Character Discussion Just another Yamato4nakama theory

#1
First of all i am a pattern believer, so i am going to point out every nakama theories that had been made by other person in the past, and try to tie them up to the possibility of Yamato joining the crew. For those who dont believe in pattern, feel free to believe what you believe.


Second, im a very lazy person, too lazy to put image, and sometimes too lazy to explain things that are already obvious. Also, there might be others that made a thread and pointed all of this, but again I'm so lazy to scroll down. so im sorry for all the inconveniences.


Third, i'll do my best to make it short as I believe most readers here are already familiar with the pattern theories.


Allright lets get going


1. The mfmm pattern.
- In east blue, nami is joining after Zoro
- In Paradise, Robin is joining after Chopper
- In NW, Jimbei is already joining and take the the first male spot in mfmm pattern. Lets stick to the pattern that the next one will be a female.


There are a lot of potential female candidats I know, but im going to stick to Yamato as the female that will join next to Jimbe as She fits the most in every existed patterns.


2. All the females characters have a role that is related to the direction of the journey so that the crew won't get lost.
- Nami is a navigator, no need an explanation here.
- Robin can read Poneglyph, well without her, no-one can read those red poneglyphs which is the key to go to Laughtale.
- As for Yamato, She holds Oden's Journal for 20 years. I believe it will play important role for the strawhats to know which direction they need to take. There must be some important informations related to how to reach Laughtale or at least where to find the last red poneglyph.


3. All the female characters are members of the a pirate crew in which they didn't really want to be a part of.
- Nami was a member of the Sun pirates.
- Robin was a member of baroque works.
- Yamato is a member of the beast pirates.


4. The alphabet pattern.
This will sound farfetched for Yamato to fit in the pattern, but I believe Oda intentionally put some Twist on his patterns such as Yamato consider herself as a man and she consider herself as 'Oden'.


Alright here it goes the pattern :
AB Brook
CD Chopper
EF Franky
GH ????
IJ Jimbe
KL Luffy
MN Nami
OP ????
QR Robin
ST Sanji
UV Ussop
WX ????
YZ Zoro


I believe Yamato will fit the OP slot as She consider herself as 'Oden'. Yea as I said it sounds farfecthed, but it is just my opinion.


I know that Pudding also fit that slot if it is only by her name, but her devil fruit doesn't fit the gorowase patterns that appeared in SBS (I forgot which volume and too lazy to do some research. And I won't point out that pattern in this theory as it isn't confirmed that Yamato has a devil fruit.)


I know Carrot's fan will say that OP can stand for Carrot with an excuse of her inheriting Pedro's will but She never consider herself as Pedro, yet Yamato keep calling herself 'Oden'.


5. Parallel to Chinese novel, Journey to the West.


I think it is obvious that the manga is a parallel of that novel, there has been so many theories about this even a really good one mentioning that both story is a journey from east to the the west ( China to India, East blue to Laughtale).


So let's see the parallel of that novel with Shs crew :


- Luffy as Sun wukong, the Monkey king, obvious.
- Sanji as Zhu Bajie, the pig (Woman lover, related to food)
- Jimbei as Sha Wujing, (both are water creature that become stronger when they are underwater)
- Zoro as Tang Sanzang, the monk, ( it is an interesting twist that in the novel, it was the monk that freed Sun wukong from the mountain prison, and in the manga it was Luffy who freed Zoro from Morgan's prison as if the monkey King freed the monk)


- There is another character in that novel, which is the white dragon horse that carried Tang Sanzang throughout the journey. And in that novel, the horse is the son of the Dragon King. We know who is the dragon here in the manga and he also have a child. So Yamato represent the white dragon horse.


As for color scheme, animals, and other patterns, I'm just too lazy to do the research and to point them out, again, I'm sorry.


So that's it. For me, Yamato is joining. Hopefully you guys enjoy the read and I'm sorry for my bad English and grammatical mistakes.

I might not respond to all of the commentary if somehow anyone is interested enough to drop a comment or two, please excuse my incredible laziness for that. My main purpose is just to express my thought.
 
Last edited:
#2
She has read the log and knows the secrets of Laugh Tale, that disqualifies her I think, also her being stronger than Zoro puts it in a bit of an awkward position. I think she'll help Momo out in Wano first.
Tama might be more likely because of the promise with Ace and the fact everyone on the crew who has met her loves her deeply.
 
#4
I like your theory with the alphabet but I think it is just coincidence since oda is japanese.
Doesn't change the fact that he knows English alphabets as well :)
10 out of 13 is a bit too much for a coincidence I guess
Post automatically merged:

She has read the log and knows the secrets of Laugh Tale, that disqualifies her I think, also her being stronger than Zoro puts it in a bit of an awkward position. I think she'll help Momo out in Wano first.
Tama might be more likely because of the promise with Ace and the fact everyone on the crew who has met her loves her deeply.
It might be true. But anyway Robin was also stronger than everyone when the crew first met her.
 
#6
Secrets aren't written there for sure... If any, the ones written there are "questions" or those which they aren't sure (as Rayleigh pointed out)...



Really? Can Yamato do what Zoro did against Kaido and the way he tanked Hakai?
Zoro didn't tank the Hakai. Blocked for 1 second, got hit and now 30 bones are broken. The complete opposite of "tank".
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
#13
She has read the log and knows the secrets of Laugh Tale, that disqualifies her I think, also her being stronger than Zoro puts it in a bit of an awkward position. I think she'll help Momo out in Wano first.
Tama might be more likely because of the promise with Ace and the fact everyone on the crew who has met her loves her deeply.
Have you ever seen a movie based on a book you read? Just to view with your own eyes things and places you could only mentally envision based on a written description? Y’all act like reading about Laugh Tale is the same in-story as it is for the fan base, but Yamato clearly wants to go there to watch the dawn that Oden never got to witness, and it’s not that hard to understand why :kayneshrug:
 
#14
Have you ever seen a movie based on a book you read? Just to view with your own eyes things and places you could only mentally envision based on a written description? Y’all act like reading about Laugh Tale is the same in-story as it is for the fan base, but Yamato clearly wants to go there to watch the dawn that Oden never got to witness, and it’s not that hard to understand why :kayneshrug:
It's not just that, both that and for her own self... She's getting to roam free. From being cooped up on a island for 20 years to having the freedom to explore the world free of shackles etc...
And given that she's met Ace and then kept up to knowledge of the Strawhats, only for her to not join. That's just a big red herring if anything.
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
#15
It's not just that, both that and for her own self... She's getting to roam free. From being cooped up on a island for 20 years to having the freedom to explore the world free of shackles etc...
And given that she's met Ace and then kept up to knowledge of the Strawhats, only for her to not join. That's just a big red herring if anything.
I know that’s not her only motivation, I’m just saying it’s a weak argument that because she read Oden’s logbook, she wouldn’t want to go to Laugh Tale or the crew wouldn’t let her tag along. As far as the rest, well...to turn a famous phrase, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar; Oda setting up all he’s giving to Yamato only for it to not pay off would be a hilarious kick in the balls, and his most egregious narrative decision to date.
 
#17
Zoro didn't tank the Hakai. Blocked for 1 second, got hit and now 30 bones are broken. The complete opposite of "tank".
Still, can Yamato block that attack for a second, break less than 20-30 bones, still be conscious and deliver a devastating attack to one of them? We know Yamato always lose against Kaido and we see no signs of permanent damage on Kaido from Yamato...

Have you ever seen a movie based on a book you read? Just to view with your own eyes things and places you could only mentally envision based on a written description? Y’all act like reading about Laugh Tale is the same in-story as it is for the fan base, but Yamato clearly wants to go there to watch the dawn that Oden never got to witness, and it’s not that hard to understand why :kayneshrug:
This...

From a perspective of someone who reads spoilers of anything (manga, series, movies, novels, etc.), even if I know stuffs that will happen, most of the time the way we think it unfolds is totally different because actually seeing it is different from just reading it somewhere by someone with different perspective than us... It's quite like the concept of "pass the message" something game...

It's not just that, both that and for her own self... She's getting to roam free. From being cooped up on a island for 20 years to having the freedom to explore the world free of shackles etc...
And given that she's met Ace and then kept up to knowledge of the Strawhats, only for her to not join. That's just a big red herring if anything.
If any, it's a setup to know why Rayleigh thinks that their interpretation might be wrong... And I think they really can be wrong or at least missed something out...

Besides, do you think Roger will allow someone to write very important details and that Oden will not honor that? He doesn't even want an Eternal Pose for Laugh Tale to be made...

Do you think Shanks and Buggy never asked about it, especially the latter? We are certain they knew some stuffs (but not everything) as well...
 
#18
If she look like Yoruichi in her hybrid form then I have to put her in top 2 best girl Lmao.
Hmm, depends... is it up to my standards.
Post automatically merged:

Still, can Yamato block that attack for a second, break less than 20-30 bones, still be conscious and deliver a devastating attack to one of them? We know Yamato always lose against Kaido and we see no signs of permanent damage on Kaido from Yamato...



This...

From a perspective of someone who reads spoilers of anything (manga, series, movies, novels, etc.), even if I know stuffs that will happen, most of the time the way we think it unfolds is totally different because actually seeing it is different from just reading it somewhere by someone with different perspective than us... It's quite like the concept of "pass the message" something game...



If any, it's a setup to know why Rayleigh thinks that their interpretation might be wrong... And I think they really can be wrong or at least missed something out...

Besides, do you think Roger will allow someone to write very important details and that Oden will not honor that? He doesn't even want an Eternal Pose for Laugh Tale to be made...

Do you think Shanks and Buggy never asked about it, especially the latter? We are certain they knew some stuffs (but not everything) as well...
Is there any damage left on Yamato? You'd think she'd be a lifer to being crippled if always getting beaten by her father. What doesn't kill you makes you stronger.
Sure that's not an actual thing but I think it still applies.
 
#19
Oda surely wants us to believe that Yamato will join. I will just say that,but i wont add more because some people seem to get too angry when i add more to this...
Nah chill dude, feel free to point anything out, if they get angry so be it. Express yourself. As I said, I'm making this thread with a purpose of expressing my thoughts, if Yamato is joining, then I'm right, if not, then I'm wrong. As simple as that.
 
Top