Questions & Mysteries Why Shanks didn't try to stop Teach himself ?

#1
Shanks is one of the few if not the only one who was aware of how ambitious and dangerous Marshal D Teach truly was and tried to warn Whitebeard about it and to have him stop Ace from continuing the hunt for him, it's also possible that the reason he went to Mariejois to meet with the Gorousei was to advise them to eliminate him before he can become too much of a threat to the world.

But why did Shanks didn't try to stop Teach himself after his betrayal and departure from Whitebeard's crew ? Is this something he wants to delegate to someone else like Luffy or Ace before his death (though not before Ace had grown much stronger) ?
What stopped him from going after him himself ?
 

Worst

Custom title
#3
Cuz probably the WG can eliminate him without causing too much damage if 2 Yonkos were to fight even if one win he will be weakened a lot and the other 2 Yonkos will want both the territories of the defeated and weakened one so they will fight too and maybe this will attract other pirates etc etc etc......
 
#7
Shanks is one of the few if not the only one who was aware of how ambitious and dangerous Marshal D Teach truly was and tried to warn Whitebeard about it and to have him stop Ace from continuing the hunt for him,
He tried to save Ace's life. It had nothing to do with Blackbeard himself.
it's also possible that the reason he went to Mariejois to meet with the Gorousei was to advise them to eliminate him before he can become too much of a threat to the world.
Nothing more than speculation.
But why did Shanks didn't try to stop Teach himself after his betrayal and departure from Whitebeard's crew ? Is this something he wants to delegate to someone else like Luffy or Ace before his death (though not before Ace had grown much stronger) ?
What stopped him from going after him himself ?
Shanks doesn't care about Blackbeard. What doees his betrayal of WB have to do with Shanks? WB was his enemy. What exactly would he stop BB from doing? Shanks doesn't stop people from living a life of piracy.

Shanks directly challenged BB during the war. If he truly cared about "stopping" him he could have easily ended him there.
 

Uncle Van

Monké Don't Do Taxes
#8
Always thought of Shanks as the ultimate gatekeeper; He's awaiting the next Roger/JoyBoy/Antu-BB aka Luffy, and is trying to keep the seas stable for his growth. If factions get too powerful, Luffy would get crushed.

Shanks chose to go warn WB about Blackbeard's threat and around that time, BB already became a Shichibukai under the WG. It wasnt long until it was revealed that WB declared war on the Marined so Shanks had bigger business to attend to.
 
#9
Simply plot armour,by the time BB beat Marco and became a new yonkou it was already too late,because other yonkous(Kaido or BM) would jump against the weakened winner of Shanks vs BB fight.
 
T
#10
becausec BB is way stronger than him and also because he is a pussy.

his bravado is enough to face admirats (who are under his sugar daddys command anyways), but not for real threats.
 
#11
becausec BB is way stronger than him and also because he is a pussy.

his bravado is enough to face Emperrors such as Kiddo or Deadbeard, but not for real threats like Admiral Teach and Navy Admirals (Sengoku was panicked seeing WG's golden boy in MF so he stopped the war immediately before any Admirals touched him)
 
A

ardym

#12
I think there might be another prophecy and BB might be important for Luffy's growth :D
and i think Shanks has to meet Luffy before he die , so if BB was to kill him then it shouldn't be before he can meet Luffy again
 

Finalbeta

Ging Freecss stan
#13
I think there might be another prophecy and BB might be important for Luffy's growth :D
and i think Shanks has to meet Luffy before he die , so if BB was to kill him then it shouldn't be before he can meet Luffy again
Yes Shanks is not dying until EoS

It would be bad writing to not let them reunite. Maybe Shanks' death will trigger Luffy's new power up.

Many scenarios are feasible. :)
 

Fujishiro

Just chilling
#14
Cuz probably the WG can eliminate him without causing too much damage if 2 Yonkos were to fight even if one win he will be weakened a lot and the other 2 Yonkos will want both the territories of the defeated and weakened one so they will fight too and maybe this will attract other pirates etc etc etc......
He's talking about yami teach not yonko teach. Maybe the gorosei told him to stay put and his only way of stoping him is going around asking others to do so.
 
#15
Shanks is one of the few if not the only one who was aware of how ambitious and dangerous Marshal D Teach truly was and tried to warn Whitebeard about it and to have him stop Ace from continuing the hunt for him, it's also possible that the reason he went to Mariejois to meet with the Gorousei was to advise them to eliminate him before he can become too much of a threat to the world.

But why did Shanks didn't try to stop Teach himself after his betrayal and departure from Whitebeard's crew ? Is this something he wants to delegate to someone else like Luffy or Ace before his death (though not before Ace had grown much stronger) ?
What stopped him from going after him himself ?
Because it was out of his jurisdiction. Blackbeard was a former Whitebeard underling so it's his crews deal. Imo Shanks didn't want to act outside of his own jurisdiction especially with how attacked Whitebeard gets to his crew.
 
#16
I think events just moved too quickly for him.

He obviously wanted to talk to Whitebeard before he did anything, and by then it was too late. By the time he'd met Whitebeard, Blackbeard had beaten Ace, became a Warlord and war was inevitable.

And I do think there's some further background involving the two, the Gorosei and Rocks that we're not privy to and is shaping a lot of Shank' actions.
 
#17
Depending on Oda's mindset, it could simply be due to plot as others said, however i don't think it's because Oda didn't do it. This is a long speculation but an interesting one nonetheless:
Although it's true Shanks desires order and stabilization, protecting the three great powers from collapsing, it seems like as if he's waiting for someone/something to reach a certain level, waiting for a trigger to quickly destroy two extremist sides (BB Pirates/WG which represent Havoc/Order) with one stone (Luffy). i think when Shanks was a child during his time with the Roger pirates decades ago, Roger told him about the God Valley incident and that he joined Garp to stop an evil pirate from ruling the world which saved the world nobles, Shanks fully understood Roger's reasons and why he did that.

After fighting kid Teach, witnessing his amnesia disease and receiving the wound on his eye, Teach told him about his goal to manipulate the great powers and surpass Whitebeard whom he despised because he never tried to become the pirate king despite him being able to. Teach's plan involves stealing the three strongest devil fruits in each class, reviving the rocks pirates whom he admired by collecting a band of the worst criminals and getting the three ancient weapons to destroy Mary Geoise, putting the world nobles' lives in danger like it was in God Valley.

Shanks became wary of Teach and considered him as someone who could potentially threat the balance itself like Rocks D. Xebec did, especially after Teach took down Ace, the late pirate king's son whom Roger himself sought to be his heir. so Shanks is trying to minimize the casualties Teach/other stakeholder do. warning Whitebeard, stopping Kaido, stopping the summit war, alarming the five elders etc.. However Shanks' true goal is to indirectly manipulate Teach and the marines into chopping each other during the final war until a third stakeholder (Luffy) emerges and deals the finishing blow to both.

So basically, Shanks made a bet on Luffy when he lost his arm before Luffy going on his journey, and that bet is for Luffy to be the next Joy Boy that would neutralize Im-sama and the future "Xebec" using the different allies he managed to befriend during his journey and the three ancient weapons. Shanks' actions are simply to ensure that Teach/Yonko/World Government are kept in check/deadlock and that none of them are able to wreck the other until endgame when Luffy becomes strong enough to finish them all.

So yeah, it's laughable how this important plot could be all according to a simple bet from a 39 year old snitch
 
#18
Shanks knew that Asce went for BB...
BB "hunted by" asce who is "WB family".
so, shanks respect WB...
if WB leave BB alone, and asce come back to the ship, 'then' Shanks will come after him...
Simple as that, 'jurisdiction'
 
Top