Character Discussion Who will be in Shanks' Top 5?

Who should be in Shanks' list?


  • Total voters
    31
#22
Kaido, Roger, Whitebeard, Mihawk,Blackbeard.


When Shanks and WB met, they split the sky and then Shanks went home. Why cant Kaido have done the same? We we told that there was a small fight.
When Shanks and WB met, Shanks went home because business is done and Moby Dick is not Shanks' home lol
When Shanks and Kaido met, Kaido wanted to go to Marineford but cancelled that immediately

He definitely has BB no DF in his top 5 :kobeha:

@Topi Jerami
Irrelevant
Shanks already made 2 DF Blackbeard + Impel Down new recruits + original crew who were rampaging non stop even with Sengoku and Garp's presence, suddenly went quiet and went home like good boys
Meanwhile Kaido wet his pants seeing Oden's subordinates 20 years later
Post automatically merged:

The fuck is Kaido doing here
His character is as important as Greenbull in Shanks' life

Shanks clearly respected Rayleigh more than Kaido
 

Fujishiro

Just chilling
#23
Maybe replace Blackbeard with Rayleigh Im not sure but either its:

Kaido, Whitebeard, Roger, Rayleigh and Mihawk

Or

Kaido, Whitebeard, Roger, Blackbeard and Mihawk.
 
#25
Maybe replace Blackbeard with Rayleigh Im not sure but either its:

Kaido, Whitebeard, Roger, Rayleigh and Mihawk

Or

Kaido, Whitebeard, Roger, Blackbeard and Mihawk.
Does Shanks view Whitebeard that high though?
This is what Buggy (aka Shanks' friend) said about Whitebeard:


Yet this is what Shanks does right in front of Whitebeard


Literally provoking him.
If Shanks does respect Whitebeard he wouldn't pull any of this. Will Shanks try to randomly KO Chopper and Sanji when he one day decides to visit the Straw Hats?
^
Shanks doesn't respect Whitebeard enough that he will put him in the Top 5. Kaido is just another Greenbull.

But imo he will put Luffy there, for whatever reason he is fanboying over Luffy. He got excited everytime he heard news about Luffy.
Kaido's Top 5 is about "high ceiling", Shanks already saw Luffy's potential in East Blue so he will think Luffy's ceiling in high.

Maybe depends at what time Shanks is thinking about Top 5. But currently he is already putting Luffy there because current Luffy already defeated Kaido.
 
#28
When Shanks and WB met, Shanks went home because business is done and Moby Dick is not Shanks' home lol
When Shanks and Kaido met, Kaido wanted to go to Marineford but cancelled that immediately


Irrelevant
Shanks already made 2 DF Blackbeard + Impel Down new recruits + original crew who were rampaging non stop even with Sengoku and Garp's presence, suddenly went quiet and went home like good boys
Meanwhile Kaido wet his pants seeing Oden's subordinates 20 years later
Post automatically merged:


The fuck is Kaido doing here
His character is as important as Greenbull in Shanks' life

Shanks clearly respected Rayleigh more than Kaido
BB was against marines also lol. Shanks is chasing BB as a result of BB ptsd
 
#29
BB was against marines also lol. Shanks is chasing BB as a result of BB ptsd
That's the point. He didn't back down from Marines, but immediately went home after seeing Shanks.

Yeah, sending a guy that just got his second DF + some new recruits from ID level 6 all home is surely result of PTSD :suresure:
This is real PTSD
 
#30
That's the point. He didn't back down from Marines, but immediately went home after seeing Shanks.

Yeah, sending a guy that just got his second DF + some new recruits from ID level 6 all home is surely result of PTSD :suresure:
This is real PTSD
Shanks still chasing BB to get revenge. BB no DF did a number on shanks :kobeha::kobeha:
Post automatically merged:

@Topi Jerami Snitch shanks had gorosei with him also :suresure:
 
#33
Stop ignoring the manga @Topi Jerami
Roger
Whitebeard
Kaido
Mihawk
Rayleigh/Oden/Garp
So surprisingly, no Kaido the so called World Strongest Creature in Shanks' Top 5. While in contrast, Kaido puts Shanks in his, right in the middle too.

Pretty clear that Kaido puts Shanks in his Top 5 list, not because of God Valley incident where Shanks was still young kid back then. But from on the way to Marineford incident, which fits Shanks' appearance in Kaido's Top 5 picture.

Whatever Shanks did to Kaido on his way to Marineford, that made Kaido quickly forgot whatever he was going to do at Marineford same way Greenbull quickly forgot whatever he was going to do at Wano. Then Shanks appeared in Marineford completely healthy, as healthy as post his encounter with Greenbull.
Sounds similar, probably that's what happened too between Shanks and Kaido 2 years ago? :kayneshrug:

Anyway, that event must have been 1 of the biggest, most important day in entire lifetime for someone like Kaido, who spent most of his days hiding in isolated Wano. He still remembers that incident and puts Shanks in his Top 5 list after 2 years later, same way he remembers Oden incident after 20 years later.

Meanwhile for someone like Shanks, whose lifetime filled with events like: shared drink with Mihawk the WSS, meeting with Ace the Roger's son, coming alone to Whitebeard ship and flexing his CoC by fainting Whitebeard's subordinates sons and split the sky, casually stopped Kaido and sent him home, casually stopped Akainu's attack to Coby, casually stopped War of The Best just by some serious words, casually made 2 DF Blackbeard and his newly recruited Impel Down crew who were rampaging non stop suddenly agreed to go home, casually knocked the door to Mariejois and have a chat with Gorosei, casually wifi diffed Greenbull and sent him home, then casually retired Kidd Pirates' career with single attack.

Yeah for man like Shanks, sending Kaido home is just another day not worth remembering into Top 5.

Thoughts? Agree with the list?
@Sasaki Kojirō
 
#35
I think the obvious 3 are Roger the guy he basically copied, mihawk his main rival, wb as the wsm and the guy that rivaled Roger.
After those 3 my guess is Rayleigh and kaido if it's current. By eos it'd be luffy and bb instead of kaido and Rayleigh.
 
#36
1. Roger, easy pick
2. Sea king, Lord of the Coast, losing an arm is no joke trauma.
3. BB, the one who gave his trademark scar.
4. White donut, the man that 100 years too early to order around
5. Buggy, still scared of him and running around to avoid Buddy asking for the lost treasure map.
 
Top