General & Others Would Kaidos crew have been bette did the commanders were Yamato King and Doflamingo?

[DonWick]

I personally feel like Jack and Queen could have been scrapped or been Fflying 6 members.

How would you rank those commanders and would the Zoro Sanji and Jinbei been able to beat them?

I would rank them:

1. Yamato
2. King
3. Doffy

I don’t think the Strawhats could handle the task. Zoro would be the only one to beat his opponent.

 

[BillSlipton]

Jimbei gets his fat squid gf to ink all over doffy blinding him. One shot ko Vagabond drill on hodys steroids

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Zoro vs Yamato would go to Zoro
Sanji vs King would go to Sanji

These were the mirror matches I would’ve wanted and think wouldve been such a good choreography but Albeit worse story.

Doffy I think Is weaker than Jack so maybe he and jinbe would be a close bout and would tell a cool story about a Fishman and a slaver, but the choreography would’ve been odd

 

[Seatonnes]

Queen > doffy
(yamato is meant to be the ace of kaidos crew)

 

[soheilhazrat]

Yamato over Queen is upgrade
Doffy over Jack is also upgrade
Why not

 

[Zaretball]

In 1 vs 1 neither Zoro nor Sanji would beat Yamato.
Jinbe vs Doffy could go either way, but Sulong Inu would still mid diff Doffy.
Sanji would extreme diff King or be defeated.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Zoro vs. Yamato, Sanji vs. King, Jinbe vs. Doffy... They'll extreme diff all 3...

 

[Seatonnes]

Yamato wins extreme diff
King wins extreme diff
Jinbe wins high-extreme diff

 

[Night Flight]

Powerscaing aside, I do believe it would've made for a much more interesting arc, at least narratively speaking. It's well-known that Doflamingo was part of Wano in Oda's early drafts, so even Oda had that in mind. And Yamato would've been especially nice to see, since that would have given her a clear-cut purpose in the arc, especially if she redeems herself and joins the alliance afterwards. Fun to think about, I suppose.

 

[WesMidnight]

current Zoro couldn't beat current Yamato, she has better base stats and better adv CoC. He and Sanji will zenkai haki bloom boost past her post-Wano if she joins though.
Sanji could beat King, as King's defense only works against slashing attacks.
Don't think Inu could beat Doflamingo tbh.

 

[DonWick]

Zoro vs Yamato would go to Zoro
Sanji vs King would go to Sanji

These were the mirror matches I would’ve wanted and think wouldve been such a good choreography but Albeit worse story.

Doffy I think Is weaker than Jack so maybe he and jinbe would be a close bout and would tell a cool story about a Fishman and a slaver, but the choreography would’ve been odd

I didn’t think about that narrative with Jinbei and Doffy that would be fire for story telling.
[automerge]1653506128[/automerge]

Yamato wins extreme diff
King wins extreme diff
Jinbe wins high-extreme diff

I don’t see Yamato beating Zoro or Jinbei beating Doffy.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Zoro and Sanji would have beat Yamato and King. But Jinbei will lose against Doffy.

 

[Finalbeta]

Yeah definitely

Yamato is defo stronger than Queen and Doffy is probably stronger than Jack other than robustly trickier

 

[Seatonnes]

I don’t see Yamato beating Zoro or Jinbei beating Doffy.

yamato has the upper hand on zoro, she has relative haki aswell as a mythical zoan so i think she wins but with extreme diff fights it could go either way, also doffy is YC4+ jinbe can win

 

[SkySanji]

Yamato would end up beating Zoro before he gets ACoC unlike King

Sanji still beats King

Jinbe vs Doflamingo goes either way

 

[Chiji_]

I can only see Zoro winning his matchup and even then I could see a scenario of Yamato beating him

 

[ConquistadoR]

The Strawhats get folded.

 

[DonWick]

The Strawhats get folded.

I think so to.

 

[m0nst3Rx]

Zoro vs yamato : rooftop zoro low diff or tatasumaki/huryu kaen oneshot kill her

King vs Eos sanji: king low diff

Queen vs Jinbei: Onigashima jinbei low/mid diff

 

[JoNdule]

Dude, Jack is the perfect commander for Kaido

King and Queen shouldn't be like this... they suck