I'm not acknowledged about Alibaba's meta so I can't express a proper judgement.
My current scum reads are AL sama / Luthon / Kiwipom prominently. Ratchet is also still there, he didn't even attempt to contribute and this occurred in a past Harry Potter game too, in which he had flipped scum.
I was right about Midnight being scum, mostly for his confession but also the fact I thought I was set up in the council to divert attention from him or other scums, so that's 1/5 for me, will see what the final score I get shall be. This is also the beauty of this game for a nerd like me.