General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Finalbeta]

Because it would not fit with the theory of Luffy + 10 crew members nor with the theory that 4 SH will join in each sea.

Yes I know about that theory, I guess it shall be likely be disproven. At least from the current look of it.

 

[langitbarat]

I'm subscribed to the Go-mu theory, 5+6=11 Straw Hats (including Luffy)

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

I'm subscribed to the Go-mu theory, 5+6=11 Straw Hats (including Luffy)

Oh that’s interesting, I’ve never heard of that 5-6 theory before. Then I guess 11 SHs would make sense.

I still like the idea of 4 people joining per sea though. And each person joining in the New World was an associate of each different Yonko.

 

[KenshiraSonata]

I believe there will be 4 ppl from each sea, that's makes 13 including our captain. Also the number 13 can be read as ichi-mi which is the word used for strawhat crew. Hence mugiwara ichimi can be inferred as 13 Strawhats.

Note: even though there may be a 100 SHs, still carrot is not on the list XD

 

[Mochiman]

I still like the idea of 4 people joining per sea though. And each person joining in the New World was an associate of each different Yonko.

I'm curious. So Jinbe would be BM's associate and Yamato would be Kaido's? And do you have any candidates for the other two?

 

[Jew D. Boy]

unpopular opinion: you can speculate yamato for the next nakama with some evidences you've got WITHOUT trashing on carrot, VICE VERSA

Hi, you must be new here?? Carrot’s supporters also trash Yamato on a regular basis?? Are we reading the same thread??

 

[Raughtale]

Between Luffy literally saying he wants to recruit 10 people and Oda being inspired to write a pirate team from his time on soccer, 11 really feels like the final number.

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

I'm curious. So Jinbe would be BM's associate and Yamato would be Kaido's? And do you have any candidates for the other two?

Not at the moment. If my theory is true then it will likely be people we haven’t met yet. Some people think we don’t have enough time left in the series to introduce completely new characters but I don’t think One Piece is actually ending in 5 years. I believe we still have plenty of time for new characters. We still need to see the Elbaf Arc, Luffy still needs to visit Ace’s grave/Weevil confrontation, Loadstar Arc, (Blackbeard) Beehive Island Arc, Post-Levely and so on before we even get to Laughtale.

For Shanks, I think it would probably be some Giant from Elbaf.

For Blackbeard, probably another character we have yet to meet. There is a part of me that wants Blackbeard’s 11th titanic captain to be Gin. And then in his case the new Straw Hat would be someone we’ve meet before. But there have been so many theories for X being Gin that it borders on parody at this point.

 

[ExcaliburLazar]

I believe there will be 4 ppl from each sea, that's makes 13 including our captain. Also the number 13 can be read as ichi-mi which is the word used for strawhat crew. Hence mugiwara ichimi can be inferred as 13 Strawhats.

Note: even though there may be a 100 SHs, still carrot is not on the list XD

Larrot will join the SHs as Nami’s fur coat. A gift from Perospero. Lmao

 

[supaaasoup]

Hi, you must be new here?? Carrot’s supporters also trash Yamato on a regular basis?? Are we reading the same thread??

I suppose I didn't write the "vice versa" part big enough lmao, can you even read

Post automatically merged: Feb 4, 2021

How can't I be aware of both toxic stan club? That's why I wrote 1 statement using vice versa in the end, shall I did the other way around it's still mean the same thing, or should I write the exact same sentence twice?

 

[Jew D. Boy]

I suppose I didn't write the "vice versa" part big enough lmao, can you even read

Post automatically merged: Feb 4, 2021

How can't I be aware of both toxic stan club? That's why I wrote 1 statement using vice versa in the end, shall I did the other way around it's still mean the same thing, or should I write the exact same sentence twice?

Aight, fair enough...in my experience, I think Yamato stans are far more accepting the idea of her AND Carrot joining, whereas fans of the latter tend to vehemently attack the idea and pretend that only one can join, and it should be her alone. A lot of us who want Yamato thought that it would be Carrot for the longest time, at least until the middle of this arc; some people are having trouble accepting that there’s a new front runner and the rabbit is old news even if she somehow remains relevant.

 

[Ravagerblade]

Was never on the Carrot Train, Still not. Doesn't mean I wouldn't accept her, So long as yamato joins. I'd much just rather prefer the Sulong version of Carrot, the other is kinda trash.
/shrug

 

[supaaasoup]

Aight, fair enough...in my experience, I think Yamato stans are far more accepting the idea of her AND Carrot joining, whereas fans of the latter tend to vehemently attack the idea and pretend that only one can join, and it should be her alone. A lot of us who want Yamato thought that it would be Carrot for the longest time, at least until the middle of this arc; some people are having trouble accepting that there’s a new front runner and the rabbit is old news even if she somehow remains relevant.

Same same, I had support carrot before yamato's debut but after 5++ chapters yamato's in I feel it's getting stronger for yamato being a crew, both of their chances keep changing in my mind as time goes by but the thing is I still can see if both will join at the same time.

 

[langitbarat]

Carrot not present in 1003's overview panels doesn't mean anything / lessen her chances or importance, since Brook Robin and Chopper are absent too.

 

[Shift]

I actually think it's a point in her favor. We're coming up to 10 chapters that the battle with Perospero hasn't been updated. This montage would have been a natural time to show how Carrot and Wanda are doing. The fact that we still don't know tells me something big is about to happen.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Love how you ignored that she still noticed everything before the crew's finest Observation Haki users
Delusion is real,how can't she see the danger when i literally showed you the panel where she informed the crew,and then Daifuku jumped her,that's it lmao.



Do you even know what Lookouts are for?

You're turning this into a power debate because you lost the argument. Yea,she's weaker than Daifuku or the Genie that was clashing with Sanji.

You know those who joins the crew are topnotch, not just an average guy, with respect to their professions/positions...

Either they're gifted or had great experience with those professions... You won't see them "miss" or something prior to joining with the position they fill in...

Carrot, is she a topnotch lookout? No... She was just very average... Informed the crew but never paid attention just afterwards... A good lookout will pay attention at all times, I believe that's a lookout basics...

CoO doesn't equate to what you're trying to point out... One doesn't use Haki all the time or they get drained...

I think the problem so far isn't about Lookout role feasibility or importance, but Carrot hasn't shown off to be very excellent at it. Just like how all SH is with their role.

Of course, we can say that her feat in her intro is "excellent", but if her skill is around that, it feels "less" Strawhat-y.

Besides, Oda always showcase a role skill with some SH around before and during the time they become a nakama. Carrot only partially do that, and Oda hasn't emphasize her skill in WCI-Wano, Mainland-Onigashima. This is why it feels "lacking".

This...

So the crew would have 12 members? It doesn't add up unless someone else joins. I'm sure that if there are not 11 there will be 13 SH in the end.

The total doesn't really matter... It always depends on Oda (and Luffy according to Oda)...

But I think they'll be 13 in the final war (including Luffy)... And I'm hoping that one of them would be a powerful teenage midget Elbaf giant with a Logia DF...

Between Luffy literally saying he wants to recruit 10 people and Oda being inspired to write a pirate team from his time on soccer, 11 really feels like the final number.

Hmm, 11 players + coach + assistant coach?

For Shanks, I think it would probably be some Giant from Elbaf.

A Shanks former protege giant would be cool...

Carrot not present in 1003's overview panels doesn't mean anything / lessen her chances or importance, since Brook Robin and Chopper are absent too.

I agree here... Same with Yamato's chances, that means nothing...

But then why not show Marco, Carrot, Wanda and Drake? They're fighting "executives" as well, especially Marco...

 

[Arrow]

Carrot not present in 1003's overview panels doesn't mean anything / lessen her chances or importance, since Brook Robin and Chopper are absent too.

I'm definitely leaning towards Yamato joining over Carrot but I think that page was only meant to show those who are fighting the Executives. Yamato fought Ulti and Sasaki so Oda added her.

 

[Kurozumi D. Trussop]

I'm definitely leaning towards Yamato joining over Carrot but I think that page was only meant to show those who are fighting the Executives. Yamato fought Ulti and Sasaki so Oda added her.

Drake was also confronted by an executive (Who’s Who) yet he wasn’t shown.

 

[Arrow]

Drake was also confronted by an executive (Who’s Who) yet he wasn’t shown.

I mean he got ambushed then jumped down, I wouldn't count that as him fighting WW.

 

[Hedfi]

It's either Yamato or Carrot, though both is a possibility too.