Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
1. Wrong, her saving Marco helped the alliance. Plus she was gathering weapon and supplies which helped greatly during the war
That doesn't make her relevant for most of the arc. Caribou helped the alliance and was clutch when it came to saving Luffy, yet most of us agree he has been irrelevant.

yes we had. Robin had a LOT LESS significance before she join after Alabasta. Carrot had the entire arc of whole cake. Again. Just because there was an arc between the two doesn't negate what happened during Whole cake.
Robin was a huge reason why the straw hats went to the sky and provided a lot of information in Skypea, she even had her own 1v1.


Their is a difference between a character who is officialized/recruited/asked by Luffy (Jinbe/Brook/Usopp) and a character who joined the crew (Robin before water Seven ; Nami before Arlong Park).

An official character has already made his proof both in a physical and narrative way (haaving a strong batch of chapter and a strong focus) and is already part of the acting crew as ".... the ... of the ship"

On the other hand the one who just joined the crew is not an official strawhat yet. They are just a "future" strawhat. (and we can usually tell that because the character as every thing the strawhats have) they still have to make an impression on the reader, either with a big arc centered around themself or a batch of chapters and a focus later.

Carrot will be in the second case as she will much likely stowaway. The real focus on her will come after. And only after those actions or focus .. will Carrot be considered a real strawhat.
Except both Nami and Robin had big roles in the arc that followed their introductions. Even as you downplayed Robin in Skypea
 
Because u trying to use what happened in WCI as a reason why she shouldn't be important in wano this is where she should have a moment like the rest of the crew
no. Carrot is not a part of the crew yet, she doesn't need a moment like the crew in Wano. She just need to have enough cahracterization in order to join after Wano. And that happened on whole cake, wether you like it or not.


buddy like I m literally speechless seeing you say starting of a fight isn't pat of the fight
Sorry but that's a narrative fact. The introduction (the moment where Carrot and wanda attacks) and the moment when Carrot and Wanda take "care" of Perospero is clearly separated in the story by a discussion and multiple panels. The fight only start offscreen.

That doesn't make her relevant for most of the arc. Caribou helped the alliance and was clutch when it came to saving Luffy, yet most of us agree he has been irrelevant.
The point was not that Carrot needed to be relevant for the whole arc. Just that Carrot needed to be relevant once.

Caribou has not been irrelevant. He helped the same way Carrot help the fact that he only had a few chapters doesn't change that.


Robin was a huge reason why the straw hats went to the sky and provided a lot of information in Skypea, she even had her own 1v1.
Yes, after she joined. Not before.


xcept both Nami and Robin had big roles in the arc that followed their introductions. Even as you downplayed Robin in Skypea
And Carrot in the arc that followed her introduction as well.

Again, don't confuse Joining as a status (what was Robin until Water Seven) and an official strawhat.

The fact that a character will help after they join is irrelevant to our discussion. Carrot hasn't joined up yet in wano. She will after Wano.
 
no. Carrot is not a part of the crew yet, she doesn't need a moment like the crew in Wano. She just need to have enough cahracterization in order to join after Wano. And that happened on whole cake, wether you like it or
So why did Zoro, Nami, Usopp, Sanji, Chopper, Robin, Franky, Brook and Jinbei all have a moment before they joined luffy? What makes carrot so special she doesn't have to follow the others? U do read when everyone has a moment in their own arc right?
 

AL sama

Red Haired
Sorry but that's a narrative fact. The introduction (the moment where Carrot and wanda attacks) and the moment when Carrot and Wanda take "care" of Perospero is clearly separated in the story by a discussion and multiple panels. The fight only start offscreen.
its not even logical to think starting of a fight isn't part of the fight but don't mind me and have fun
 
So why did Zoro, Nami, Usopp, Sanji, Chopper, Robin, Franky, Brook and Jinbei all have a moment before they joined luffy? What makes carrot so special she doesn't have to follow the others? U do read when everyone has a moment in their own arc right?
Not all of them.

Nami had her moment and was officialized in Arlong Park while she joined in the arc of Buggy
Robin had her moment and was officialized in water Seven while she joined after Alabasta

Like always you are clearly confusing "joining the crew" and "being officialized as a true strawhat"

Until you understand the difference, there is no way we can have a clear discussion.


its not even logical to think starting of a fight isn't part of the fight but don't mind me and have fun
Good night.
 
no. Carrot is not a part of the crew yet, she doesn't need a moment like the crew in Wano. She just need to have enough cahracterization in order to join after Wano. And that happened on whole cake, wether you like it or not.




Sorry but that's a narrative fact. The introduction (the moment where Carrot and wanda attacks) and the moment when Carrot and Wanda take "care" of Perospero is clearly separated in the story by a discussion and multiple panels. The fight only start offscreen.



The point was not that Carrot needed to be relevant for the whole arc. Just that Carrot needed to be relevant once.

Caribou has not been irrelevant. He helped the same way Carrot help the fact that he only had a few chapters doesn't change that.




Yes, after she joined. Not before.




And Carrot in the arc that followed her introduction as well.

Again, don't confuse Joining as a status (what was Robin until Water Seven) and an official strawhat.

The fact that a character will help after they join is irrelevant to our discussion. Carrot hasn't joined up yet in wano. She will after Wano.
I'm confused, you said Robin was less significant prior to her initial joining, did you mean prior to her "recruitment" phase you categorized?
 
I'm confused, you said Robin was less significant prior to her initial joining, did you mean prior to her "recruitment" phase you categorized?
No, prior her initial joining. Meaning Alabasta.

Robin became relevant only after she joined, a bit during Skypea then fully in Water seven where she was officiallized at the end of the arc.
 
This is what happened with Carrot, she was a bit relevant in Whole cake, but her real mooment will come after she really join the crew at the end of Wano (for the good reasons this time)

PErsonnally, I expect Carrot to be put in a very difficult situation in Whole cake and to question herself quite a lot.. only to be reassured by the crew later
 
Not all of them.

Nami had her moment and was officialized in Arlong Park while she joined in the arc of Buggy
Robin had her moment and was officialized in water Seven while she joined after Alabasta

Like always you are clearly confusing "joining the crew" and "being officialized as a true strawhat"

Until you understand the difference, there is no way we can have a clear discussion.
Didn't she help luffy when was fighting buggy?
Also didn't robin save luffy after crocodile almost killed him and not to mention defeated the strongest warrior of Vivi's kingdom? Also, the BOMB stuff she did when was she first introduced
 
Dude she was a huge deal in Alabasta
No. You only has this impression because she was Crocodile's acolyte, but in reality Robin only saved Luffy, beat up Pell and tried to beat Crocodile.

In reality, the moments of Robin in this arc are nothing in comparison to what Carrot did in Whole cake. And furthermore, to what Carrot did in chapter 888 when she had entire pages dedicated to herself. (counting 889 too)
 

This is what happened with Carrot, she was a bit relevant in Whole cake, but her real mooment will come after she really join the crew at the end of Wano (for the good reasons this time)

personally, I expect Carrot to be put in a very difficult situation in Whole cake and to question herself quite a lot.. only to be reassured by the crew later
If it doesn't happen in wano what the hell will u think she getting a moment? Only u think she joined the crew when all of them gets a power up/character moment
 
Didn't she help luffy when was fighting buggy?
Also didn't robin save luffy after crocodile almost killed him and not to mention defeated the strongest warrior of Vivi's kingdom? Also, the BOMB stuff she did when was she first introduced
Just like carrot helped the crew during Whole cake. Those situation are very similar. Carrot is in the "joining phase" while she will only be officialized long after Wano. Just like the girls were officialiazed long after they joined.
Post automatically merged:



If it doesn't happen in wano what the hell will u think she getting a moment? Only u think she joined the crew when all of them gets a power up/character moment
In Elbaf. Everything points to Carrot having a moment on this Island.
 
No. You only has this impression because she was Crocodile's acolyte, but in reality Robin only saved Luffy, beat up Pell and tried to beat Crocodile.

In reality, the moments of Robin in this arc are nothing in comparison to what Carrot did in Whole cake. And furthermore, to what Carrot did in chapter 888 when she had entire pages dedicated to herself. (counting 889 too)
U think carrot in WCI did more than robin in Alabasta
 
No. You only has this impression because she was Crocodile's acolyte, but in reality Robin only saved Luffy, beat up Pell and tried to beat Crocodile.

In reality, the moments of Robin in this arc are nothing in comparison to what Carrot did in Whole cake. And furthermore, to what Carrot did in chapter 888 when she had entire pages dedicated to herself. (counting 889 too)
we also got the reveal that she's the only who could read stones that led to the strongest weapon in the world

in fact we literally had chapters dedicated to that in the middle of the climax
 
U think carrot in WCI did more than robin in Alabasta
It's not that I think, it's a fact. Chapter 888 only is more than everything that Robin did in Alabasta.
Post automatically merged:

we also got the reveal that she's the only who could read stones that led to the strongest weapon in the world

in fact we literally had chapters dedicated to that in the middle of the climax
Yes, I'm taking those into account. THose were setup for her future role in the crew. Just like Carrot in the look out post was a setup to her future role in the crew.
 
In Elbaf. Everything points to Carrot having a moment on this Island.
Where cause everyone knows that Elbaf arc will Be Usopp moment, what points you are talking about please don't tell me is that one think bubble where carrot said “that giant do exist"
Post automatically merged:

It's not that I think, it's a fact. Chapter 888 only is more than everything that Robin did in Alabasta
Only to u cause, u think carrot alone can sink ships and stuff
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top