Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why are you switching up now u just said that she would now she won't?
Never said that she would face a giant. You invented that.


Is this what you going with right now? He also helped Wanda too but she isn't with him, so come again.
Showing that Carrot is more important that wanda indeed.


just wanna ask something have we seen carrot worried about luffy at all during wano??
Nope. During that time, Carrot was facing the ground because of Perospero. The maries only broadcasted in the interior.



Even during what was arguably Carrot's only real character-defining moment, Pedro's death, Luffy wasn't present. Instead, Pekoms told him about it, and Luffy didn't really react either after he was told or when he met up with the group again. Pekoms said that he was making sure the crew got out of Tottoland to make sure Pedro's sacrifice wasn't in vain, and Luffy's reaction was "Ok, makes sense." Pekoms was the one to make sure Luffy got out of the Mirro World and Luffy showed more concern about Pekoms whereabouts after he was abducted by Bege than anything he showed towards Carrot, but obviously, he has a super special bond with Carrot...
Luffy was there.
 
nothing from a future Nakama huh funny
Also what's is more funny is that he thinks that when carrot loses to Perospero it's mean that it's happening for a reason. When all of the straw hats won all of the fights no matter what, Oda always make they won to show a sign of they getting stronger
Post automatically merged:

Never said that she would face a giant. You invented that.
Hmmm 🤔 what u make think that carrot can beat anyone stronger than Perospero in the future.
Post automatically merged:

Showing that Carrot is more important that Wanda indeed
Meh. Going too far but Okay
 
Also what's is more funny is that he thinks that when carrot loses to Perospero it's mean that it's happening for a reason. When all of the straw hats won all of the fights no matter what, Oda always make they won to show a sign of they getting stronger
Wrong. Brook lost to Ryuma. Nami lost to Arlong. Usopp lost to Kuro etc..

Winning is not synonym of growth in One Piece.


what u make think that carrot can beat anyone stronger than Perospero in the future.
Because she lost to Perospero, she now needs to face an ennemy like him and win to prove to herself that she is worthy. The ennemy doesn't need to be stronger than Perospero.


does justify her not worrying at all the whole time??
Do the strawhats worries about Luffy when they are not informed of his position and status ?


But how did she knows that Perospero was outside if she couldn't hear luffy at that time?
She saw Perospero. Carrot has good eyes.
 
Wrong. Brook lost to Ryuma. Nami lost to Arlong. Usopp lost to Kuro etc..

Winning is not synonym of growth in One Piece
Brook lost to Ryuma was already set for Zoro to get the sword,
Nami can't beat Arlong common sense could tell you that,
Usopp Can't beat Kuro but at least He Defeats the other guy thou
So try again.
Post automatically merged:

Because she lost to Perospero, she now needs to face an ennemy like him and win to prove to herself that she is worthy. The ennemy doesn't need to be stronger than Perospero.
LMAO what? If u think that she going to win a fight without using her sulong form like Cat viper and dog storm come again cause what type of bullshit is This “she now needs to face an ennemy like him and win to prove to herself that she is worthy" :suresure:
Like you are thinking ahead from Oda writing
Post automatically merged:

She saw Perospero. Carrot has good eyes.
Meh. Not that good to me but she has long ears
Post automatically merged:

the straw hats worry about Luffy when they are not informed of his position and status?
They all do worry about each other no matter what is going on but why wasn't carrot thou?
 
Last edited:
Wrong. Brook lost to Ryuma. Nami lost to Arlong. Usopp lost to Kuro etc..

Winning is not synonym of growth in One Piece.




Because she lost to Perospero, she now needs to face an ennemy like him and win to prove to herself that she is worthy. The ennemy doesn't need to be stronger than Perospero.




Do the strawhats worries about Luffy when they are not informed of his position and status ?




She saw Perospero. Carrot has good eyes.
It’s okay lose to fight but who is coming to back them up after lost of fight or betrayal? That is the question. When Brook lost ryuma zoro came to his defense. When nami was betrayed arlong?when nami ask for help from luffy he back her up alongside the other strawhats. When captain kuro and his subordinates mock ussop for being week and not being strong like everyone. It was luffy that defend honor and back up. In carrot case when she lost to Perospero. cat viper back her up instead one of strawhats.
 
Last edited:
Brook lost to Ryuma was already set for Zoro to get the sword,
Nami can't beat Arlong common sense could tell you that,
Usopp Can't beat Kuro but at least He Defeats the other guy thou
So try again.
It dosn't matter. Those fight ended up the way they are because of the NARRATION. Just like Carrot.


LMAO what? If u think that she going to win a fight without using her sulong form like Cat viper and dog storm come again cause what type of bullshit is This “she now needs to face an ennemy like him and win to prove to herself that she is worthy" :suresure:
Like you are thinking a way ahead from Oda writing
You are inventing things I didn't say. This is a constant with you : lying on what the contradictor is saying to make your point. Very disrespectful way of making an argument.


They all do worry about each other no matter what is going on but why wasn't carrot thou?
No, they trust each others.


It’s okay loss to fight but who coming to back them after lost of fight or betrayal?
Wuat ?
 
@CarrotForNakama what do you expect Carrot to do in the last 5-6 chapters of the raid?
It depend on what the last 5-6 chapter of the raid are. Are they the next chapter following 1043 ? If yes, I expect Carrot to try to attack Kaido and failing again. I also expect her to have a flashback Pedro's word while seeing Luffy defeat kaido.

Finally, for the remaining chapters.. I don't know.. she could do a lot with SUlong, like striking the ennemy army hard for exemple.
 
It depend on what the last 5-6 chapter of the raid are. Are they the next chapter following 1043 ? If yes, I expect Carrot to try to attack Kaido and failing again. I also expect her to have a flashback Pedro's word while seeing Luffy defeat kaido.

Finally, for the remaining chapters.. I don't know.. she could do a lot with SUlong, like striking the ennemy army hard for exemple.
And that's what you think would confirm she's a SH?
 
You are inventing things I didn't say. This is a constant with you : lying on what the contradictor is saying to make your point. Very disrespectful way of making an argument.
U literally say something that isn't in the story making shit that wasn't foreshadowing “she now needs to face an enemy like him and win to prove to herself that she is worthy" like where do you see that in her defeat? 😂
Post automatically merged:

No, they trust each other
It's doesn't matter cause they all worry about each other no matter what like in chapters 1043 and where Franky was worried about Zoro and Nami about Usopp
 
they trust him but also show worry for him at the same time
That not what I saw during that raid. During that raid each strawhat trusted eachother enough not to worry. They only started to worry when they heard bad news.


No you are just thinking like that
No


iirc characters who had similar flashbacks

- Jinbe
- Franky
- Brook

probably some I forgot, but Law also had that and he didn't join
The difference is that a panel of this nature for Carrot would link her to the words of PEdro and Luffy at the same times. In other words, this would be the setup for the creation of a purpose, that purpose would then be the reason for her to follow Luffy.

There is no world were a character like Carrot has a development post fight and this development doesn't become important for her character.

Everything in a story matter. If Oda makes carrot remember Luffy, this will be for a reason. In fact that would be the exact way I would do this too.

The point is too make Carrot understand the importance of Luffy. Once she understand that, she will also understand the importance of Pedro's words and the purpose of the Mink Tribe.
 
The difference is that a panel of this nature for Carrot would link her to the words of PEdro and Luffy at the same times. In other words, this would be the setup for the creation of a purpose, that purpose would then be the reason for her to follow Luffy.

There is no world were a character like Carrot has a development post fight and this development doesn't become important for her character.

Everything in a story matter. If Oda makes carrot remember Luffy, this will be for a reason. In fact that would be the exact way I would do this too.

The point is too make Carrot understand the importance of Luffy. Once she understand that, she will also understand the importance of Pedro's words and the purpose of the Mink Tribe.
Ok let me be devils advocate here, why was it different from Law when Corazon's words rang true when Luffy beat Doffy?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top