Questions & Mysteries Why did WB run from Garp but he did not run from Roger?

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Because like we've said 50,000 times before, he had to save Shakky so he couldn't fight Garp. Not to mention he typically avoids unnecessary fights anyway.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Damn you are getting more aggressive.

Again I am talking from WB POV not from Roger POV. What made WB ran from Garp but he did not run from Roger?

What happened on Roger mind was irrelevant. Sure he wanted to let Rayleigh to save Shakky. But what about WB mind? He did not care about Rayleigh. He wanted to save Shakky. Why didn't he run from Roger like how he ran from Garp?

Why didn't WB try to postpone or cooperate? You answered Roger did not want because of Rayleigh. How about WB?

I don't know. It's like Oda was trying to make both Roger and WB look bad.

Lol you're trolling even more now.
Run away from Roger to go where ?

 

[Scarred_Face]

Lol you're trolling even more now.
Run away from Roger to go where ?

Getting even more aggressive huh.

To save Shakky. Didn't he run from Garp to save Shakky too?

Because like we've said 50,000 times before, he had to save Shakky so he couldn't fight Garp. Not to mention he typically avoids unnecessary fights anyway.

Why didn't WB run from Roger to save Shakky too?

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Getting even more aggressive huh.

To save Shakky. Didn't he run from Garp to save Shakky too?


Why didn't WB run from Roger to save Shakky too?

Roger personally attacked him and wouldn't let him pass.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Because like we've said 50,000 times before, he had to save Shakky so he couldn't fight Garp. Not to mention he typically avoids unnecessary fights anyway.

He's obviously trolling but if he can ask the same question a thousand times, we can answer him a thousand times.

But this is probably someone's alt. The worst thing is that it's probably an alt of someone I appreciate reading when he's using his real account.

 

[Scarred_Face]

Roger personally attacked him and wouldn't let him pass.

Garp also attacked WB personally. Why did not WB try to run from Roger too? At least he tried. WB was not trying to run from Roger. He was seen trying to run from Garp.

He's obviously trolling but if he can ask the same question a thousand times, we can answer him a thousand times.

But this is probably someone's alt. The worst thing is that it's probably an alt of someone I appreciate reading when he's using his real account.

How old are you? Are you 12? When did I try to attack you?

I'm still trying to figure out why didn't WB run from Roger to save Shakky. You still have not given me convincing arguments.

Why cannot WB just run? Why? What's wrong? Care to explain?

 

[Garp the Fist]

Geography and timing, from the looks of things.

When they clash with Garp it looks like the Rocks Pirates are outside the valley that God’s Valley is named after, in the forest area.

The Hunting Games seems to have started from right in the centre of the valley.

We see from the map a few pages later that the Roger and Rocks Pirates both end up getting funnelled right into the Valley to where the Hunting Games take off, and clashing right where all their goals (Shakky, treasure) are, which is also an enclosed location with very few exits.

 

[Luffy is the mc]

How old are you? Are you 12? When did I try to attack you?

I'm still trying to figure out why didn't WB run from Roger to save Shakky. You still have not given me convincing arguments.

Why cannot WB just run? Why? What's wrong? Care to explain?

Yeah, see you dude. Use your real account next time.

 

[Scarred_Face]

Yeah, see you dude. Use your real account next time.

Why didn't WB try to run from Roger?

Geography and timing, from the looks of things.

When they clash with Garp it looks like the Rocks Pirates are outside the valley that God’s Valley is named after, in the forest area.

The Hunting Games seems to have started from right in the centre of the valley.

We see from the map a few pages later that the Roger and Rocks Pirates both end up getting funnelled right into the Valley to where the Hunting Games take off, and clashing right where all their goals (Shakky, treasure) are, which is also an enclosed location with very few exits.

What stopping WB to run from Roger to save Shakky? What do you mean few exits? Care to show the images where there are few exits for WB to run from Roger?

 

[Djordje]

1 . Why was Crocodile running from Magellan but did not have problem fighting Whitebeard ?

2. Why Greenbull who was apperently afraid of Kaido and his rule went there to fight a guy that actually defeated Kaido , how does that make sense ?

3. Why Kaido who apperently wants to find a way to die , decided to run away from Shanks and his entire crew ?

4. Why is Luffy scared and sweating when sensing Kizaru power , when arc before he defeated Kaido a more powerful opponent than Kizaru.

5. Why Big Mom did not finish Law and Kid when they were down instead of turning her back on them which resulted in her defeat.

6. Why is Blackbeard afraid and avoids fighting Rayleigh yet he was brave enough to face Garp and Sengoku at marineford.

 

[soupongo]

Garp may have been stronger then Roger/WB back then.

 

[Scarred_Face]

1 . Why was Crocodile running from Magellan but did not have problem fighting Whitebeard ?

2. Why Greenbull who was apperently afraid of Kaido and his rule went there to fight a guy that actually defeated Kaido , how does that make sense ?

3. Why Kaido who apperently wants to find a way to die , decided to run away from Shanks and his entire crew ?

4. Why is Luffy scared and sweating when sensing Kizaru power , when arc before he defeated Kaido a more powerful opponent than Kizaru.

5. Why Big Mom did not finish Law and Kid when they were down instead of turning her back on them which resulted in her defeat.

6. Why is Blackbeard afraid and avoids fighting Rayleigh yet he was brave enough to face Garp and Sengoku at marineford.

1. They wnated to escape Impel Down
2. The alliance was injured
3. Shanks>Kaido I guess.
4. Luffy was the one who kicked Kizaru first he was not afraid. I think he was just surprised of Kizaru power
5. I don't know how this is related to the thread.
6. BB was drunk of power.

 

[Djordje]

1. They wnated to escape Impel Down
2. The alliance was injured
3. Shanks>Kaido I guess.
4. Luffy was the one who kicked Kizaru first he was not afraid. I think he was just surprised of Kizaru power
5. I don't know how this is related to the thread.
6. BB was drunk of power.

Manga also already provided answer to your question why WB avoided facing Garp at that moment.

 

[Scarred_Face]

Manga also already provided answer to your question why WB avoided facing Garp at that moment.

But he did not avoid Roger that's what I'm confused about

 

[sanjikun]

OP fan logic "You must fight every single person you meet to the death"

 

[Scarred_Face]

OP fan logic "You must fight every single person you meet to the death"

Except the situation was similar for both Garp and Roger.

Wb encountered Roger and Garp.
In both situations Shakky life was at stake.

Only 1 man he chose to run away from. I'm confused why did Oda do Roger and WB dirty like this.