Speculations I was wrong about Shanks's sword

[Monet]

so that means shanks is using roger haki

haki man = roger haki

 

[DiscoZoro20]

OK .... I guess I was wrong


many people claimed Shanks have Roger's sword ... and I was disagreeing with that


and when we saw this ... I thought the argument is over

as you can see here (or any official pictures) Roger's sword have a golden grip


so I said ... well it's over cause I've seen this

in anime , games and .... Shanks's sword is Green


While in MANGA

so .... I think don't think they are qiute the same sword ...

but the fact Shanks have a golden grip sword just like his daddy is a detail to be notice by fans


p.s

POST Marineford Shanks ... seems to have SAME SWORD as Roger btw
Shanks's sword as of now was designed in 3 or 4 ways

so I guess Oda is not sure about how it dose look like​

Maaaybe this is actually related to haki and Shanks finally managed to reach the same level of haki mastery as Roger Post-skip.

 

[Red Admiral]

Maaaybe this is actually related to haki and Shanks finally managed to reach the same level of haki mastery as Roger Post-skip.

I like to think ... someone else had Roger's sword after his death ... and Shanks reclaimed it after beating him

 

[DiscoZoro20]

I like to think ... someone else had Roger's sword after his death ... and Shanks reclaimed it after beating him

That is an interesting idea too. Probably more likely than mine too.

 

[Finalbeta]

I like to think ... someone else had Roger's sword after his death ... and Shanks reclaimed it after beating him

I just hope it's a Supreme Grade.

Less enthralled about the substory hehe.

 

[Red Admiral]

I just hope it's a Supreme Grade.

Less enthralled about the substory hehe.

there are 5 members of Rocks pirates who went to rule the seas after their captains

we know 4 of them ; WB , Kaido , Big Mom , Shiki and X (one of other 3 big names)​

the idea of Shanks beat that rocks member , reclaimed Roger's sword and became a Yonko is too good in my eyes
hope Oda listen to me once more​

 

[MarineHQ]

If Gryphon indeed belonged to Roger before, can Mihawk/Zoro bois flip the Enma Argument on Shanks's head ?

 

[Red Admiral]

If Gryphon indeed belonged to Roger before, can Mihawk/Zoro bois flip the Enma Argument on Shanks's head ?

if we get the information about Shanks sword ... it means Shanks Vs Mihawk would be resolved by that point of story

 

[MarineHQ]

if we get the information about Shanks sword ... it means Shanks Vs Mihawk would be resolved by that point of story

?

 

[Red Admiral]

?

I mean .... by that point of story ... we should get a lot more information about Shanks , CoC , Shanks Vs Mihawk and ... by story
it's unlikely for us to get this type of info before those

so there gonna be FAR better arguments to make about Shanks Vs Mihawk ... not this Enma argument that rarely anyone agree with

p.s
and please don't turn this to Shanks Vs Mihawk

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

if we get the information about Shanks sword ... it means Shanks Vs Mihawk would be resolved by that point of story

I mean.....

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

any top tier without a df
you can bet they use a sword
oda needs to diversify weapons they use a bit more.

 

[Finalbeta]

I mean.....

I swear I was looking at that description today. Good thing you preemptively posted it.

 

[Seth]

Using candies logic.

Shanks is only strong because of how much Roger's Haki Gryphon stored up.

Ez.

 

[Red Admiral]

I mean.....

I saw this before as well
but
I mean it's not canon data that story gave us ... these are careful observations

only canon data we got form Oda was it's name

 

[I'mTired]

any top tier without a df
you can bet they use a sword
oda needs to diversify weapons they use a bit more.

Tbf there aren't that many top tiers without a df to begin with

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

Tbf there aren't that many top tiers without a df to begin with

hmmm
roger
rayleigh
shanks
garp
oden
mihawk

this is a sizeble number imo. one person that does not is garp lol. all time ofc
currently the only two are shanks and mihawk.

 

[I'mTired]

hmmm
roger
rayleigh
shanks
garp
oden
mihawk

this is a sizeble number imo. one person that does not is garp lol. all time ofc
currently the only two are shanks and mihawk.

Ye I meant currently ahaha.

As for all time, I might add Gaban and Xebec, maybe Captain John too, but since so little is known about them, I'll refrain from doing so

But again only Gaban doesn't use a sword.

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

Ye I meant currently ahaha.

As for all time, I might add Gaban and Xebec, maybe Captain John too, but since so little is known about them, I'll refrain from doing so

But again only Gaban doesn't use a sword.

am not sure gaban was top tier which is why he's excluded .
xebec might have been like BB with df as well.

 

[I'mTired]

am not sure gaban was top tier which is why he's excluded .
xebec might have been like BB with df as well.

Ye I'm not sure about Gaban either but last we saw him, he was quite enthusiastic about the idea of fighting Oden himself so maybe. Tbh I'm not sure about Oden either, he seemed like a fly in front of WB and Roger ngl, this is a hyperbole comparison but ye.

Anyway we know too little about those characters to make an accurate rating ahaha.