Questions & Mysteries Why was Roger not WSS?

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
That's not what happened, Mihawk sent a slash to test the true distance between him and Whitebeard..
No he didnt.
At no point does mihawk mention himself alone
The whole build up before that slash is everyone declaring wb wsm the strongest etc

Mihawk tells doffy he thinks the gap between wb and the rest of the world SEEMS RATHER SMALL

Then he tested his theory


Primebeard stands in front of his crew

Old beard has his crew jump in front of him

Showing the decline and mihawk losing interest
 
No he didnt.
At no point does mihawk mention himself alone
The whole build up before that slash is everyone declaring wb wsm the strongest etc

Mihawk tells doffy he thinks the gap between wb and the rest of the world SEEMS RATHER SMALL

Then he tested his theory


Primebeard stands in front of his crew

Old beard has his crew jump in front of him

Showing the decline and mihawk losing interest
He's speaking..
lt's a metaphor to Mihawk and Whitebeard's power level, he wanted to see how far he is from Whitebeard's level..
 
Well, swordsisters? Why was Roger not World's Strongest Swordsman?
  • He carried a sword
  • He fought with a sword
  • He used haki in fights
  • He loved his sword to name his son after it
and yet he was not WSS. Why is that?

Mihawk never once was used in the same sentence as Roger. He was never compared to Roger. Zoro never once thought about Roger as his goal or even in general.
Why is that?

Mihawk as WSS was seeing himself inferior to old Whitebeard who was WSM.
While Roger was being compared as prime Whitebeard's equal and superior. Why is that?
Ryuma was known as leggendary swordsman, Roger was not. Guess why
Simple answer, Hakiman

:handsup:
 
Wrong. :kobeha:




Except you'd have to overcome every single other pirate in the world trying to get the road poneglyphs which include the Yonko. Not just a single swordsman. Even Kaido acknowledges Rogers Haki as being the one to transcend all and that this power alone was enough to conquer the world. What difficulty overcoming one swordsman over every single pirate in the world. This is why the title of PK has more meaning than World's strongest Swordsman.




Mihawk is strong but he pales in comparison to Roger and WB. He could never reach those heights.
Roger was a swordsman and a one arm swordsman became a yonko. Swordsmen can be the best fighters in one piece so why bother beating all the pirates when you can be the strongest by just beating swordsmen
 
Lmao stop the cope once again
Which pirates Roger even overcome??

Panzy ran away from loser like Big Mom
Whitebeard never bothered being in his way
Kaido was a fucking kid
Rayleigh was with him
Shiki was trash

Roger's strength has no hype that compares to Mihawk lol. Unskilled Ace lover failed to even make black blade..his bounty is barely 5.5 billion

Considering mihawks base bounty is already 3.6 billion..with Yonko title he would have bad 6 billion

Mihawk mid or high diffs Roger
Post automatically merged:
You speak of hype as if Mihawk has any. :luffylaugh:

Beyond clashing with a young Shanks I don't really see any hype surrounding Mihawk.

All of what you said is irrelevant.


Mihawk hasn't beaten anyone noteworthy that we know of besides Zoro. I don't imagine getting stalled by Vista of all people is noteworthy achievement. :milaugh:


At least Roger has overcome Xebec and his entire crew which consisted of WB, Kaido, BM and Shiki in the past. All of whom are legends at this point in the story. He did so with just Garp by his side. As I recall there was no Rayleigh or anyone else you can use to cope about how easy it was for Roger.



Nonetheless Mihawk admitted inferiority to Roger and WB. No amount of Copium as you call it is going to change that.
 
Last edited:
You speak of hype as if Mihawk has any. :luffylaugh:

Beyond clashing with a young Shanks I don't really see any hype surrounding Mihawk.

All of what you said is irrelevant.


Mihawk hasn't beaten anyone noteworthy that we know of besides Zoro. I don't imagine getting stalled by Vista of all people is noteworthy achievement. :milaugh:


At least Roger has overcome Xebec and his entire crew which consisted of WB, Kaido, BM and Shiki in the past. All of whom are legends at this point in the story. He did so with just Garp by his side. As I recall there was no Rayleigh or anyone else you can use to cope about how easy it was for Roger.



Nonetheless Mihawk admitted inferiority to Roger and WB. No amount of Copium as you call it is going to change that.
The fuck are you on about young Shanks old Shanks bullshit

Shanks is a one armed hobo who needs mihawk not the other way around. Mihawk low diffs that trash who can't even get 5 billion with special crew territory sucking gorosei dick and everything.

Mihawks strength is worth 3.6 billion and Shanks strength is worth 1 billion

Mihawk can literally defeat 3 Shanks

And stop bullshitting
When did mihawk say Roger is stronger than him?
Show me one panel you liar
 
He was. Unless you can name a swordsman from his era who was stronger.

It doesn't matter if the title was given name or not. It's a reality title, not an arbitrary one. As long as there are swordsmen in the world, there will be a strongest one.

Ryuma was known as leggendary swordsman, Roger was not. Guess why
Because being PK is more prestigious? Mihawk even says so. Why would Roger be known as something lesser than his biggest accomplishment.
 
King vs Zoro literally spoonfed it to us, yet people don't get it. Just using a sword doesn't make you a swordsman in OP.

Oda is just that much of a hack...

Everyone too busy on Mohawk > Skank , that they miss the irrelevancy of the WSS title.
Dumb argument since king had other things beside his sword to rely on.

He had a devil fruit

Naturally lunarian fire powers

Wings for flight and offense.

Shanks has none of these things and instead has a ton of haki, aton of haki control and swordsmanship

The fact that they keep bringing shanks up for mihawks swordsman ship means that shanks is swordsman hence why he made me for himself with his blade
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
Oda, narrator, Garp, Sengoku and Buggy are all irrelevant, but Brannew who has likely never even witness Shanks fight is to be taking at 100% truth :milaugh:
They are. Because none of them had seen wb in decades
They set up to fight primebeard but that's not what showed up
Wbs own words
Marcos words whose been with him for years
And even Croc calling him pathetic
Hold more weight
 
They are. Because none of them had seen wb in decades
They set up to fight primebeard but that's not what showed up
Wbs own words
Marcos words whose been with him for years
And even Croc calling him pathetic
Hold more weight
Old WB>MF WB off the IV's. He showed AdvCoC when he split the skies with Shanks and top tier CoO against Ace. The narrator introduces him as the WSM with the title box. Isn't that what you Mihawk fans love to use? If we're not to believe the title box and the narrator, why should we believe that a Mihawk that duelled Shanks 12 years ago is stronger? Pure hypocrisy
 
Lmao stop the cope once again
Which pirates Roger even overcome??

Panzy ran away from loser like Big Mom
Whitebeard never bothered being in his way
Kaido was a fucking kid
Rayleigh was with him
Shiki was trash

Roger's strength has no hype that compares to Mihawk lol. Unskilled Ace lover failed to even make black blade..his bounty is barely 5.5 billion

Considering mihawks base bounty is already 3.6 billion..with Yonko title he would have bad 6 billion

Mihawk mid or high diffs Roger
Post automatically merged:


Mihawk shits on Roger

If Roger's CoC was above mihawk he would be wss since CoC is main requirement for WSS and Zoros fighting style is advCoC based.

Mihawks CoC >>> Shanks CoC
You are either trolling or so ridiculously biased to your favorites that you’re reading the entire narrative incorrectly. Like not even going deep into thinking of character dynamics and shit…it’s just plain out written out and instilled in the story.

Alright, prepare to be debunked in another obvious way, but you’ll probably put your Zoro and Mihawk agenda glasses on.
 
Top