Status
Not open for further replies.
Blother is a new player, and I suck at reading new players since I give them the benefit of the doubt too much.


Honestly, I think I'm overthinking and confusing myself, so I'll just keep it simple.

If we simply clear the ones who came out early, since it's a basic towny instinct to come out with information as soon as possible, then we can clear Luthon, Lanji, Flower, Beta, Juliet and Light. We can even clear Fuji since he came out with his passive.

that's 7 players cleared, and with 2 dead that leaves 9 unknown:
Me
Salah
Typo
Rhea
Sera
JDB
Tris
Blother
Marimo

Give your scum and town reads from these 9 players.
I narrowed today's pool to 5

Rhea, Salah, Typo,Marimo and Light.

I feel like you cleared Light too fast. All he said is that the kill could've possibly failed on him, it's not a lot to go on to be honest. The way he acted yesterday didn't just disappear to me.

And why Juliet? Because she claimed Rced?
 
do you trust me
or is that just based on the fact that scum wouldnt openly defend a claim like that
I don't trust either, it's just that accusing flower means accusing both of you which will complicate things & there are better players to discuss

Also since you're vouching for her, then when we catch either of you lying, we automatically suspect the other one so it's good for us that you're trust her. Either you're both townies which is great or both scum which helps us later

Anyway, for now, i want Seraphoenix, my third eye tells me he is scum
 

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
I just said something about blother if you read up, had to go iso him fast. He had one good post.

Why JDB?
JDB only tunneled Usopp last phase I believe. He did mention Nat, but I think his main interactions were only with Usopp. I might be wrong on him, but tunneling day 1 is a way that scum pretend to scum hunt. I will have to wait for him to post this day phase to make a read again, but I will be sticking with this for now.

What did Juliet claim/say? Sorry I’m on mobile so I’m prone to missing things
She claimed that she was role crushed for 2 cycles.

This is a contradiction yes, do you think either is lying? I feel like they had no reason to come out the way they did when not even asked.

So if both aren't lying then would that raise the possibility of a redirect on Luthon? If so this should give the both more of a townie lean i guess.
Yeah, Beta definitely had no reason to come out imo. He also said something last phase like Usopp can't be marco if he can't heal himself. That's a weird way of putting it if you ask me.

Luthon, well, his case is very confusing. Apparently, the hosts told him first that Beta visited Fuji, then they said no one visited Fuji. So why vote Beta when Beta said he visited you? I think he should have assumed that he was either redirected or Beta was role blocked first.

But his vote looked genuine, I'm quite confused.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top