Questions & Mysteries Who will be the other 3 strawhats?

#1
With Roger's crew being confirmed to have 13-crew members as the core crew, SHPs which mirror that crew as evident by the whole Wings-concept. Who will be the remaining 3 strawhats?

1. Yamato, I think is a given at this point and is the likely one to be fighting Catarina Devon against the BBPs, by the time Elbaf gets finished her lil Oden's journey should be done too, and then on her way to link up with the SHPs.
2. ??
3. ??
 
#2
Yamato was left behind and oda is not in the business of back tracking. Unless she finds herself a ship and catches up to the SHs you can forget about her

also she read odens journal, she basically skipped the adventure part of the story. It never made sense to have someone like that in the crew
 

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
#8
With Roger's crew being confirmed to have 13-crew members as the core crew, SHPs which mirror that crew as evident by the whole Wings-concept. Who will be the remaining 3 strawhats?

1. Yamato, I think is a given at this point and is the likely one to be fighting Catarina Devon against the BBPs, by the time Elbaf gets finished her lil Oden's journey should be done too, and then on her way to link up with the SHPs.
2. ??
3. ??
1- Yamato- I alreasy consider her a member just because she isn't currently traveling with them doesn't mean she isn't a member of the crew, she just had a side quest to take care of, Jinbe technically joined end of wci but it wasn't made official till after he showed up in Wano

2- Loki- he was recently invited and it follows the same pattern as pretty much all the east blue strawhats, refuse, Luffy helps them out of a jam, they begin to trust Luffy and agree to help him I think Loki is going to follow this same pattern

3- ??? This is the one im not sure about but I can narrow it down to 3 candidates

A- Bonney- a cabin girl, Luffys apprentice and the one who'll inherit the strawhat next ? Possibly but the whole point of her becoming a pirate was finding and rescuing her father so this one is unlikely

B- Gunko? She has a connection with Brook and that connection may convince her to join us and having a semi-immortal with a pretty powerful ability on the crew would be neat however seeing that she has the Abyss Mark and she's likely much older than she looks its quite possible Imu kills her the same way she killed Saturn, imu did that to Saturn just for messing up, imagine the punishment for betrayal

C- Stussy- the third and most likely candidate she's strong but not to strong, she has inside information to the inner workings of mariejose having been a part of CP0 for so long and although Lucci claimed to have killed her we didnt actually see a body she could of escaped egghead I believe this is most likely but theres a low chance she really was killed by Lucci

So all n all

1- Yamato
2- Loki
3- Stussy
 
#10
FF: Bonney (weird but is oda alright)
I think Bonney is most likely fulfilling the Shanks role, so not part of the "main crew", as she's too young.

Since she's the only one who could replicate Luffy's strongest moves due to her DF. Much like Shanks replicating Divine Departure. She's the perfect apprentice for Luffy, of course there's also the Kuma-Dragon connection too.
 
Last edited:
#11
I could be wrong but im sure Luffy gave momo or Yamato a vivre card that leads people straight to the person they're looking for
He didn’t, he just gave them his flag. Next time we see the wano people it will likely be in their own ship in the final war
 
#12
FF: Bonney (weird but is oda alright)
PVC: Barto, Smoker or Law
Disgraced Royal: Sabo or Hancock
I figured Stussy was the perfect FF but after Egghead she seems narratively gone unfortunately.

PVC: Law works well. Only dark horses would be Bellamy and Loki

Royal I think Sabo works best
 
#13
I think Bonney is most likely fulfilling the Shanks role, so not part of the "main crew", as she's too young.

Since she's the only one who could replicate Luffy's strongest moves due to her DF. Much like Shanks replicating Divine Departure. She's the perfect apprentice for Luffy, of course there's also the Kuma-Dragon connection too.
How could she be the apprentice when they both set to sail at the same time?

They are both of the same generation as pirates and also age wise, age doesn’t matter in one piece

She will join as a core crew member
 

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
#14
He didn’t, he just gave them his flag. Next time we see the wano people it will likely be in their own ship in the final war
I mean Yamato made one for Ace and he wasn't even aware she had made it until she showed him so its not outside the realm of possibility that she makes one for Luffy or she took a piece of the one he already has off screen
 
#15
I figured Stussy was the perfect FF but after Egghead she seems narratively gone unfortunately.

PVC: Law works well. Only dark horses would be Bellamy and Loki

Royal I think Sabo works best
FF: Vivi could also fit into this as she was Ms Wednesday after all

On PVC: I’m torn between Smoker and Law, manly leaning towards Smoker because I don’t think Law needs to be in the crew to be in laugh tale and Smoker vs Kuzan is a very interesting matchup for the eventual SHP Vs BBP
 
#16
I figured Stussy was the perfect FF but after Egghead she seems narratively gone unfortunately.

PVC: Law works well. Only dark horses would be Bellamy and Loki

Royal I think Sabo works best
Bad, bad predictions, bad bad teenagers think they have the right to actually have an opinion
 
#18
I mean Yamato made one for Ace and he wasn't even aware she had made it until she showed him so its not outside the realm of possibility that she makes one for Luffy or she took a piece of the one he already has off screen
At that point we’re diving into headcanon to explain the inexplicable. With Jinbe we had an idea we’ll see him again because BM made an enemy out of Luffy and Jinbe was going to her. Yamato stayed behind and Luffy just offered her a seat if he ever went by Wano again
 

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
#19
At that point we’re diving into headcanon to explain the inexplicable. With Jinbe we had an idea we’ll see him again because BM made an enemy out of Luffy and Jinbe was going to her. Yamato stayed behind and Luffy just offered her a seat if he ever went by Wano again
Yamato stayed behind yes to fulfill her unnecessary Oden cosplay fantasy but once thats done then what? Is she just gonna hang around in wano? She's been wanting to go out to sea ever since she met Ace, and its not like members of a crew need to stay with the crew 24/7 we've seen crew members not with the crew, she'll finish what she needs finished in wano then catch up, and headcanon or not theres no reason to assume she didn't get a vivre card
 
Top