General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Ballel]

Here is a more accurate deconstruction of this panel:

Point of focus in Yellow
Line of sight in red
Composition construction in blue
And Focus helpers in black.

See, the problem is that I'm both a writer and an artist. I don't like to brag, but with you guyz I don't have a choice. I possesse both knowledge to understand properly storytelling AND composition to a high degree. So when someone like you or Sigran tries to put my back against the wall on storytelling or composition.. I bite.

Here is the proof that your analysis is (partially) wrong. Carrot is INDEED a focus in this panel. Not the only one, but a focus nonetheless. She is here the secondary subject. Much like a hidden clew here.

In a panel of this importance, this is not normal. This is in fact really odd and SHOULD raises eyebrows.

This panel only shows one thing: the people travelling on the sunny welcoming Jinbe.
Carrot, Nami, Luffy and Chopper are the quickest to hug someone.

Sanji being upset that 2 girls are hugging another guy instead of himself(lol) is also in-character.

The others are simply not as emotionally expressive as the 4 in the center.

 

[Logiko]

@CarrotForNakama as you said, we'll see in 3 chapters how rElEvaNt Larrot will become.

Do you know why I said three ?

wow that's a bunch of lines that mean nothing

For someone who is not aware of composition, I can understand that this doesn't make much sence. But trust us on that, those lines are important.

 

[Ballel]

Do you know why I said three ?

No
But you said it.
See ya in 3 chaps

 

[Animangaboy]

Here is a more accurate deconstruction of this panel:

Point of focus in Yellow
Line of sight in red
Composition construction in blue
And Focus helpers in black.

See, the problem is that I'm both a writer and an artist. I don't like to brag, but with you guyz I don't have a choice. I possesse both knowledge to understand properly storytelling AND composition to a high degree. So when someone like you or Sigran tries to put my back against the wall on storytelling with the antagonist or composition with that.. I usually bites hard.

Here is the proof that your analysis is (partially) wrong. Carrot is INDEED a focus in this panel. Not the only one, but A focus nonetheless. She is here the secondary subject. Much like a hidden clew.

In a panel of this importance, this is not normal. This is in fact really odd and SHOULD raises eyebrows.

Oh Btw! I forgot to add that Carrot's head (and the sun of Jinbe) are PRECISELY at the center of this panel.

Why isn't the “hidden clew” wasn't in the wano opening then?

 

[Logiko]

Why isn't the “hidden clew” wasn't in the wano opening then?

Because the anime doesn't know squat. They are not even capable of doing two good episodes in a raw, why do you expect anything from them?

No
But you said it.
See ya in 3 chaps

Because:

1044 will probably be the battle All VS Kaido (with Joy Boy arriving at the end)
1045 Will be a explanation of Joy Boy's importance or lore
1046 could be the very quick end of the fight

That's why I said "3". But it could actually take as long as kaido VS Joy Boy goes on.

 

[Ballel]

Because the anime doesn't know squat. They are not even capable of doing two good episodes in a raw, why do you expect anything from them?



Because:

1044 will probably be the battle All VS Kaido (with Joy Boy arriving at the end)
1045 Will be a explanation of Joy Boy's importance or lore
1046 could be the very quick end of the fight

That's why I said "3". But it could actually take as long as kaido VS Joy Boy goes on.

Already backpedaling

I'll still come back in 3 chaps to clown you

 

[Logiko]

I'll still come back in 3 chaps to clown you

No. In fact if in three chapters there are none of the panel of Carrot I mentionned previously.. I'll take my L and lower Carrot's chances to 70%

That's said.. If that panel still happens later. The chances of Carrot will still go to 100% straight away.

 

[Ballel]

No

I will

I'll take my L and lower Carrot's chances to 70%

Lmaooooo Carrot is the 1% character. She has 1% probability to join the sh's

 

[Logiko]

I will

Lmaooooo Carrot is the 1% character. She has 1% probability of joining the sh's

Not if one of those panel appears.

 

[Ballel]

Not if one of those panel appears.

A panel with her saing 'yes' or 'u-huh' you mean?

 

[Logiko]

A panel with her saing 'yes' or 'u-huh' you mean?

More like a panel with no dialogue at all.

 

[Animangaboy]

Because the anime doesn't know squat. They are not even capable of doing two good episodes in a raw, why do you expect anything from them?

Keep telling yourself that cause it will bring you hope, cause in the new opening the anime show kid's raid gun attack before Oda reveals in the manga 😂

 

[IIskandar1997]

A dream is something that the fanbase created. In reality, most strawhats don't have dreams

 

[Ballel]

More like a panel with no dialogue at all.

So for you:
Character on random panel with no text=proof that they'll join

You are beyond saving

 

[Animangaboy]

1044 will probably be the battle All VS Kaido (with Joy Boy arriving at the end)

And you think carrot going to do something against kaido?

Post automatically merged: Mar 12, 2022

No. In fact, if in three chapters there are none of the panel of Carrot I mentioned previously.. I'll take my L and lower Carrot's chances to 70%

That's said. If that panel still happens later. The chances of Carrot will still go to 100% straight away.

WAIT what happens to 99% that you said that she has

 

[Garp the Fist]

A much overused meme, but by God is it applicable here

 

[Kuruka]

Here is a more accurate deconstruction of this panel:

Point of focus in Yellow
Line of sight in red
Composition construction in blue
And Focus helpers in black.

See, the problem is that I'm both a writer and an artist. I don't like to brag, but with you guyz I don't have a choice. I possesse both knowledge to understand properly storytelling AND composition to a high degree. So when someone like you or Sigran tries to put my back against the wall on storytelling with the antagonist or composition with that.. I usually bites hard.

Here is the proof that your analysis is (partially) wrong. Carrot is INDEED a focus in this panel. Not the only one, but A focus nonetheless. She is here the secondary subject. Much like a hidden clew.

In a panel of this importance, this is not normal. This is in fact really odd and SHOULD raises eyebrows.

Oh Btw! I forgot to add that Carrot's head (and the sun of Jinbe) are PRECISELY at the center of this panel.

MORE ACCURATE!?!?

why did you just shoehorn carrot into the line of focus..?
and why are you using perpendicular lines where they should be diagonal?
I guess it really is cofirmation bias with you...but

robin, usopp and sanjis gaze are not directed at carrot...she is simply infront of them...just as nami is...which defeates your whole arguement...not only that but carrot's line is pointing toward jinbe also.
Jinbe is the ONLY person in this panel to not be directing a line toward something...Why? because he's the ONLY one in focus.
otherwise carrot would be just like jinbe(only lower) but she is not.
you definitely LOVE to brag but
if you are a writer and and artist can u dm me some of your work? I'll show you some of mine.
Before you were here, my avatar was actually of artwork I did of carrot...and yes I went to school for it.

BTW...why do you keep mentioning the center of the panel like it means anything...? Oda is using the golden rule remember?
or did you forget to google it?

 

[Animangaboy]

More like a panel with no dialogue at all.

So you are saying that one panel with her staring is good for you?

 

[Ballel]

A much overused meme, but by God is it applicable here

 

[Logiko]

Keep telling yourself that cause it will bring you hope, cause in the new opening the anime show kid's raid gun attack before Oda reveals in the manga 😂

No. The animes shows a LASER. (Kaido's one). A rail gun is firing PROJECTILES. Stop listening to this "the anime is spoiling the manga" conspiracy bullcrap.

And you think carrot going to do something against kaido?

No. I would love to but I don't think Carrot can hurt him.. UNLESS she shows a news skill.

MORE ACCURATE!?!?

why did you just shoehorn carrot into the line of focus..?

Yes

why did you just shoehorn carrot into the line of focus..?

I didn't do anything but show the composition here.

and why are you using perpendicular lines where they should be diagonal?

I'm not using perpendicular lines

robin, usopp and sanjis gaze are not directed at carrot...she is simply infront of them...just as nami is...which defeates your whole

Yes they are

Jinbe is the ONLY person in this panel to not be directing a line toward something...Why? because he's the ONLY one in focus.

Jinbe is just the main subject not the only focus.

if you are a writer and and artist can u dm me some of your work?

No. Either you believe me or not.

Before you were here, my avatar was actually of artwork I did of carrot...and yes I went to school for it.

Me too, for both field.

BTW...why do you keep mentioning the center of the panel like it means anything...? Oda is using the golden rule remember?
or did you forget to google it?

Oda is known to bend his composition rule as well as the narrative ones. The golden Triangle is added to a simple centering rule here.

So you are saying that one panel with her staring is good for you?

If this panel is just before a flashback of Pedro's words, yes. Because this panel would have an important meaning for the story.