Speculations Which of these 5 defeated Kaido in the past?

Who defeated Kaido?


  • Total voters
    23
#26
Kaido thought that he himself was Joyboy.

Besides, if that’s really what happened, you’d think that we’d see a flashback of Shanks telling Kaido he can fight Joyboy in the near future during the Kaido vs Nika fight…
Sry I thought being joyboy was actually not strength-related
:sanmoji:
 
#29
If Shanks won then Kaido’s title becomes pointless and he’d be either an idiot or amnesiac to still think he’s the strongest. That goes for King as well.
It was said to just be a scuffle, also I don't see how Shanks could win but not even scar Kaido or anything. Unless he has some technique where he can KO someone with a move that has less power than Ashura..
 
#30
He probably lost to Roger, WB and Rocks when he was young, or maybe he admired their strength and wanted to challenge them. Oden sort of defeated him but Kaido won because of cheap shot. And he had a skirmish with Shanks which made Kaido accept him as someone on the level of all those guys who had passed away.
 
#31
Xebec, Whitebeard and Roger all make sense.

We see Oden lost even if it was through trickery. If Shanks won then Kaido’s title becomes pointless and he’d be either an idiot or amnesiac to still think he’s the strongest. That goes for King as well.
Kaido would have died if the hag didn’t interfere. Kaido definitely considers it a defeat

I think Shanks and Kaido might have had a CoC clash, rather than a full on fight, to decide who goes to MF, and Shanks won that clash
 
#33
This is disingenuous though because the agenda can be pushed either way. On panel only Oden sort of defeated Kaido, same Oden didn't think WB or anybody could defeat Kaido until Joy boy.

Saying WB, Roger or Rocks defeated Kaido with certainty would be pure agenda since it never happened on panel and there is zero evidence for it. Also nobody can use an early defeat to define prime power level.
 
#34
Many Characters can Defeat Kaidou who isn't in his Prime yet
When Someone believes that only some Child of Prophecy can Defeat them, it means They are referring to when They are at their Prime,
Kaidou isn't Stupid to believe No One can Defeat at any Moment in his Life, but He believed that when He finally reaches his Full Potential (Prime), then No One can Defeat him

Xebec, Roger, WB & Oden are proven to not have Fought Kaidou in his Prime
And his Meeting with Shanks was Quick suggesting that They didn't actually Fight, but Shanks proved that He has Roger's Level of Haki & Skills

So those Five represent Fighters whom Kaidou met & He believes They were/are Joy Boy Candidates.
As for who Defeated his Non-Prime Version among them? Probably Xebec & WB + We've seen how He almost Died against Oden, and it's 50-50 whether He lost against Roger or not, He didn't lose against Shanks though
 
#36
Apart from Roger who was his enemy at God Valley I dont think any of those actually defeated him ( Oden was about to do it before old hag ) , but I doubt even Roger did it.
 

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
#38
Kaido thought that he himself was Joyboy.

Besides, if that’s really what happened, you’d think that we’d see a flashback of Shanks telling Kaido he can fight Joyboy in the near future during the Kaido vs Nika fight…
Hmmm true
 
#40
Kaido would have died if the hag didn’t interfere. Kaido definitely considers it a defeat

I think Shanks and Kaido might have had a CoC clash, rather than a full on fight, to decide who goes to MF, and Shanks won that clash
Kaido himself said “the victor needs no excuses” or something like it. He considers it a win regardless even if through dubious means.
If Kaido felt his CoC which he places above all was inferior to Shanks, he wouldn’t still be calling himself the strongest unless he had brain damage.
 
Top