General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Monkey D Al]

No, assume your sexism

 

[Logiko]

 

[jordin]

Another nakama ad
The rough translation of the headline is "Yamato becomes a nakama?!"

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1501860420314800137

This is not the first time they had nakama talk as her headlining question either. Unlike this one, the new one has an editor there as well.

 

[Logiko]

Another nakama ad
The rough translation of the headline is "Yamato becomes a nakama?!"

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1501860420314800137

This is not the first time they had nakama talk as her headlining question either. Unlike this one, the new one has an editor there as well.

Lmao golden. Oda and his team are such trolls

 

[Monkey D Al]

Another nakama ad
The rough translation of the headline is "Yamato becomes a nakama?!"

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1501860420314800137

This is not the first time they had nakama talk as her headlining question either. Unlike this one, the new one has an editor there as well.

She’s basically already confirmed. Every one piece fan with a normal functioning brain can see that.

Post automatically merged: Mar 10, 2022

Lmao golden. Oda and his team are such trolls

No you’re just delusional

 

[jordin]

Lmao golden. Oda and his team are such trolls

I know. They had people really thinking Carrot would join

 

[Logiko]

She’s basically already confirmed. Every one piece fan with a normal functioning brain can see that.

Post automatically merged: Mar 10, 2022

No you’re just delusional

What is the best that can happen for an author:

That the next big revelation is discovered and discussed by the fanbase and put on adds by the editing team?

Or

That everyone has taken a narrative bait .. leaving the author the room to do whatever they wants?

 

[Staticshadic]

What is the best that can happen for an author:

That the next big revelation is discovered and discussed by the fanbase and put on adds by the editing team?

Or

That everyone has taken a narrative bait .. leaving the author the room to do whatever they wants?

Your jealous because your precious bunny girl not relevant not talk about as much

 

[Logiko]

Your jealous because your precious bunny girl not relevant not talk about as much

That doesn't answer my question

 

[Monkey D Al]

What is the best that can happen for an author:

That the next big revelation is discovered and discussed by the fanbase and put on adds by the editing team?

Or

That everyone has taken a narrative bait .. leaving the author the room to do whatever they wants?

The best thing that can happen to an author is that people take such interest in his story, analyze it so good that they can predict what will happen. And that is that Yamato will join.
By now Oda has surprised us so often, that actually doing the predictable is the unpredictable.

I don’t know if this to much work for you brain

 

[Logiko]

The best thing that can happen to an author is that people take such interest in his story, analyze it so good that they can predict what will happen. And that is that Yamato will join.

There is no need for analysis here tho. Remember what you guyz are always saying ? "It's written in the story that Yamato will join the crew" There is therefore no need for analysis here, it's not even remotely "predictible", it's literally WRITTEN black on white. There is no surprise.

So.. Do you think that a revelation without surprise is a good revelation ? Do you really think Oda would do a revelation with no surprise ?

 

[jordin]

Yall remember when Oda himself called Franky a SH right at the beginning of Enies Lobby and video games were also lumping him with the crew before he joined so they can fuel the narrative bait for Paulie?

Also the narrative bait, Brook, who immediately got accepted into the crew on introduction and served to cover up for Perona

Or Jinbe, who promised to join the crew but was meant to die and be the narrative bait for Carrot in WCI

 

[Staticshadic]

Yall remember when Oda himself called Franky a SH right at the beginning of Enies Lobby and video games were also lumping him with the crew before he joined so they can fuel the narrative bait for Paulie?

Also the narrative bait, Brook, who immediately got accepted into the crew on introduction and served to cover up for Perona

Or Jinbe, who promised to join the crew but was meant to die and be the narrative bait for Carrot in WCI

Carrot4nakama: paulie going join there no way Franky will join the crew.

 

[Logiko]

Yall remember when Oda himself called Franky a SH right at the beginning of Enies Lobby

Do you have a quote from Oda calling Franky a strawhat at the beginning of Ennie Lobby ?

Because if the "proof" you have is that Oda is putting Franky with the Strawhat, I can easily do that with Carrot too. Remember that characters in the story literally put Carrot WITH the strawhats ?

Also the narrative bait, Brook, who immediately got accepted into the crew on introduction and served to cover up for Perona

Or Jinbe, who promised to join the crew but was meant to die and be the narrative bait for Carrot in WCI

You are forgetting here that each revelations was a surprise. Brook with the question of Luffy, With the question Luffy to Jinbe, With the Franky Family favor.

Yamato wouldn't be a surprise at all.

Carrot on the other hand

 

[Monkey D Al]

Yall remember when Oda himself called Franky a SH right at the beginning of Enies Lobby and video games were also lumping him with the crew before he joined so they can fuel the narrative bait for Paulie?

Also the narrative bait, Brook, who immediately got accepted into the crew on introduction and served to cover up for Perona

Or Jinbe, who promised to join the crew but was meant to die and be the narrative bait for Carrot in WCI

What people fail to understand here is. Yamato joining was never meant to be a secret and have people guess, will she join will she not. From the moment of her introduction as female without the mask, she was basically already a Strawhat. She straight away said she will help Luffy fight and then join him.

 

[jordin]

Carrot4nakama: paulie going join there no way Franky will join the crew.

You know people were unironically arguing Franky vs Paulie even after that color spread?

"Franky is meant to get all this shine since he's only building the boat for the crew. Just like Tom, Franky is just meant to be good friends with the crew"

"Paulie will do something at the end of the arc. Just wait until the ending"

"Franky only wants to build a boat. His dream is done right after he's done making it this arc"

 

[Monkey D Al]

Do you have a quote from Oda calling Franky a strawhat at the beginning of Ennie Lobby ?

Because if the "proof" you have is that Oda is putting Franky with the Strawhat, I can easily do that with Carrot too.

you can do what Oda did? You can confirm Carrot as strawhat on Oda’s manga? I think what Oda can and can’t do is only up to him and nobody can make confirmations on his story.
Except that Yamato is joining that I can confirm.

 

[Logiko]

"Franky is meant to get all this shine since he's only building the boat for the crew. Just like Tom, Franky is just meant to be good friends with the crew"

"Paulie will do something at the end of the arc. Just wait until the ending"

"Franky only wants to build a boat. His dream is done right after he's done making it this arc"

So nothing here is stating "Franky is a strawhat".. You made my point.

You know people were unironically arguing Franky vs Paulie even after that color spread?

Franky was a given at the time with a little analysis. Anyone rooting for Paulie was delusional.

you can do what Oda did? You can confirm Carrot as strawhat on Oda’s manga? I think what Oda can and can’t do is only up to him and nobody can make confirmations on his story.
Except that Yamato is joining that I can confirm.

Yup I can. This is what I'm doing everyday.. (And the reason why I'm facing dogpiling on this thread lol)

What people fail to understand here is. Yamato joining was never meant to be a secret and have people guess, will she join will she not. From the moment of her introduction as female without the mask, she was basically already a Strawhat. She straight away said she will help Luffy fight and then join him.

My point exactly. If Yamato is going to be a strawhat, this wouldn't be a surprise.

But let's remember:

- The next strawhat is the BIGGEST discussion subject in the ENTIRE fanbase.

- The next strawhat will be the next BIGGEST event revelation after the revelations about the Lore (D / Dawn).

- The next strawhat will be the next BIGGEST event in term of merchandizing

- The next strawhat (after Jinbe) as been discussed for over 10 years.

Etc.

So.. You are telling me that Oda wouldn't add a revelation on that? And wouldjust giveaway the answer like it's nothing important ?

 

[jordin]

Because if the "proof" you have is that Oda is putting Franky with the Strawhat, I can easily do that with Carrot too. Remember that characters in the story literally put Carrot WITH the strawhats ?

For anyone curious, its because the BM pirates lumped Carrot with the SH group since they had no info besides her being with them.

By this logic, Jinbe isn't part of the crew since Queen didn't recognize him with the SHs and said Zoro and Sanji are the 2nd and 3rd off of their bounties

 

[Logiko]

By this logic, Jinbe isn't part of the crew since Queen didn't recognize him with the SHs and said Zoro had the second highest bounty.

Wrong, by this logic Jinbe is a strawhat because he has been recognize in Wano as a strawhat by people in the story, the fact that Queen didn't knew about the integration of Jinbe only reenforce the fact that carrot was recognized as a strawhat before.. My point indeed.