General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
........
Yes it does. That "little goal system" are the most objective and narrative parameters related to ALL the strawhats.
Those parameters are important because EACH of them plays a narrative role into the characterization of said strawhat, by himself and through the crew.
Those are therefore the most logical parameters to take into account when discussing the similarity between the strawhat .. in order to predict the recrutment of one of them.
You can reject the obvious if you don't want to listen because it hurt your narrative and agenda.... it won't make those dissapear.
I didn't choose them, Oda did.
And in the end, if you keep blinding yourself, you will only be met with dissapointment.
For example, you will have hard time understanding why Yamato is not recruted by Luffy at the end of Wano.
Those parameters are important because EACH of them plays a narrative role into the characterization of said strawhat, by himself and through the crew.
Those are therefore the most logical parameters to take into account when discussing the similarity between the strawhat .. in order to predict the recrutment of one of them.
You can reject the obvious if you don't want to listen because it hurt your narrative and agenda.... it won't make those dissapear.
I didn't choose them, Oda did.
And in the end, if you keep blinding yourself, you will only be met with dissapointment.
For example, you will have hard time understanding why Yamato is not recruted by Luffy at the end of Wano.
No. You’re wrong. This is an example of bad faith argument. Carrot hasn’t been shown to be able to be invisible. She’s in her sulong form and glides really fast from 1 frame to another for the whole opening, that you all can’t see her wonder. Only me, an ultimate Carrot fan, can see that she does that. You need to see the context of the opening to subvert expectations as a surprise factor
Last edited:
Yes it does. That "little goal system" are the most objective and narrative parameters related to ALL the strawhats.
Those parameters are important because EACH of them plays a narrative role into the characterization of said strawhat, by himself and through the crew.
Those are therefore the most logical parameters to take into account when discussing the similarity between the strawhat .. in order to predict the recrutment of one of them.
You can reject the obvious if you don't want to listen because it hurt your narrative and agenda.... it won't make those dissapear.
I didn't choose them, Oda did.
And in the end, if you keep blinding yourself, you will only be met with dissapointment.
For example, you will have hard time understanding why Yamato is not recruted by Luffy at the end of Wano.
Those parameters are important because EACH of them plays a narrative role into the characterization of said strawhat, by himself and through the crew.
Those are therefore the most logical parameters to take into account when discussing the similarity between the strawhat .. in order to predict the recrutment of one of them.
You can reject the obvious if you don't want to listen because it hurt your narrative and agenda.... it won't make those dissapear.
I didn't choose them, Oda did.
And in the end, if you keep blinding yourself, you will only be met with dissapointment.
For example, you will have hard time understanding why Yamato is not recruted by Luffy at the end of Wano.
Mr. Berry Rich, it's nice to see you again 
Been awhile since OJ.I see you are not a fan of Yamato.
Post automatically merged:
Pedro may have other students besides being Pedro's student doesn't mean she is a Top 10 Mink.
Hmm... well the Vivre Card says she learned with control young so she is ahead of the curve in that respect. It doesn't say her Sulong form multiplies her base more than other Minks. My point still stands as of her being a genius isn't stated. It is your implication.
Sulong enhances the base. Base Carrot <= Base Wanda < Base Sicilian.
Doesn't seem likely. Visible full moonlight seems to be the power trigger. Chopper had to use a Rumble Ball for years for his transformations.
Sulong Carrot AND Sulong Wanda had a shot not singular Carrot.
Carrot has not been displayed as a powerful mink. The trigger could be the moonlight energy so the moon must be visibly seen for transformation. This possibility you present has no allusion from the material. If it were just a memory trigger, than the Minks could just look at a picture of a full moon to transform or envision it in their mind.
What Haki? Carrot doesn't posses any. Not saying she couldn't develop it but her having haki at age 15 seems unlikely as someone with that capability IMO would be treated as more capable.
Infinite sure but not probable. Lightning Kamehameha is awesome but why give that to Carrot? Why not Dog or Cat?
Electro has been displayed poorly IMO. So much potential but has been underutilized.
Jinbe is not losing to Carrot be her Strawhat or not.
Last edited:
Lmao, you have a lot to learn.
You'r cute
Post automatically merged:
You'r cute
Your narrative is nothing but wishful thinking and a great deal of bias. Give it up, even children would realize this.
Unlikely. Carrot is one Mink with a green cape. Meaning that she is the only musketeer with "a guardian hearth", that should mean that she was the only musketeer trained by a guardian.
You are right, genius my be a stretch but it's a logical appreciation when ther VIvre card says that "The mastery of Sulong to such a young age is unusual"
Tho I didn't said that Sulong was multiplying her base ability.
Yes she was. by being put against Zoro first. Oda narratively made a point about her strenght. Plus, remember what the light of the moon is. It's just the sun reflection on the moon. There might be more to the Sulong transformation that just that.
Why not ? Being able to use Sulong at the age of 15 is also unlikely. So having Haki for Carrot wouldn't be a stretch.
Because Carrot's Sulong design might be directly inspired by Goku's Saiyan 3 form. The Sulong being also inspired by the Ozaru transformation, giving Carrot a form of Kamehameha would be more that fitting. (and mega cool lol)
Also remember, we are talking here of the case if Carrot was a future strawhat. In that matter, she is bound to surpass the capacities of Inu and Neko in term of originality.
Also this would not be such a stretch as Carrot's Electrical Luna begin also like a Kamehameha at first
I wouldn't say poorly but I agree yeah
Lmao I don't even know why I reply to you, it's completely useless, you are unable to understand
Feel like in your case, you will have to experience the reality of the writings of Oda.
So sad..
Narratively carrot is logical, and she has done more in whole cake that Brook in his own arc of recrutment. So there is no reason to feel that Carrot joining is unearned. Now.. being absent from an arc doesn't negate what has been written. The narration doesn't forget.
And we are not talking here about a real recrutment, just a joining by stowaway. Carrot's moment will come after that.
They have no idea
You are right, genius my be a stretch but it's a logical appreciation when ther VIvre card says that "The mastery of Sulong to such a young age is unusual"
Tho I didn't said that Sulong was multiplying her base ability.
Yes she was. by being put against Zoro first. Oda narratively made a point about her strenght. Plus, remember what the light of the moon is. It's just the sun reflection on the moon. There might be more to the Sulong transformation that just that.
Why not ? Being able to use Sulong at the age of 15 is also unlikely. So having Haki for Carrot wouldn't be a stretch.
Because Carrot's Sulong design might be directly inspired by Goku's Saiyan 3 form. The Sulong being also inspired by the Ozaru transformation, giving Carrot a form of Kamehameha would be more that fitting. (and mega cool lol)
Also remember, we are talking here of the case if Carrot was a future strawhat. In that matter, she is bound to surpass the capacities of Inu and Neko in term of originality.
Also this would not be such a stretch as Carrot's Electrical Luna begin also like a Kamehameha at first
I wouldn't say poorly but I agree yeah
Post automatically merged:
Lmao I don't even know why I reply to you, it's completely useless, you are unable to understand
Feel like in your case, you will have to experience the reality of the writings of Oda.
So sad..
Post automatically merged:
Narratively carrot is logical, and she has done more in whole cake that Brook in his own arc of recrutment. So there is no reason to feel that Carrot joining is unearned. Now.. being absent from an arc doesn't negate what has been written. The narration doesn't forget.
And we are not talking here about a real recrutment, just a joining by stowaway. Carrot's moment will come after that.
Post automatically merged:
They have no idea
Unlikely. Carrot is one Mink with a green cape. Meaning that she is the only musketeer with "a guardian hearth", that should mean that she was the only musketeer trained by a guardian.
You are right, genius my be a stretch but it's a logical appreciation when ther VIvre card says that "The mastery of Sulong to such a young age is unusual"
Tho I didn't said that Sulong was multiplying her base ability.
Yes she was. by being put against Zoro first. Oda narratively made a point about her strenght. Plus, remember what the light of the moon is. It's just the sun reflection on the moon. There might be more to the Sulong transformation that just that.
Why not ? Being able to use Sulong at the age of 15 is also unlikely. So having Haki for Carrot wouldn't be a stretch.
Because Carrot's Sulong design might be directly inspired by Goku's Saiyan 3 form. The Sulong being also inspired by the Ozaru transformation, giving Carrot a form of Kamehameha would be more that fitting. (and mega cool lol)
Also remember, we are talking here of the case if Carrot was a future strawhat. In that matter, she is bound to surpass the capacities of Inu and Neko in term of originality.
Also this would not be such a stretch as Carrot's Electrical Luna begin also like a Kamehameha at first
I wouldn't say poorly but I agree yeah
Lmao I don't even know why I reply to you, it's completely useless, you are unable to understand
Feel like in your case, you will have to experience the reality of the writings of Oda.
So sad..
Narratively carrot is logical, and she has done more in whole cake that Brook in his own arc of recrutment. So there is no reason to feel that Carrot joining is unearned. Now.. being absent from an arc doesn't negate what has been written. The narration doesn't forget.
And we are not talking here about a real recrutment, just a joining by stowaway. Carrot's moment will come after that.
You are right, genius my be a stretch but it's a logical appreciation when ther VIvre card says that "The mastery of Sulong to such a young age is unusual"
Tho I didn't said that Sulong was multiplying her base ability.
Yes she was. by being put against Zoro first. Oda narratively made a point about her strenght. Plus, remember what the light of the moon is. It's just the sun reflection on the moon. There might be more to the Sulong transformation that just that.
Why not ? Being able to use Sulong at the age of 15 is also unlikely. So having Haki for Carrot wouldn't be a stretch.
Because Carrot's Sulong design might be directly inspired by Goku's Saiyan 3 form. The Sulong being also inspired by the Ozaru transformation, giving Carrot a form of Kamehameha would be more that fitting. (and mega cool lol)
Also remember, we are talking here of the case if Carrot was a future strawhat. In that matter, she is bound to surpass the capacities of Inu and Neko in term of originality.
Also this would not be such a stretch as Carrot's Electrical Luna begin also like a Kamehameha at first
I wouldn't say poorly but I agree yeah
Post automatically merged:
Lmao I don't even know why I reply to you, it's completely useless, you are unable to understand
Feel like in your case, you will have to experience the reality of the writings of Oda.
So sad..
Post automatically merged:
Narratively carrot is logical, and she has done more in whole cake that Brook in his own arc of recrutment. So there is no reason to feel that Carrot joining is unearned. Now.. being absent from an arc doesn't negate what has been written. The narration doesn't forget.
And we are not talking here about a real recrutment, just a joining by stowaway. Carrot's moment will come after that.
Carrot had no talent in swordsmanship so Pedro taught her how to use the gloves.
- Status