General & Others Skip Oden Flashback. Get to the War

I want Oden's Flashback to

  • Last a few chapters. Only the highlights

    Votes: 24 26.7%
  • Last over 10 chapters. Take its time

    Votes: 53 58.9%
  • End. Now. WAR!!!!

    Votes: 13 14.4%

  • Total voters
    90
#41
Imagine Oda building this particular part of the story up for almost a full decade in real time, carefully laying the groundwork and mythology around Wano/Kozuki clan (especially Oden), shaping so much of the SHP’s journey through the New World towards the events of this arc, and connecting a ton of the series’ major mysteries to the subject of this flashback...and then glossing over it in 5 chapters so we can watch Luffy lose to Kaido for the second (and maybe not final) time.

We could end up getting SO MUCH in this flashback - the formation of the Scabbards is imminent, but we could see Oden venture into the NW with Whitebeard/Roger, learn how he met Toki, watch him become shogun, see the machinations that Orochi set in motion to bring him down, and most importantly, finally be provided with the remaining crucial pieces of context we need to truly appreciate the clash between the alliances in the current storyline - and you wanna skip that? Dawg, have we been reading the same manga the last 15 years??

This should be the most consequential flashback of the series...we need this one to go long.
Couldn't have said it any better.
 
#42
Man if You're not interested in those things then what's the point of even reading the manga ?
Seriously? SO MANY OTHER THINGS. The SHs, Elbaf, Raftel, Brooks bone jokes, etc...
Also yeah there’s Oden hype, but Oden or no Oden, this war is already jam packed with meaning
Kaido, after plummeting down from Earth, screamed to the heavens demanding a war to end all wars.
Almost all the big players laid out in Doffys throne wars speech are in place, along with bunches of hidden monsters
The alliance has forces.
The SHs got their power ups.
The snake Orochi has made his move.
Scores need to be settled
Shits bursting at the seams
Oda, Let it out. And PLEASE LET THERE BE TONS OF APOO:poop:
 
#43
I think that when it comes to flashbacks in Wano. I believe there will be 3 types of flashbacks:

1- Long Flashback (Oden):
It will be delivered BEFORE the war

2- Very small Flashbacks:
It will be delivered mid-battle for us to make us care more about the characters fighting as well as build motivation..etc. Also, it will be VERY SHORT, kinda like Baby 5 flashback, so that it does NOT disrupt the flow of battle and war. Rather, it just gives us more interest for the one who is fighting and make us more invested in them.

3- Mid length flashback (ryuuma):
the perfect way to tell it will be like in Skypea's Norland/Calgara, where it was told at the very END of the arc. Specially if the ending of the arc will have some historical info from Robin about the poneglyphs copies attained thus far, let alone Kozoki has ties with Anicient history. So, Ryuuma getting his shine probably will be at the VERY END.
Really? I don't see how Ryuma's flashback would be important oit side of the black blades business... the only other way it would be important is if those theories about Kaido having a relationship to the Dragon Ryuma cut down is true

Maybe something will be brought up later on with Ryuma having some other plot relevance but as of now it mostly only pertains to Zoro and that's if Ryuma is first of all related Zoro even or its a way of introducing the creation of black blades which surely can't be a big deal before the end of the arc since Zoro won't be making black blades this arc
Post automatically merged:

There is a possibility that Shusui is only temporarily removed from the plot. It'd weird for the best sword of Wano to sit idly while everybody is fighting for Wano's freedom with whatever weapons they can find.

Plus, the Gyukimaru/Ushimaru thread has been left open.
What's more to tell regarding Gyukimaru? And how would he matter in whether Ryuma gets a flashback or shusui appears in the plot? Zoro, Kawamatsu and Hiyori all know shusui is in Ryuma's temple so all they have to do is go there at the end of the andri

This is similar to how yubashiri was buried on thriller bark at the end of the arc... shusui and Ryuma's Grave will be revisited At the end of the arc

And there is in fact a reason why shusui isn't used for battles... its a holy relic... is like burning Jesus' s cross for fire wood just coz it's cold out... No way religious items are just tampered with just because they have pragmatic uses for them...

In fact the only way for Shusui to be pulled out of retirement is if Zoro or someone somehow ascends to Ryuma's godhood and earns the sword... But theories about Zoro becoming the new sword god in this vey arc soon became more impossible given that Oden was introduced as being such a ridiculously strong guy and yet even he isn't a Sword god so Ryuma's godhood might be a feat way beyond Zoro in just this arc
Post automatically merged:

Seriously? SO MANY OTHER THINGS. The SHs, Elbaf, Raftel, Brooks bone jokes, etc...
Also yeah there’s Oden hype, but Oden or no Oden, this war is already jam packed with meaning
Kaido, after plummeting down from Earth, screamed to the heavens demanding a war to end all wars.
Almost all the big players laid out in Doffys throne wars speech are in place, along with bunches of hidden monsters
The alliance has forces.
The SHs got their power ups.
The snake Orochi has made his move.
Scores need to be settled
Shits bursting at the seams
Oda, Let it out. And PLEASE LET THERE BE TONS OF APOO:poop:
So you would've been fine with Ennies lobby without the Robin flashback? Or MarineFord without any flashback of Ace or Whitebeard... As long as there's a bunch of guys ready to fight in present day, we don't need any context for why they are fighting
 
Last edited:
#45
OP why don't you try a social experiment to the benefor of us all you included? Don't read the Oden flashback and restart to read OP when the flashback ends (and at that point don't read it back) then at the end of Wano you will recollect how many grey/black areas there were because you skipped the flashback.
 

Cyrus the Cactus

Mihawk Reigns Supreme
#46
Really? I don't see how Ryuma's flashback would be important oit side of the black blades business... the only other way it would be important is if those theories about Kaido having a relationship to the Dragon Ryuma cut down is true

Maybe something will be brought up later on with Ryuma having some other plot relevance but as of now it mostly only pertains to Zoro and that's if Ryuma is first of all related Zoro even or its a way of introducing the creation of black blades which surely can't be a big deal before the end of the arc since Zoro won't be making black blades this arc
Calgara didn’t have much plot relevance but we still got a flashback on his relationship with Noland.
 
#47
So you would've been fine with Ennies lobby without the Robin flashback? Or MarineFord without any flashback of Ace or Whitebeard...
Never really thought of that before now. Yes totally fine. Both cases. Robins meh to me & less talky more Quake Quake please
But both of those flashbacks had better timing in the story. They happened in the midst of things, not right before stuff got going
As long as there's a bunch of guys ready to fight in present day
Yes. 10000% that. Tell me where the freaks at
we don't need any context for why they are fighting
Context: They’re enemies.
Fight time:funky:
 
#49
Really? I don't see how Ryuma's flashback would be important oit side of the black blades business... the only other way it would be important is if those theories about Kaido having a relationship to the Dragon Ryuma cut down is true

Maybe something will be brought up later on with Ryuma having some other plot relevance but as of now it mostly only pertains to Zoro and that's if Ryuma is first of all related Zoro even or its a way of introducing the creation of black blades which surely can't be a big deal before the end of the arc since Zoro won't be making black blades this arc
Post automatically merged:


What's more to tell regarding Gyukimaru? And how would he matter in whether Ryuma gets a flashback or shusui appears in the plot? Zoro, Kawamatsu and Hiyori all know shusui is in Ryuma's temple so all they have to do is go there at the end of the andri

This is similar to how yubashiri was buried on thriller bark at the end of the arc... shusui and Ryuma's Grave will be revisited At the end of the arc

And there is in fact a reason why shusui isn't used for battles... its a holy relic... is like burning Jesus' s cross for fire wood just coz it's cold out... No way religious items are just tampered with just because they have pragmatic uses for them...

In fact the only way for Shusui to be pulled out of retirement is if Zoro or someone somehow ascends to Ryuma's godhood and earns the sword... But theories about Zoro becoming the new sword god in this vey arc soon became more impossible given that Oden was introduced as being such a ridiculously strong guy and yet even he isn't a Sword god so Ryuma's godhood might be a feat way beyond Zoro in just this arc
Post automatically merged:


So you would've been fine with Ennies lobby without the Robin flashback? Or MarineFord without any flashback of Ace or Whitebeard... As long as there's a bunch of guys ready to fight in present day, we don't need any context for why they are fighting
Not entirely true. You gotta remember what Onimaru was telling Zoro about Ryuuma and the land of Wano in the past. It used to be "the city of gold"
ryuuma stood his ground against the invasion of the World Government according to what Onimaru said.
And what's more interesting is that because of Ryuuma's legendary reputation, WG and Marines do not set foot in Wano casually anymore.

When we bring WG into story, City of Gold, Ryuuma, all of them combined in one story, I'm sure that would make a nice flashback.

Ryuuma definitely was a warrior who defended Wano successfully from invaders long ago. And I'm not gonna lie, it sounds even more similar to Calgara back in the day. Some people may think that Ryuuma was defending the "city of gold". But I bet it was just a diversion from Oda once again, cause Calgara and those warrior shandians were not protecting gold, they were in fact protecting a poneglyph.

Considering Wano is the land were poneglyph was created, I'll be damned if Oda didn't give any history tying all that shit up.
Or maybe I am a better writer than he is hahahahaha, but yeah, overall, a lot of hints points towards a backstory about Wano at ancient times, and Ryuuma being incorporated in that story is the best way for Oda to display Ryuuma
 
#50
Calgara didn’t have much plot relevance but we still got a flashback on his relationship with Noland.
Well wasn't the point of thevflashback explaining Noland not being a liar and how the fairy verth got into Skypiea... Surely there's nothing You expect in the Ryuma flashback to be that important

Like of course its possible for Oda to be keeping his cards to his chest and his waiting to pull out a twist that Ryuma has some very serious direct connection to the events that happened now but as of now that's very unclear... In fact let me help you out and list as many things as we know now that are related to Ryuma and could come up

First of all, Wano was apparently the country of gold during Ryuma's time, and there's this "white gold" in Oden's flashback BUT NONE OF THIS HAS BEEN IMPORTANT IN THE CURRENT STORY

The only other characters we know existed in Ryuma's story are the dragon he cuts down and the World nobles who try to invade wano but again none of the current stories are related to World Nobles and the Dragons in the current story are all just devil fruits

Ryuma is the apparent ancestor originator of the Shimotsuki clan. But so what? The Shimotsuki clan is important sure but what's their history matter? It's the Kozuki who have a history of passing on he information and methods of making poneglyphs... We don't know anything about the Shimotsuki clan passing on any secret techniques or anything so why would their specfically ancestry mater to the current plot

Ryuma's sword shusui is the last and most important thing about Ryuma and it's been kicked out of the plot already and all indications points to it on mattering at the very end of the arc

I mean as of now there's so little that requires a ryuma flashback... at this point it just seems like fanservice to include it given how little it's actually needed
Post automatically merged:

Never really thought of that before now. Yes totally fine. Both cases. Robins meh to me & less talky more Quake Quake please
But both of those flashbacks had better timing in the story. They happened in the midst of things, not right before stuff got going

Yes. 10000% that. Tell me where the freaks at

Context: They’re enemies.
Fight time:funky:
You must love fairy tail... you are basically describing Fairy tail's plot
 
M

MD Zolo

#51
Never really thought of that before now. Yes totally fine. Both cases. Robins meh to me & less talky more Quake Quake please
But both of those flashbacks had better timing in the story. They happened in the midst of things, not right before stuff got going
Robin's flashback happened before fights started, just like this one.
 
#52
Not really something you can complain about. One Piece flashbacks are usually triggered during emotional moments. Kinemon's desire to take back Wano from Kaido despite the dismal odds is the perfect lead in to Oden's backstory since it will explain why Kinemon is so desperate to defend the Kozuki family name.

If it bothers you so much you can just ignore One Piece until December and then binge read. Unlikely we'll get more than seven or eight chapters for this, and then it's right back to the action.
 
#53
Well wasn't the point of thevflashback explaining Noland not being a liar and how the fairy verth got into Skypiea... Surely there's nothing You expect in the Ryuma flashback to be that important

Like of course its possible for Oda to be keeping his cards to his chest and his waiting to pull out a twist that Ryuma has some very serious direct connection to the events that happened now but as of now that's very unclear... In fact let me help you out and list as many things as we know now that are related to Ryuma and could come up

First of all, Wano was apparently the country of gold during Ryuma's time, and there's this "white gold" in Oden's flashback BUT NONE OF THIS HAS BEEN IMPORTANT IN THE CURRENT STORY

The only other characters we know existed in Ryuma's story are the dragon he cuts down and the World nobles who try to invade wano but again none of the current stories are related to World Nobles and the Dragons in the current story are all just devil fruits

Ryuma is the apparent ancestor originator of the Shimotsuki clan. But so what? The Shimotsuki clan is important sure but what's their history matter? It's the Kozuki who have a history of passing on he information and methods of making poneglyphs... We don't know anything about the Shimotsuki clan passing on any secret techniques or anything so why would their specfically ancestry mater to the current plot

Ryuma's sword shusui is the last and most important thing about Ryuma and it's been kicked out of the plot already and all indications points to it on mattering at the very end of the arc

I mean as of now there's so little that requires a ryuma flashback... at this point it just seem
@Sadistic Senpai
 
M

MD Zolo

#55
Tbf, the scabbards are way more interesting than Oden, and they are not dead (as for now)... they are the reason I don't mind a bit of flashbacks
Hope we get more Denjiro and Kin'emon next chapter
Being dead doesn't diminish the value of the flashback in my opinion. After all, we saw Fisher Tiger and Otohime's flashback and it wasn't bad at all (Otohime was annoying though). Besides, would you say the same of Roger's flashback, he is dead too.
 
#56
Being dead doesn't diminish the value of the flashback in my opinion. After all, we saw Fisher Tiger and Otohime's flashback and it wasn't bad at all (Otohime was annoying though). Besides, would you say the same of Roger's flashback, he is dead too.
Oden is annoying, too, but that's my opinion
Looking forward to Goda showing us why we should care about him or his death...
Showing, not telling
 
#57
I already explained.
It'll be related to WG invading Wano long ago according to Onimaru, and Ryuuma stopping the foreginers from invading trying to protect the City of Gold which Onimaru talked about to Zoro. And Ryuuma along with other Samurai probably were protecting a poneglyph (just like Shandians did, the city of gold in Skypea was not what they are protecting, but rather the poneglyph itself)
I daresay that Wano became isolationist because of their overprotectiveness over the poneglyph they have.
Afterall, Wano is the land where Poneglyphs were created. And it's a land of many secrets and mysteries, even Sengoku emphasized that to Akainu about Wano.

So, it will be a flashback that has those certain points:
1- Kozoki Clan and Zunisha's curse.
2- City of Gold
3- The kozoki skill as stonemasons creating Poneglyphs.
4- WG invading Wano while Ryuuma standing in their way, and basically made WG fears Wano for hundreds of years and basically Ryuuma became like a God to Wano because he stopped WG
5- Wano becoming an isolationist.

I have a feeling that Robin might be the key to opening Wano's borders, just like she told Skypeans that the poneglyph they had served its purpose.
And the old geezer cried and said that "there is no need for fighting anymore"

I think the same will be applied here in that the poneglyph in Wano would have served its purpose by the time Robin reads it, thus Wano's obligation to stay protecting it is NO MORE NEEDED. Thus, the reason it became isolated long ago will no more be needed, allowing its borders to open and elders of Wano accepting it without complaints
 
#58
Seriously? SO MANY OTHER THINGS. The SHs, Elbaf, Raftel, Brooks bone jokes, etc...
Also yeah there’s Oden hype, but Oden or no Oden, this war is already jam packed with meaning
Kaido, after plummeting down from Earth, screamed to the heavens demanding a war to end all wars.
Almost all the big players laid out in Doffys throne wars speech are in place, along with bunches of hidden monsters
The alliance has forces.
The SHs got their power ups.
The snake Orochi has made his move.
Scores need to be settled
Shits bursting at the seams
Oda, Let it out. And PLEASE LET THERE BE TONS OF APOO:poop:
This war will be hyped far more after this flashback. Just wait and see. Also to be honest Oden is hype af.
 
#60
And Ryuuma along with other Samurai probably were protecting a poneglyph
See now this is the point as I was making... This is the sort of statement that is NEEDED to make the Ryuma flashback warranted and yet it hasn't come. As fat as we know, Ryuma could've just been a full blown racist who hurt didn't like outsiders and went on a killing spree... there's no indication that what ryuma was doing back then has much to do with what's up now... the closing of wano's borders is to do wth the Kozuki and poneglyphs, not the country of gold or the shimotsuki or the dragon that Ryuma cut down or black blades

Basically all the things Ryuma is known for still don't have a hook in the current story... As far as I can tell, only the dragon bit is important... because Oda chose to actually even elaborate on it by adding story one thing we never knew (he said ryuma cut the dragon above the flower capital)... Oda added something to dragon cutting meaning there's a chance there's even more to that story... Everything else, the fighting off world nobles hasn't been a factor at all... We haven't seen a world noble talk about wano or have anyone in wano talk about the world nobles in anyone about meaningful way... the only person who did was Orochi when he was threatening the CP-0 guys that not even they can fuck with Kaido... Outside of that, even the CP-0 guys don't care about wano outside of it being Kaido's base of operations where he makes them guns and this is a good very minor plot point that again doesn't have anything to do with Ryuma
 
Top