General & Others Why titles don't mean anything in mangas and how Mihawk title isn't valid.

[[No Name]]

? Roger found the One piece and is confirmed the PK. Also Luffy will not defeat everyone. He claimed he would defeat BM didn't. Megallan beat his ass. If Zoro becomes the WSS by beating Mihawk than Mihawk was the WSS

Roger Is the PK, but according to Luffy's definition PK Is not the one of other people.

Standing above other supreme kings and finding the treasure Is enough to be considered the PK, but for Luffy this still wouldn't be enough to call himself PK, people would call him PK true, but for Luffy the PK Is the most free person in this world.

Won't surprise me if Luffy Is being recognized by others as a PK already before the final war against WG, with him already finding the treasure but him refusing to consider his Dream completed because he Is still not free until he destroyes WG.

 

[Sword God Ryuma]

Roger Is the PK, but according to Luffy's definition PK Is not the one of other people.

Standing above other supreme kings and finding the treasure Is enough to be considered the PK, but for Luffy this still wouldn't be enough to call himself PK, people would call him PK true, but for Luffy the PK Is the most free person in this world.

Won't surprise me if Luffy Is being recognized by others as a PK already before the final war against WG, with him already finding the treasure but him refusing to consider his Dream completed because he Is still no t free until he destroyes WG.

1. According to Luffy definition he won't be PK if he doesn't beat every Yonkou and Admiral which he isn't going to do. Nor beat megallan who beat his ass.
2. Mihawk is confirmed in the Vivrecard to be WSS

 

[Nikuzi]

And I'm reporting you.

lol

 

[Shanal]

As I said, if Zoro ends up being the WSS It doesn't matter if Mihawk's title was fake.

I mean, Luffy could be following the wrong Road to the One piece DOES this make his title of finding It fake? No, if he ends up finding It having followed a wrong way to It doesn't make his Dream not valid.

But why does it HAVE to be fake.

Why does Zoro have to chase a fake guy with fake title.

Why can't it be genuine as it should be because it's our protagonist's dream and a meaningful amobition reaching point.

It has no evidence of being fake, it doesn't even have implication of being fake and now Mihawk has a proper Yonko level portrayal as well to go with his title.

So why you gotta just make it fake and pretend it's likely? Lol

 

[[No Name]]

But why does it HAVE to be fake.

Why does Zoro have to chase a fake guy with fake title.

Why can't it be genuine as it should be because it's our protagonist's dream and a meaningful amobition reaching point.

It has no evidence of being fake, it doesn't even have implication of being fake and now Mihawk has a proper Yonko level portrayal as well to go with his title.

So why you gotta just make it fake and pretend it's likely? Lol

Never Say that Mihawk title MUST be fake.
But that I won't be that sorue that his title protects or prevents him from this scenario happening.

 

[Owari Da]

cope, seeth and stay mald fella.

 

[Shanal]

Never Say that Mihawk title MUST be fake.
But that I won't be that sorue that his title protects or prevents him from this scenario happening.

But it is true and it should be looked at that way until contradicted!

It's his title. VC says it's his title both in name and actuality.

It's one of our protagonist's dream so it matters FAR more than any other arbitrary title outside of Luffy's PK one.

Mihawk has portrayal backing of at least being the level required for that title to be genuine.

There's nothing so far which has contradicted the title in any manner or form.

For instance, there's absolutely nothing which gives total protection. Oda even retcons DF names and types if need be (Katakuri). But we shouldn't pretend stuff don't mean stuff unless proven wrong by Manga.

 

[[No Name]]

But it is true and it should be looked at that way until contradicted!

It's his title. VC says it's his title both in name and actuality.

It's one of our protagonist's dream so it matters FAR more than any other arbitrary title outside of Luffy's PK one.

Mihawk has portrayal backing of at least being the level required for that title to be genuine.

There's nothing so far which has contradicted the title in any manner or form.

Shanks' hype, role and stuff @Charlotte Horchata explained, suggest you to read their comment.

 

[Shanal]

Shanks' hype, role and stuff @Charlotte Horchata explained, suggest you to read their comment.

Mihawk's portrayal is enough to be on same general level as Shanks, at the very least.

But other than that, how one interprets a person's role isn't a good enough reason to downright deny the canonical statements, title, and end-game Oda has set up not only in general, but also for one of our protagonists lol. Vivre Card, info-box, Manga statements, Zoro's end goal, etc, are all set up for Mihawk being > Shanks.

Sure, Oda can contradict it all to hell (which he has never done so far in series, though. Maybe once with this or that but never to this extent), but pretending it's more likely than not is kind of ridiculous.

You might be able to put an asterisk in front of Kaido's or WB's title, but you can never disprove them. And their titles are narratively insignificant compared to Mihawk's because they become irrelevant outside of their character, but this is one of our protag's main ambition lol

Ultimately, folks can believe whatever they want. But isn't it just personal interpretation of what WILL happen vs what manga and Oda has stated so far, then?