Controversial Who would you rather come back?

Who would you rather come back

  • Big Mom

    Votes: 24 58.5%

  • Kaido

    Votes: 17 41.5%
  • Total voters
    41
Yoho

Yoho

Your End is often Another's Beginning
‎
#1
#1
Kaido or Big Mom?

Personally I say big mom there was a lot of set up for her to be the main big bad of Elbaf given her recorded history of beef with the giants

Also Luffy even promised Katakuri to take her down and when luffy promises to beat someone he usually does

And the main reason I think big mom should come back over kaido

Kaidos story and arc is finished there isn't a legitimate reason to write kaido back in
 
C

Cruxroux

#2
#2
Both got good enough reasons tbh.
I'm more inclined towards Bigmam though , her flashback is still blurry , people say she ate mother Carmel but who knows , also giants are connected to Bigmam.
I thought she would play side Antagonist with amnesia in Elbaf.
 
Yoho

Yoho

Your End is often Another's Beginning
‎
#3
#3
Cruxroux said:
Both got good enough reasons tbh.
I'm more inclined towards Bigmam though , her flashback is still blurry , people say she ate mother Carmel but who knows , also giants are connected to Bigmam.
I thought she would play side Antagonist with amnesia in Elbaf.
Click to expand...
I think Kaido would only come back into the story via flashback most likely if we get a rocks full flashback
 
C

Cruxroux

#4
#4
Yoho said:
I think Kaido would only come back into the story via flashback most likely if we get a rocks full flashback
Click to expand...
I thought of another way , Seraphim Kaido , both king and Kaido were at same facility and Zoan fruit unlike Logia can be replicated , maybe there was a succesful version too.
So final war , Seraphim Kaido vs Momonusuke (ofc this would be no haki battle only DF showcase , momo might use same attack oden to end this)
 
Yoho

Yoho

Your End is often Another's Beginning
‎
#5
#5
Cruxroux said:
I thought of another way , Seraphim Kaido , both king and Kaido were at same facility and Zoan fruit unlike Logia can be replicated , maybe there was a succesful version too.
So final war , Seraphim Kaido vs Momonusuke (ofc this would be no haki battle only DF showcase , momo might use same attack oden to end this)
Click to expand...
Hmm yeah that is possible 🤔 tho I think there's a reason only the original 7 Shichibukai are seraphim why them specifically?

Are they actually the first 7 or are the just the first 7 we met
 
Malakhith

Malakhith

‎
#6
#6
Big Mom. She has the better backstory and character. Actually her younger version would be a perfect SH.

If Oda fix the shit he did in wano she would be amazing.
 
Malakhith

Malakhith

‎
#8
#8
Yoho said:
Elaborate, would she?
Click to expand...
Yeah. I mean the younger version that appeared in Kuma's flashback not the kid version.

She was funny and seemed way more cheerful than most characters. Even the way she acted with the kids was not extremely villain like. If this version appeared in the modern setting lots of people would want her as a SH (me included).

But I actually like BM (this is one of the reasons I hate wano).
 
Yoho

Yoho

Your End is often Another's Beginning
‎
#9
#9
Malakhith said:
Yeah. I mean the younger version that appeared in Kuma's flashback not the kid version.

She was funny and seemed way more cheerful than most characters. Even the way she acted with the kids was not extremely villain like. If this version appeared in the modern setting lots of people would want her as a SH (me included).

But I actually like BM (this is one of the reasons I hate wano).
Click to expand...
Big Mom is a good character with a lot of story left to tell
 
MonsterKaido

MonsterKaido

‎
#10
#10
Big mom. She was disappointing strength wise. Kaido had a bigger focus than BM so I feel more satisfied for him. Only that oda should have given him better back story.

Obviously I am biased towards Kaido so I want him to come back as well.
 
Last edited:
JDragon20

JDragon20

‎
#14
#14
It's tough. If Kaido comes back there's a big chance he'll become a joyboy fanboy but if big mom return she could hit her head and become o-lin again.

I'd still choose Big mom. She's a better character than Kaido, her territory is still mostly intact, she has beef with Elbaf, and Kaido coming back ruins his inglorious death that he received.
 
T

trav

‎
#15
#15
BM.
She has unfinished business with Elbaf and she has potential to be redeem.
The biggest reason for me is how much it would make many people seethe though.
The pure anger and dismay her returning would cause is well worth it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top