[FNZ] Role Madness [Season 2] Round 13 - Harry Potter

[Jew D. Boy]

But sigh, no choice at this point

Nick is Harry Potter. If you think scum began the game with that knowledge, you are insane

All right, so this makes me think a few things:

• You’re telling the truth about your role and his, which is possible if not increasingly unlikely and also means you just made him and yourself sitting ducks when you could have claimed without immediately revealing your roles
• You’re lying about your role and telling the truth about his; this would lead me to believe you are the one who must not be named, and you knew this from the start for contextual reasons
• You’re lying about your role AND his, in the hopes that someone will believe it and try to protect him when he’s actually the Voldy guy, or that we’ll look for others instead of continuing to monitor your actions or lynch you outright

Which one of these sounds best to you??

 

[Grammaton]

It isn’t like this is EOD and you are the leading wagon though. There was minimal pressure to claim something like that.

I weighed it up against wasting a day phase

 

[Seraphoenix]

Nope

Yes.

 

[Seraphoenix]

Voldemort's goal is to kill Harry and this guy apparently just outed Harry

 

[Dr_Professor83]

You’re lying about your role AND his, in the hopes that someone will believe it and try to protect him when he’s actually the Voldy guy, or that we’ll look for others instead of continuing to monitor your actions or lynch you outright

This is almost assuredly only possible if Dest was Harry.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

There's another hote take he realized he's outted and fake claimed Nick Harry so real one might out himself.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

This is almost assuredly only possible if Dest was Harry.

Which I don’t think he was, I’m just saying that it could be a ploy to that end.

 

[Grammaton]

All right, so this makes me think a few things:

• You’re telling the truth about your role and his, which is possible if not increasingly unlikely and also means you just made him and yourself sitting ducks when you could have claimed without immediately revealing your roles
• You’re lying about your role and telling the truth about his; this would lead me to believe you are the one who must not be named, and you knew this from the start for contextual reasons
• You’re lying about your role AND his, in the hopes that someone will believe it and try to protect him when he’s actually the Voldy guy, or that we’ll look for others instead of continuing to monitor your actions or lynch you outright

Which one of these sounds best to you??

Well option 3 sounds dumb cause the real Harry Potter would know it’s untrue and that’d be 2 mafia down for basically nothing, so I don’t even see why you’d put that on the table

If you think I’m Voldemort, that would kinda make sense from a thematic point of view but would make for a somewhat unfair game if scum knew who their biggest threat was without having to do anything whatsoever to find out

As for point 1, you can’t ask me for a full claim and then complain when you (and I use town as you) get it. I warned you up front that full claiming would be bad for everyone

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

There's another hote take he realized he's outted and fake claimed Nick Harry so real one might out himself.

But doubt Harry role is that good to cost two scums

 

[Dr_Professor83]

There's another hote take he realized he's outted and fake claimed Nick Harry so real one might out himself.

Well if Nick is Town then Nick would vote to lynch him. And if Nick isn’t Town then this is the earliest double scum suicide conceivable.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

And if this is true Nick is going to be very pissed.

 

[ConquistadoR]

As for point 1, you can’t ask me for a full claim and then complain when you (and I use town as you) get it. I warned you up front that full claiming would be bad for everyone

He asked you for your ability names lol. Nobody asked you to out HP.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

but would make for a somewhat unfair game if scum knew who their biggest threat was without having to do anything whatsoever to find out

Well if you’re town that part has been handled lol.

 

[Grammaton]

Well if you’re town that part has been handled lol.

Again if I flip, it would have been easy to piece together anyway

 

[Grammaton]

He asked you for your ability names lol. Nobody asked you to out HP.

I was asked to give a full claim before that

 

[Dr_Professor83]

He asked you for your ability names lol. Nobody asked you to out HP.

Lol this. No one asked for Nick’s role. I understand not wanting to get lynched or “waste a day” but outting Harry should have been an absolute last ditch resort.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Again if I flip, it would have been easy to piece together anyway

But you weren’t in that much danger of being flipped yet. You hit the big red button almost immediately with 2 votes on you and others just speculating.

 

[Rhea]

Vote Count :

Jew D. Boy : Grammaton -> Unvote
T-Pein : Seraphoenix
Ratchet : Grammaton -> Unvote
Nick : Grammaton
Yo Tan Wa : Grammaton
Seraphoenix : Grammaton

Grammaton : 3
Seraphoenix : 1

Please let me know if I made any mistakes with the votes or the tags didn't works.

Spoiler: Players Alive

@Sallucion @DynaMight @Seraphoenix @Xlaw @Grammaton @Marimo_420 @ConquistadoR @Rej @Ryu Kishi @Ratchet @Gambit @Lord Melkor @Nick @T-Pein™ @Jew D. Boy @Yo Tan Wa @Dr_Professor83

 

[ConquistadoR]

I was asked to give a full claim before that

Yeah and why would you claim who HP is before your own abilities?

Scum knowing your abilities would probably lead to a roleblock maybe or put a target on your back. HP is literally his target if the game goes by flavour lol.

This either poor play from Gram (which I doubt it) or Dest was HP and scum got lucky during N1

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Okay 3 votes. Forgot about Nick. But he wasn’t here for your opening claim.