There's no good guys and bad guys in one piece
@TheAncientCenturion remind these peeps about Doffy's speech smh
Xebec was probably an anti-hero at best. I thinn he wanted to kill Celestial Dragons but caused too much damage
He was probably a bit like Kid
Lol, in that arc of the story, I actually believe Xebec was Luffy, while Roger was Kid. I mean we can already see Roger's manners in this chapter, we can already remember Garp stating the Roger destroyed an entire country just because someone badmouthed a crew member. That's something a villain does. Roger was the one who killed Squard entire crew.
I can't believe that people see Roger here as the saint who NEVER question if he was actually the right side of the matter or wrong
And NO, I do believe that there is right and wrong, there is good and evil. Doffy's speech is meant to stimulate your thinking, not overtake it and simply become a worshipper. It's meant to make you see the big picture. But doing evil acts, is EVIL, as simple as that, and doing good deeds is good. So, there is good and there is evil.
And One Piece characters fall inbetween those two terms "good and evil". But it's like a scale. Where you can fall ANYWHERE inbetween those two terms. Cause no one is purely good with no bad qualities or purely evil with no good qualities. But in that scale, you can be closer to evil or more far away. but still on the side of evil.
So, te gray area simply is too wide, and you can fall anywhere. But there is evil, and there is good, and Doffy's speech is meant for you to understand the other side of the coin and to understand other people view, but not that whatever you do, it's not evil or good. That's a villain speech after all, just meant to stimulate your thought and not blindly follow him. That's why he's a good villain, cause some people go word by word for him and obey his words LOL