Questions & Mysteries Why would Hancock team up with cross guild?

[Albino 👑]

Mihawk is "working under" Buggy, so don't give me that crap. Even an agenda lord like you ultimately considers Mihawk a top tier.
Oda is Buggy's biggest fanboy. Don't be crying when Oda makes Buggy pirate king before Luffy :)

And at the end of the day, CG ultimately works as a guild than a pirate crew. The commanders all have comparable positions, even though outside world considers Buggy as the Yonko, Mihawk/Crocodile as YC.
Within CG, the crew dynamics will always be that of partners.


Boa is never going to be a crewmate.
Her character of giga fangirling Luffy only works as an outsider.

If she doesn't join CG, the best you can get is her becoming a member of grand fleet, or an ally like Marco (and potentially Katakuri)

Her joining luffy whether it’s as a crew member, fleet member, ally, or whatever makes 1000% more sense than forcing her into an organization of people she doesn’t like or respect

 

[Brush D. Teeth]

Doffy and Moria are probably gonna join Cross Guild it is foreshadowed in the Roger execution chapter.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Many seem to be for Hancock teaming up with cross guild but why would she do that when she could join luffy?

She actually cares about luffy and he’s also an emperor. Even if she didn’t officially join as a crew member she could still officially make Amazon lily officially one of his territories.

Buggy could promise to lead her to Luffy.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

People have forgotten she still doesn’t like men bar few exceptions.

 

[X18999]

Buggy could promise to lead her to Luffy.

As if she couldn't just find him herself... the Straw Hats aren't a stealthy group that hard to find... just follow the chaos.

 

[Lor D. Coast]

Why would a conqueror join the Strawhats, what about the fan made status quo of the crew?
Boa would be an insta top 3 Strawhat, she's a conqueror and a Captain with her own crew, think of the death threats that Oda would receive.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

As if she couldn't just find him herself... the Straw Hats aren't a stealthy group that hard to find... just follow the chaos.

BB nearly got Hancock killed. There are plenty of arguments to persuade Hancock to get help from others.

 

[Albino 👑]

BB nearly got Hancock killed. There are plenty of arguments to persuade Hancock to get help from others.

She’s not joining a group directly against luffy and the strawhats…

 

[HA001]

Because mihawk is related to her.

 

[kumae]

Who says she is gonna join the guild kuma and her are finish she will stay in Amazon lily with rayleigh protection also law won't join only Doffy moria and weevil

 

[Shiroyru]

She probably wouldnt. She'd be on the side of Luffy, like Marco & WBP remnants.

I see Moria & Doffy ending up at Cross Guild. Not Hancock/Jinbe/Kuma, they are clearly the pro-Luffy Warlords.

Oda should have Moria, Doffy, Kata, and the BMP remnants join CG if he wants them to rival the RHPs and BBPs

 

[Albino 👑]

Kata, and the BMP remnants join CG

 

[X18999]

BB nearly got Hancock killed. There are plenty of arguments to persuade Hancock to get help from others.

Yes, she was almost killed and now needs to leave her island...

So why would she go join someone she doesn't know and has no real connection with rather than the guy she's in love with who would accept her and her whole island with no conditions and let her do pretty much whatever she wants (besides marry him)?

If Luffy was still just another pirate then I could understand her joining the Cross Guild but the Straw Hat Pirates is already a more powerful/famous organization than the Cross Guild. Not to mention they continually fight the WG which she would be all for considering her past.

 

[RebelliousSoma]

Yes, she was almost killed and now needs to leave her island...

So why would she go join someone she doesn't know and has no real connection with rather than the guy she's in love with who would accept her and her whole island with no conditions and let her do pretty much whatever she wants (besides marry him)?

If Luffy was still just another pirate then I could understand her joining the Cross Guild but the Straw Hat Pirates is already a more powerful/famous organization than the Cross Guild. Not to mention they continually fight the WG which she would be all for considering her past.

Depends on the interaction.

I am just going along with the question. It's possible and it's plausible.
I don't think it will happen due to different reasons. You forget Oda can be unpredictable.

 

[Shiroyru]

Why not? Makes 100000% more sense than recruiting Doffy

 

[Cruxroux]

All the Warlords will be somehow under Cross guild.

I have already theorised this.

Cross guild will be a parallel to Rocks.

All the weird powers will be together.

And they do not have agree with each other or share same goal. Because that's the fuckin point.
they won't agree on anything yet banded together for some reason. None of the rocks ever agreed with each other. Bigmam confirmed it by saying Rocks fall was them infighting with each other.

 

[TheLastBerserker]

Buggy could promise to lead her to Luffy.

Doesn't she have Luffy's Vivre Card lol

 

[Weeman]

Unless Crocodile can offer her protection for her island or something i doubt she would join.

 

[Albino 👑]

Why not? Makes 100000% more sense than recruiting Doffy

And I doubt doffy would join cross guild too

Why would kata, Hancock, or any big supporter/fan of luffy join a rival organization that goes directly against him

 

[Shiroyru]

And I doubt doffy would join cross guild too

Why would kata, Hancock, or any big supporter/fan of luffy join a rival organization that goes directly against him

Totland needs protection now that BM is gone (and also Smoothie and the others being MIA). The fact that the BBPs could casually stroll into WCI, kidnap Pudding, and get a RP rubbing with little issue shows that Totland needs a new Yonko to protect it. Buggy can offer to protect WCI in exchange for Kata allying with CG and giving him access to their RP.