Questions & Mysteries Why was Roger not WSS?

[CbShadow]

Let me guess, this is another swordsmanship doesn't include haki thread.

Zoro using haki to beat King is no different than Roger using haki to conquer the world.

''I DON'T THINK'' , ''ODA NEVER SAID THIS GUY HAS MORE SKILL'' HE THINK WRONG, ITS CONFIRMED LAST CHAPTER.

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/for...ain-confirmed-to-be-mainly-skill-based.31012/

I was right, Paul was wrong to ''think'' its not SKILL.

:holdthisl:

Skilled is defined as the ability to do something well.

Zoro was able to master enma because of how well he could release and add incredibly large amounts of haki to his sword.

 

[Marco]

According to OP's logic, since before WB's birth and after his death (2+ years) there was no WSM because no real men existed then or now

 

[Lor D. Coast]

because haki is what matters
Roger conquered the world with his haki, not with his swordmanship

Lanji has no haki, good too see that Lanjitards finally understand that Lanji gets oneshotted by Zoro. It only took you 1057 chapters!

 

[Rolling nut]

Possible scenarios
-He wasn't the world strongest swordsman, in the interpretation of "more skilled"
-He wasn't the world strongest swordsman in the interpretation of "strongest with a blade"
-That title didn't exist because piracy wasn't great yet and there were just titles like "great pirates" and, finally, the "pirate King", so maybe he was but wasn't publicly credited for that but for other bigger achievements (PK > all)
-He can't be categorized in a simplicistic way, he is a swordsman as much as a brawler, he uses a blade against Whitebeard and he might have used a brawler style against the likes of Garp or Sengoku
-Oda doesn't even care about power levels and some worstgen users agendas, no one cares

Don't know other possible explanations to your question, give me a feedback you weirdos

 

[CbShadow]

Possible scenarios
-He wasn't the world strongest swordsman, in the interpretation of "more skilled"
-He wasn't the world strongest swordsman in the interpretation of "strongest with a blade"
-That title didn't exist because piracy wasn't great yet and there were just titles like "great pirates" and, finally, the "pirate King", so maybe he was but wasn't publicly credited for that but for other bigger achievements (PK > all)
-He can't be categorized in a simplicistic way, he is a swordsman as much as a brawler, he uses a blade against Whitebeard and he might have used a brawler style against the likes of Garp or Sengoku
-Oda doesn't even care about power levels and some worstgen users agendas, no one cares

Don't know other possible explanations to your question, give me a feedback you weirdos

What? Roger is a swordsmaster. Enough with this pure swordsman BS.

The most logical explanation is 1 of 2 things:
- the title didn't exist back then because nobody actually traveled the world to become or prove who is the strongest.

- Roger was the WSS he just hasn't revealed that information yet. There is still more to learn about Roger.

 

[Rolling nut]

What? Roger is a swordsmaster. Enough with this pure swordsman BS.

The most logical explanation is 1 of 2 things:
- the title didn't exist back then because nobody actually traveled the world to become or prove who is the strongest.

- Roger was the WSS he just hasn't revealed that information yet. There is still more to learn about Roger.

I expressed several different scenarios, exploring opposite interpretations of the issue, you usually do that when you analyze things

You shouldn't shut an opinion just cause you disagree with it, what's that "enough with this bullshit", even more cause we don't know much about Roger

 

[SkySanji]

For the same reason that WB wasn't both the WSM and WSS, WSM is a superior title so being WSS is pointless, the same way PK is even more superior to that.

 

[Kurozumi Giggio]

Roger was too weak to get the title , in fact Roger the swordsman never reached the top of swordsmanship as he was never able to turn his sword black

 

[Minatoze Narutomaki]

Here is the official translation but it wont change your mind probably. Erkan took his lesson but didnt stop his cope.

That is just one person's opinion, even he admits its said "greatest"
If there was no difference why do you think in the last chapter it was mentioned Mihawk is better swordsman "in skill", instead couldnt he just say Mihawk is stronger than Shanks
Clearly means the intention is to differentiate between skill and strength

Post automatically merged: Aug 27, 2022

Lmfao you delusional window licker.
Try reading the official translation

I have, show me where it was mentioned

 

[S.W317]

Away from “fanboism”, I think the term was specifically coined for Mihawk, as in it’s not an inherited title that people pass on to the next one but just a tittle that was specifically given to and was only pursued by a Mihawk and currently Zoro.

And while there’s lots of arguments of Mihawk being at least as strong as Shanks if not stronger making the title as legit as it sounds it doesn’t apply to all eras since I’m sure Xebec, Ryuma and Roger were all swordsmen of a higher caliber than Mihawk and in fact even Oden could be stronger than both him and Shanks

 

[Rootbeer]

Well, swordsisters? Why was Roger not World's Strongest Swordsman?

• He carried a sword
• He fought with a sword
• He used haki in fights
• He loved his sword to name his son after it

and yet he was not WSS. Why is that?

Mihawk never once was used in the same sentence as Roger. He was never compared to Roger. Zoro never once thought about Roger as his goal or even in general.
Why is that?

Mihawk as WSS was seeing himself inferior to old Whitebeard who was WSM.
While Roger was being compared as prime Whitebeard's equal and superior. Why is that?

Because it's not worth it.. lt hinders the CoC potential for Haki masters..

 

[DiscoZoro20]

Because Roger is likely not a swordsman.

 

[BuggyDGod]

Well, swordsisters? Why was Roger not World's Strongest Swordsman?

• He carried a sword
• He fought with a sword
• He used haki in fights
• He loved his sword to name his son after it

and yet he was not WSS. Why is that?

Mihawk never once was used in the same sentence as Roger. He was never compared to Roger. Zoro never once thought about Roger as his goal or even in general.
Why is that?

Mihawk as WSS was seeing himself inferior to old Whitebeard who was WSM.
While Roger was being compared as prime Whitebeard's equal and superior. Why is that?

Its pretty obvious to anyone with a functioning brain.

Roger was the greatest pirate and the strongest pirate aside from maybe WB. His most relevant titles would be the greatest pirate or strongest man.

Both of these titles are greater than world's strongest swordsman.

On the other hand Shanks only important thing he is is a yonkou title something mihawk just threw in the garbage cause he thinks its worthless.

Keep coping Lanks fans.

 

[Peroroncino]

how many cope threads does this make?

 

[centurion]

how many cope threads does this make?

Erkan and Kurwa fighting over who can make the most cope threads in WG in a single day:

 

[BuggyDGod]

 

[Peroroncino]

Erkan and Kurwa fighting over who can make the most cope threads in WG in a single day:

honestly i've been counting them but i've lost count lol

 

[Ninjashadow0209]

Just answer the question. How do you even know if the title existed 20+ years ago? How does Roger being the WSS 20+ years ago affect Mihawk being the WSS and Shanks a swordsman right now?

You're literally trying to force a correlation between Roger and the WSS title for some Shanks>Mihawl argument lol

Because Zorotards brinks Roger everytime when Mihawk doed something with his Swords, or when people see for the first time Roger using a Sword and even knowing his sword was a 12 and named Ace.

 

[HA001]

That is just one person's opinion, even he admits its said "greatest"
If there was no difference why do you think in the last chapter it was mentioned Mihawk is better swordsman "in skill", instead couldnt he just say Mihawk is stronger than Shanks
Clearly means the intention is to differentiate between skill and strength

Post automatically merged: Aug 27, 2022

I have, show me where it was mentioned

世界最強の剣士 = Sekai Saikyō no Kenshi = World's strongest swordsman

世界最強の男 = Sekai Saikyō no Otoko = World's strongest man

Here we have Mihawks and Whitebeards title. It should be clearly visible that both titles are very similar to each other, in fact the only thing they differ in is the last part. 剣士 means swordsman while 男 means man.

Both titles are build up in the same pattern: The first part is what they are, in this case the World's strongest, that is the same in both titles. The second part is the more important part as it states what group the first part refers to: In case of Whitebeards title it refers to the group of man, while it in Mihawks title refers to the group of swordsman.



Mihawks title is world's STRONGEST

 

[CbShadow]

I expressed several different scenarios, exploring opposite interpretations of the issue, you usually do that when you analyze things

You shouldn't shut an opinion just cause you disagree with it, what's that "enough with this bullshit", even more cause we don't know much about Roger

We know he's a swordsman/swordsmaster.