Still Kizaru got one taped and unless Kizaru he's able to tank stronger blows from Luffy. It will stay as a massive antifeat.
Completely absurd.
You said it himself Kizaru got one taped something we wouldn't expect from a top tier (adding it's not even some high tier move) whereas Luffy's stamina's issue exist since G4. He was already eating a lot to recover from G4 in both Katakuri or Cracker fights.
Secondly Luffy still eating when he should know what is happening (CoO) isn't needed ?
You said it himself Kizaru got one taped something we wouldn't expect from a top tier (adding it's not even some high tier move) whereas Luffy's stamina's issue exist since G4. He was already eating a lot to recover from G4 in both Katakuri or Cracker fights.
Secondly Luffy still eating when he should know what is happening (CoO) isn't needed ?
On the other hand Luffy's stamina lasted less than a virgin and he only managed to land that one tap on someone who took his attention away from him constantly.
Luffy isn't eating because he isn't needed, he is eating because he's recovering.
They both have issues I wouldn't expect from a top tier. Kizaru looks better because he got up earlier, that's all.