not as tight and immediately satisfying. Like it's almost ten volumes and we haven't seemed to march toward the end.
So far I think it's the best arc after Water Seven though. Better in many ways, just not as tight and immediately satisfying. Like it's almost ten volumes and we haven't seemed to march toward the end.
My rate will probably change after the fighting, the real fighting start. We haven't reached the climax yet.
So obviously Wano isn't really high in my ranking. So far I give it a 5/10, it can go higher or lower depending on what follows.
Lots of things I didn't like and but also few that I enjoyed.
1. Enies Lobby/ Water 7 (9,5/10)
2. Skypiea/Alabasta (9)
3. Alabasta/ Skypiea (9)
4. Impel Down (8,5)
5. WCI (8)
6. Arlong Park (8)
7. Sabaody (7,5)
8. Thriller Bark (7,5)
9. Dressrosa (7)
10. Marineford (7)
While I liked arc like Little Garden, Reverie and Zou, I didn't include them because they were very short.
So obviously Wano isn't really high in my ranking. So far I give it a 5/10, it can go higher or lower depending on what follows.
Lots of things I didn't like and but also few that I enjoyed.
1. Enies Lobby/ Water 7 (9,5/10)
2. Skypiea/Alabasta (9)
3. Alabasta/ Skypiea (9)
4. Impel Down (8,5)
5. WCI (8)
6. Arlong Park (8)
7. Sabaody (7,5)
8. Thriller Bark (7,5)
9. Dressrosa (7)
10. Marineford (7)
While I liked arc like Little Garden, Reverie and Zou, I didn't include them because they were very short.
Wano is the best bow in the world, thanks for the post, the pirates of the beasts are awesome and funny, and kaido is the badass.
Nobody will touch my subordinate from now on ...
Kaido and Jack.
Nobody will touch my subordinate from now on ...
Kaido and Jack.
Not 1 but 2 Yonkos in one arc, 1 with his complete crew
New nakama(s)
Strongest alliance Luffy can get in 1 arc until now (compare scabbards and Marco vs the likes of Dressrosa gladiators, Franky Family or Alabasta warriors)
8 out of 11 Supernovas involved in the arc
Flashback has Roger Pirates and Whitebeard Pirates on it and centered on former Roger Pirates who had seen Raftel and married someone from Void Century
The enemies being a crew filled with Zoan users, and led by a Mythical zoan user
Sounds very great on paper. But the execution is meh
New nakama(s)
Strongest alliance Luffy can get in 1 arc until now (compare scabbards and Marco vs the likes of Dressrosa gladiators, Franky Family or Alabasta warriors)
8 out of 11 Supernovas involved in the arc
Flashback has Roger Pirates and Whitebeard Pirates on it and centered on former Roger Pirates who had seen Raftel and married someone from Void Century
The enemies being a crew filled with Zoan users, and led by a Mythical zoan user
Sounds very great on paper. But the execution is meh
How can anyone look at this and not give a 10/10?
I can't find a single thing that is messed when I look at each drawing. I'm not an expert but at the end of the day it's only the eye of the overall beholder that matters.