General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Vivi fits all Of the criteria
Nami Robin - Vivi
Usopp Franky - Bellamy
Bellamys a better fit then law for that role. Laws not a craftsman.
For Brook and Sanji the only overlying connection is the pervert gags. But I think it’ll be another individual from paradise
Post automatically merged:
Nami Robin - Vivi
Usopp Franky - Bellamy
Bellamys a better fit then law for that role. Laws not a craftsman.
For Brook and Sanji the only overlying connection is the pervert gags. But I think it’ll be another individual from paradise
Last edited:
You know what, im not a fan of this parallel thingy, luffys crew doesnt have to be paralleled to rogers crew
In this fandom, I think they being so much into these parallels that at some point they're losing it essence,
It's easy to say that certain character is parallel another one because youre nitpicking what's similar in them. But that disregarding the fact that there are tons of characteristics that make them entirely different, but this fandom would take it as if its parallel just because there are certain similiarities as they try to make things fit on what they believe in.
I can directly say robin is paralleled to oden based on what you said, but I can also say otherwise since they're still different.
Robin didnt want to go to adventure because she wants to. SHE HAD TO, since shes being hunted by WG. Oden is not like that
Oden was a heir of a certain kindom oppressed by a pirate crew, Robin was not.
Robin joined Crocs crew for protection and hide against WG, the same when she first joined SH prior to events in Enies Lobby. Oden was carefree and just wanted adventure.
See. You can be subjective on who is parallel and who is not, and fit it conveniently to your beliefs.
The only parallelism I believe Oda is making an effort to do was Roger and Luffy, and it was depicted in panels. I remember this scene during the meeting of roger, wb and oden, the reaction of oden and wb to what roger said was exactly the same with sabo and ace reaction to what Luffy said when they re still kids. You also have to note that even the bandages of oden and wb was similar to sabo and ace. That's an undeniably parallelism.
But the others, just like what you mentioned, you only nitpicked similarities
In this fandom, I think they being so much into these parallels that at some point they're losing it essence,
It's easy to say that certain character is parallel another one because youre nitpicking what's similar in them. But that disregarding the fact that there are tons of characteristics that make them entirely different, but this fandom would take it as if its parallel just because there are certain similiarities as they try to make things fit on what they believe in.
I can directly say robin is paralleled to oden based on what you said, but I can also say otherwise since they're still different.
Robin didnt want to go to adventure because she wants to. SHE HAD TO, since shes being hunted by WG. Oden is not like that
Oden was a heir of a certain kindom oppressed by a pirate crew, Robin was not.
Robin joined Crocs crew for protection and hide against WG, the same when she first joined SH prior to events in Enies Lobby. Oden was carefree and just wanted adventure.
See. You can be subjective on who is parallel and who is not, and fit it conveniently to your beliefs.
The only parallelism I believe Oda is making an effort to do was Roger and Luffy, and it was depicted in panels. I remember this scene during the meeting of roger, wb and oden, the reaction of oden and wb to what roger said was exactly the same with sabo and ace reaction to what Luffy said when they re still kids. You also have to note that even the bandages of oden and wb was similar to sabo and ace. That's an undeniably parallelism.
But the others, just like what you mentioned, you only nitpicked similarities
Well to be fair, even if Im in for Yamato for SH, im not a fan of Yamato is to oden parallel. Im still putting my bet on Yamato though for am entirely different reasons and not for just mere parallelism.
So carrot is to inu neko, parallel or yamato, is to oden, or robin is to oden, or whatever parallelism, hold no value, as to who will be the next sh.
Whoever will ne the next sh, they have to be relevant to plot, from the moment they were introduced until joining the sh, up until the end of series.
So carrot is to inu neko, parallel or yamato, is to oden, or robin is to oden, or whatever parallelism, hold no value, as to who will be the next sh.
Whoever will ne the next sh, they have to be relevant to plot, from the moment they were introduced until joining the sh, up until the end of series.
I said this before, characters aren't important because they're Straw Hats, they're Straw Hats because they're important to the grand scheme of the story. Oda had most of the crew planned out for a reason, anybody that is not part of the original sketch needs to have a grand role in the story because we already know Oda planned out the OG group from the beginning
Yamato is definetily joining!Momonosuke might tag along as an apprentice,if this happens,1 of the sccabards might join too to be his bodyguard!
Do you guys think Emerald city will be a thing or Oda will forget about this!Emerald city must be Laugh Tale,that is the only way i see Oda implementing this without dragging the story ou!
Post automatically merged:
Do you guys think Emerald city will be a thing or Oda will forget about this!Emerald city must be Laugh Tale,that is the only way i see Oda implementing this without dragging the story ou!
Is 'misdirection' a better word then? The point I was making was that Yamato being the bait for the real Nakama Carrot never made sense in the first place, because Carrot was introduced first before Yamato. What is the surprise of Carrot as Nakama if she's been present for more than 2 and a half arcs now?
Dizzy was the one who started calling Yamato as a Red Herring, i was just following where he left off.
I also disagree with you that Yamato would be a Red Herring, imo there is no other narrative possibility that makes logical sense for her to not join the crew, stay on Wano or leave herself otherwise. Logically speaking, Yamato NOT able to join the crew can only happen if she dies on Wano, and the chances of that happening imo are almost zero.
Yamato ain't dying to no names like CP0 because we haven't even seen who they really are, plus if CP0 is gonna finish off anyone this arc, Who's Who already fits this purpose.
Kaido ain't killing Yamato, intentionally or accidently. Kaido won't kill Yamato intentionally because he still needs her to rule Wano, and the chances of Kaido killing Yamato accidently are also unlikely considering how durable Yamato's zoan devil fruit is, if Ulti doesn't even die from Big Mom's laser beam, then Yamato ain't dying to one of Kaido's clubs that didn't even kill Kinemon.
Saying that Yamato is a Red Herring is a poor argument imo that has no logical basis and is lacking in facts. I can also ask you what narrative purpose would Yamato have being a Red Herring?
Dizzy was the one who started calling Yamato as a Red Herring, i was just following where he left off.
I also disagree with you that Yamato would be a Red Herring, imo there is no other narrative possibility that makes logical sense for her to not join the crew, stay on Wano or leave herself otherwise. Logically speaking, Yamato NOT able to join the crew can only happen if she dies on Wano, and the chances of that happening imo are almost zero.
Yamato ain't dying to no names like CP0 because we haven't even seen who they really are, plus if CP0 is gonna finish off anyone this arc, Who's Who already fits this purpose.
Kaido ain't killing Yamato, intentionally or accidently. Kaido won't kill Yamato intentionally because he still needs her to rule Wano, and the chances of Kaido killing Yamato accidently are also unlikely considering how durable Yamato's zoan devil fruit is, if Ulti doesn't even die from Big Mom's laser beam, then Yamato ain't dying to one of Kaido's clubs that didn't even kill Kinemon.
Saying that Yamato is a Red Herring is a poor argument imo that has no logical basis and is lacking in facts. I can also ask you what narrative purpose would Yamato have being a Red Herring?
Nah. Bellamy is going to be a straw hat. When Oda separated the Straw Hats from the Grand Fleet, Bellamy went with the straw hats. Bellamys the only one who Luffy calls a friend. Bellamy is building Luffy an indestructible flag which fits with when franky joined he gave Luffy a nigh indestructible ship.
If Bellamy returns he’ll return as a straw hat.
If Bellamy returns he’ll return as a straw hat.
- Status