Questions & Mysteries Which One Of The Sweet Commanders Did Kid fight?

Which one of the sweet commanders did Kid fought?

  • Total voters
    87
centurion

centurion

‎
#82
#82
Katakuri lost ONCE = didn't get demoted

Cracker lost ONCE = didn't get demoted

but Snack loses ONE time to Urouge and he IMMEDIATELY LOSES his rank? Wrong.

it would only be because he had previously lost against someone else too, making it the second time.

It also explains why he has a grudge with the Worst Generation in general and not just Urouge specifically...

Snack fought both Urouge and Kidd, and lost. The latter fight didn't get reported however and was kept secret.

 
L57

L57

‎
#83
#83
ReggieZoldyck21 said:
Oda just said that Kidd “defeated” the commander. I always said this even years ago. It makes no sense that Kidd was able to steal a poneglyph rubbing if all he did was injure him. Kidd had to have at least incapacitated him to get away.
Click to expand...
He didnt
He said he defeated some officers (ministers) while snack was the commander of the ship
Kidd himself stated "i injured one of her commander" not "i beat"
Pretty sure brule also said only urouge beat snack
 
Roo

Roo

‎
#85
#85
centurion said:
Katakuri lost once = didn't get demoted

Cracker lost once = didn't get demoted

but Snack loses ONE time to Urouge and he IMMEDIATELY loses his rank? Wrong.

it would only be because he had previously lost against someone else too, making it the second time.

It also explains why he has a grudge with the Worst Generation in general and not just Urouge specifically...

Snack fought both Urouge and Kidd, and lost. The latter fight didn't get reported however and was kept secret.

Click to expand...
The only reason why Brûlée was happy to talk about Urouge beating Snack was because she believed Cracker killed him.

If she knew he survived they would’ve also lied about it
Post automatically merged:

L57 said:
He didnt
He said he defeated some officers (ministers) while snack was the commander of the ship
Kidd himself stated "i injured one of her commander" not "i beat"
Pretty sure brule also said only urouge beat snack
Click to expand...
Oda literally said he beat Snack and Snack had to beg for his life.
 
centurion

centurion

‎
#88
#88
Roo said:
The only reason why Brûlée was happy to talk about Urouge beating Snack was because she believed Cracker killed him.

If she knew he survived they would’ve also lied about it
Click to expand...
Of course, this is a Yonko crew here and they DEEPLY care about their reputation.

They can't just let word get out that someone infiltrated their territory and survived. Its a bad look for them.

They need to set examples for everyone else to see, to intimidate the public and WG + Marines, even if they have to resort to lies.

 
Roo

Roo

‎
#89
#89
Warchief Sanji D Goat said:
Regardless, Kidd still beats Snack during the timeskip and got what he needed, so he's fine.

What I don't understand is that why did Snack carry the copy of the Poneglyph on his ship in the first place lol?

Man's just setting himself as an obvious bait at that point.
Click to expand...
The SBS makes no mention or Snack carrying it on his ship. In fact it sounds like Kid ordered Snack to steal it for him
 
park_min young

park_min young

‎
#90
#90
Roo said:
This keeps fueling my theory that Law had already met with the man with the burnt scar and got the rubbing from him :DeepThink:
Click to expand...
This is very possible but I don’t think he has it though, he just knows who it is maybe. Law’s been involved with a lot of shit like Rocky Port. He was a warlord and has been in the New World longer compared to the SHs, it’s not surprising that he gets a lot of info as a big name.
 
Juanpiz

Juanpiz

‎
#91
#91
park_min young said:
This is very possible but I don’t think he has it though, he just knows who it is maybe. Law’s been involved with a lot of shit like Rocky Port. He was a warlord and has been in the New World longer compared to the SHs, it’s not surprising that he gets a lot of info as a big name.
Click to expand...
Oda Never bothered to explain what the Navy did with the many hearts he gave to them:ihaha:
 
J

JoNdule

‎
#94
#94
centurion said:
Katakuri lost ONCE = didn't get demoted

Cracker lost ONCE = didn't get demoted

but Snack loses ONE time to Urouge and he IMMEDIATELY LOSES his rank? Wrong.

it would only be because he had previously lost against someone else too, making it the second time.

It also explains why he has a grudge with the Worst Generation in general and not just Urouge specifically...

Snack fought both Urouge and Kidd, and lost. The latter fight didn't get reported however and was kept secret.

Click to expand...
Snack was walking around with RP copies and gets beaten

BM can't accept that
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top