General & Others Would've Rooftop 5 vs 2 been better story-wise, with this certain change?

[Ballel]

Will 6 vs 2 be better story-wise and felt more fitting as the struggle against 2 Emperors? Compared to 5 vs 2?

no

 

[Rmstorm]

The rooftop was an absolute garbage fight. It was a 5v1 and yet for some reason, every character attacked 1 at a time instead of ganging up on kaido and linlin, like you would expect from a tag team.

Also, Luffy had beef with Linlin, but never did anything to her. Kid had beef with Kaido, but never did anything to him.

feels like Oda did the bare minimum to give payoff for the hundreds of chapters he spent building up supernova vs kaido,

Oda will never have Luffy straight up punching a women,

This is why he said Big Mom.would pay for zapping Zoro with lightning and then proceeded to hit kaido right after.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Oda will never have Luffy straight up punching a women,

This is why he said Big Mom.would pay for zapping Zoro with lightning and then proceeded to hit kaido right after.

but he drew Kid smacking her in the face

 

[Marco]

Nah, keep the same lineup but more of the fight. So before Hakai we get 3-5 chapters extra and BM gets hits on her too. Would love to have seen Law, Killer, Zoro vs BM at some point. Then everything can proceed as it did, except for Killer fighting a calamity or Smoothie instead.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Luffy and Zoro vs Kaido and Kidd and Killer vs Big Mom while Law supporting both teams would have been better.

 

[Rmstorm]

but he drew Kid smacking her in the face

Yes, but not LUFFY. He will never have his main character smacking them around.

 

[Midnight Delight]

but he drew Kid smacking her in the face

Kidd is an antihero who kills people for talking shit, Law was always ruthless

Oda sees Luffy as a Role model for kids so he would never draw him punching a grandma. It's that simple

 

[MonsterKaido]

Rooftop was amazing. It should never have come to the current situation where Luffy has gotten 10 zenkai boosts going from power level 9.000 to 1.000.000 in 5 hours

Yeah I agree ; Kaido vs all the supernovas to decrease his HP by 10% and then luffy defeats in 3 chapters would be better

 

[Welkin]

I'm ngl I don't like the way it was handled

Killer was given top of WG portrayal (put alongside the other 4) but did fuckall during the fight and his final fight of the arc was against Hawkins (terrible)

If we had stayed on the Rooftop then they all could've been given relatively equal portrayal

Also make it an actual team fight Big Mom literally did nothing

 

[Kiku]

I liked it as is

Sanji being up there would just mean there'd need to be 2 Mink Medicine Asspulls this arc

 

[IsaziSempi]

i think my onky real problem with roof piece or that match up is Big mom and to a lesser extsnt Kaidous attacks had no effect even though they proved they could oneshot them all.

 

[Kuroemon]

Rooftop should've been the final fight. Imagine everyone on the roof got their PU at the same time. That would've been sick

Thisss, except it was SHC vs Kaido then other Law and Kidd crew vs Big Mom

 

[TepesIII]

Nah, the dome needed some strong fighters there too for us to take it seriously. Marco/Sanji/Jinbe is a good balance below.

 

[Franosuke]

I'm ngl I don't like the way it was handled

Killer was given top of WG portrayal (put alongside the other 4) but did fuckall during the fight and his final fight of the arc was against Hawkins (terrible)

If we had stayed on the Rooftop then they all could've been given relatively equal portrayal

Also make it an actual team fight Big Mom literally did nothing

We could've had them eventually split into Law, Kid and Killer vs. BM and Luffy, Zoro, Yamato vs. Kaido

 

[Finalbeta]

Luffy and Zoro vs Kaido and Kidd and Killer vs Big Mom while Law supporting both teams would have been better.

Yeah what I was claiming bud :cheers:

 

[Tai long]

Yeah I agree ; Kaido vs all the supernovas to decrease his HP by 10% and then luffy defeats in 3 chapters would be better

you know if kaido fought in a group fight he won't show as much as he has shown right now

 

[Courier]

Just a lil change...what if Sanji joined and made it 6 vs 2?

So maybe first off there would be scrambles and ganging and switching up the opponents randomly, and then it changed to (for example):

Zoro - Law - Kidd vs Kaidou
Luffy - Sanji - Killer vs Big Mom

And finally it switched again to become

Luffy - Sanji - Law vs Kaidou
Zoro - Kidd - Killer vs Big Mom

And at some point King, Queen and Hawkins interfere with Zoro, Sanji, and Killer

While

Luffy vs Kaidou

Kidd vs Big Mom

Law vs Greenbull (arrived at Wano to capture Law for Ope2) or something


---

Will 6 vs 2 be better story-wise and felt more fitting as the struggle against 2 Emperors? Compared to 5 vs 2?

I agree that Sanji should join the roofpiece . Oda just mess up Sanji with black maria plot since nobody stalling black maria before her fight with robin.

But, the animation for roofpiece is so damn fireeeee . If oda continue this type of animation, then Luffy vs Kaido will be the best fight after all in OP history .

 

[Doggo]

Not really.
I just think it should have stayed as a 5v2, instead of breaking it.

 

[Sanji D Cook]

On the roof, Luffy and Zoro vs Kaido. Kid, Killer and Law dealing with Big Mom and her homies. Also have Hawkins on the roof waiting on that prediction he was talking about earlier.

Sanji would fight King. Drake and Chopper would fight Queen.

 

[Tai long]

On the roof, Luffy and Zoro vs Kaido. Kid, Killer and Law dealing with Big Mom and her homies. Also have Hawkins on the roof waiting on that prediction he was talking about earlier.

Sanji would fight King. Drake and Chopper would fight Queen.

chopper defeating a yonko commander, lmao