Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.

TheKnightOfTheSea

𝕷𝖔𝖗𝖉 𝖔𝖋 𝕸𝖔𝖔𝖓'𝖘 𝕾𝖕𝖆𝖜𝖓
There's no real chance for Carrot joining at this point.

There's decent arguments against Yamato not joining, but the evidence seems to point toward her sailing with Luffy EoW.

Personally, I think Jinbe should have been the final member, with VIvi sailing for the final few arcs, but Yamato's likely going to be the final one.
 
well I don’t like robin . I feel she is nothing to me to add even pre-timeskip manga. Heck oden is way better and can translate poneglyph. But there are people who like robin. Good for them.

Then for some reason poneglyph language is only know on Ohara library. I am sure they are people who speak poneglyph language in other place other than ohara island without government knowing it. It is just learn this language in private area and speak or written in private area but don’t expose to public.
 
There's no real chance for Carrot joining at this point.

There's decent arguments against Yamato not joining, but the evidence seems to point toward her sailing with Luffy EoW.

Personally, I think Jinbe should have been the final member, with VIvi sailing for the final few arcs, but Yamato's likely going to be the final one.
Well, anyone with a brain can see this.
But some users in this thread think Larrot will join:kayneshrug:
 
well I don’t like robin . I feel she is nothing to me to add even pre-timeskip manga. Heck oden is way better and can translation poneglyph. But there are people who like robin. Good for them.

Then for some reason poneglyph language is only know on Ohara library. I am sure they are peole who speak poneglyph language in other place other than ohara island without government knowing it. It is just learn this language in private area and speak or written in private area but don’t expose to public.
No worries. Everybody can have different opinion about any character. We should appreciate any opinions instead of accusing the specific someone who states their opinion
:cheers:
 
Just noticed that you only ever post in this thread
it was the only discussion i found interesting enough to continuously come back to since the Orojackson days, anything else is too specific and can disproven and end the conversation
Post automatically merged:

I think I'm going to argue in favor of Carrot just to have an actual conversation lmao
 
How long did it take you to make this also Yamato is fighting for Kozuki but she also falls under the alliance of the StrawHat Pirates...
I had thought about how the Strawhat Grand Fleet could get bigger years back. Had a theory at OJ. If the Strawhat Grand Fleet arrives in Wano bigger with certain recruits...bliss.

Marco being in Wano opens up the recruitment for the Whitebeard Pirates remnants for a special division in the Straw Hat Grand Fleet. Weevil is looking for a Daddy figure. Gear 4 Luffy post-Wano is going to surpass "Whitebeard" by defeating Weevil. Elbaf may be a great setting adding Loki and Big Mom in the mix. Or none of this prediction happens lol but what I stated would be an updated theory ending since the time is almost here in Wano.

Yes, Yamato is a part of the alliance under Kozuki under Samurai for the Ninja-Pirate-Mink-Samurai Alliance.
He's just got a bias. Pay him no attention. At least imo.
Who did you think was joining before Yamato? Did you feel the same certainty you feel now? I think you did. My "bias" has a process like yours.

I started thinking about it during when the New World began.

Monet is a cute birdwoman that seemingly made a great lookout for Caesar Clown. Astronomy potential. Snow Logia. But then she ruined it by knowingly drugging children. Then she showed her ass by attacking Zoro. Shook my head. She should have known better.

Bartolomeo would be a great Shipguard. And him feeling unworthy adds to him staying on-board the Sunny while they adventure. Too much of a stan. 2nd Division Commander of the Strawhat Grand Fleet is a great consolation. The leader of Strawhat Stans.

Leo would have been the best Tailor, Gardener, and Surgeon. Super useful. Too naive and small though. Princess Manshelley may have been an obstacle. 5th Division Commander of the Strawhat Grand Fleet is a great consolation.

Kyros, the statue of foreshadowing that wasn't, made more sense over Rebecca from a pure battle capacity with him defeating Diamante. Trueno Bastardo was magnificent. But in the end Kyros wasn't going to leave his daughter ever. Ally to Strawhats in the WG War.

Neko and Inu have shown no interest to follow Luffy like they did Whitebeard and Roger. Comparing the rest of the Minks by strength, impact in story, design, and mystery for my interest I'd rank it:
1. Pedro
2. Pekoms
3. Faust
4. Bepo
5. Lindbergh
6. Carrot
7. 3 Dog Musketeers
The top 5 have not shown their Sulong forms. Pedro is a top Mink we the readers seen in a fight with no named moves...curiousity peaking. Pekoms is the ONLY Mink seen with a Devil Fruit. Hybrid Sulong. Nuff said. Faust for some unknown reason has not been seen ANYWHERE in Wano. Where is Faust? I'm thinking more than likely Faust is Hawkins escape plan. It makes no sense otherwise for Faust not to be in this Wano war during a Full Moon.

Bepo has been displayed but has not shown his Sulong form. What has prevented Bepo from looking at multiple Full Moon opportunities? Perhaps some acknowledgement about Zepo for character development?

Lindbergh could have a machine or weapon that amplifies his Sulong form. Electro as an energy source...my gawd!

Carrot is who she is. Childish. Fun. Simple. Straightforward. Helpful. 1st Sulong shown. Maybe be the 1st Super Sulong? I jest. Going to Elbaf is a possibility though. Beyond that depends on what Oda gives her next interest. If it's the moon then that fits. That would insane for Carrot to keep sneaking on-board but never being a crewmate!

In Wano, Yamato vs Tama is really what it comes down to as Carrot ALREADY rode on Sunny so that in itself separates her over either. They both share Ace connection and are against Kaido negging unique factors. Add that Caribou may be riding after Wano takes away panels from someone else's impact joining with Jinbe. I think more time will pass to drag the nakama wars to the latest reasonable deadline lol.

Jinbe recruitment process seems to be halting any other new recruits. At least that's how the results are portrayed to me. Oda planned this out for a LONG time. Decades. Of course plans change but I doubt Oda didn't know who the final crew would be pre-timeskip. I in my observations see possible hints from chapters 31, 175, 302, 318, 392, 424, 484, 603, 658-659 for Pedro. I haven't seen potential early hints for the other candidates I thought had a chance for however long it lasted.
I
It's like they don't read chapter 1016 by Oda where it's stated that she is going to leave with luffy.
I've read. Yamato stating they will leave ain't the same as Luffy inviting Yamato.
 
I had thought about how the Strawhat Grand Fleet could get bigger years back. Had a theory at OJ. If the Strawhat Grand Fleet arrives in Wano bigger with certain recruits...bliss.

Marco being in Wano opens up the recruitment for the Whitebeard Pirates remnants for a special division in the Straw Hat Grand Fleet. Weevil is looking for a Daddy figure. Gear 4 Luffy post-Wano is going to surpass "Whitebeard" by defeating Weevil. Elbaf may be a great setting adding Loki and Big Mom in the mix. Or none of this prediction happens lol but what I stated would be an updated theory ending since the time is almost here in Wano.

Yes, Yamato is a part of the alliance under Kozuki under Samurai for the Ninja-Pirate-Mink-Samurai Alliance.

Who did you think was joining before Yamato? Did you feel the same certainty you feel now? I think you did. My "bias" has a process like yours.

I started thinking about it during when the New World began.

Monet is a cute birdwoman that seemingly made a great lookout for Caesar Clown. Astronomy potential. Snow Logia. But then she ruined it by knowingly drugging children. Then she showed her ass by attacking Zoro. Shook my head. She should have known better.

Bartolomeo would be a great Shipguard. And him feeling unworthy adds to him staying on-board the Sunny while they adventure. Too much of a stan. 2nd Division Commander of the Strawhat Grand Fleet is a great consolation. The leader of Strawhat Stans.

Leo would have been the best Tailor, Gardener, and Surgeon. Super useful. Too naive and small though. Princess Manshelley may have been an obstacle. 5th Division Commander of the Strawhat Grand Fleet is a great consolation.

Kyros, the statue of foreshadowing that wasn't, made more sense over Rebecca from a pure battle capacity with him defeating Diamante. Trueno Bastardo was magnificent. But in the end Kyros wasn't going to leave his daughter ever. Ally to Strawhats in the WG War.

Neko and Inu have shown no interest to follow Luffy like they did Whitebeard and Roger. Comparing the rest of the Minks by strength, impact in story, design, and mystery for my interest I'd rank it:
1. Pedro
2. Pekoms
3. Faust
4. Bepo
5. Lindbergh
6. Carrot
7. 3 Dog Musketeers
The top 5 have not shown their Sulong forms. Pedro is a top Mink we the readers seen in a fight with no named moves...curiousity peaking. Pekoms is the ONLY Mink seen with a Devil Fruit. Hybrid Sulong. Nuff said. Faust for some unknown reason has not been seen ANYWHERE in Wano. Where is Faust? I'm thinking more than likely Faust is Hawkins escape plan. It makes no sense otherwise for Faust not to be in this Wano war during a Full Moon.

Bepo has been displayed but has not shown his Sulong form. What has prevented Bepo from looking at multiple Full Moon opportunities? Perhaps some acknowledgement about Zepo for character development?

Lindbergh could have a machine or weapon that amplifies his Sulong form. Electro as an energy source...my gawd!

Carrot is who she is. Childish. Fun. Simple. Straightforward. Helpful. 1st Sulong shown. Maybe be the 1st Super Sulong? I jest. Going to Elbaf is a possibility though. Beyond that depends on what Oda gives her next interest. If it's the moon then that fits. That would insane for Carrot to keep sneaking on-board but never being a crewmate!

In Wano, Yamato vs Tama is really what it comes down to as Carrot ALREADY rode on Sunny so that in itself separates her over either. They both share Ace connection and are against Kaido negging unique factors. Add that Caribou may be riding after Wano takes away panels from someone else's impact joining with Jinbe. I think more time will pass to drag the nakama wars to the latest reasonable deadline lol.

Jinbe recruitment process seems to be halting any other new recruits. At least that's how the results are portrayed to me. Oda planned this out for a LONG time. Decades. Of course plans change but I doubt Oda didn't know who the final crew would be pre-timeskip. I in my observations see possible hints from chapters 31, 175, 302, 318, 392, 424, 484, 603, 658-659 for Pedro. I haven't seen potential early hints for the other candidates I thought had a chance for however long it lasted.

I've read. Yamato stating they will leave ain't the same as Luffy inviting Yamato.
Carrot is a bland bunny character.
Almost every other fucking character is better than her.
 
Think and want are two different things. Learn the difference.
Jinbei and he joined.
I know the difference. I just went through my quick history of crewmate possibilities thoughts.

So you thought Jinbe. Good as he was more than worthy with his interactions with Luffy and buildup. I "thought" you "wanted" Monet IIRC. Well whatever.
 
I know the difference. I just went through my quick history of crewmate possibilities thoughts.

So you thought Jinbe. Good as he was more than worthy with his interactions with Luffy and buildup. I "thought" you "wanted" Monet IIRC. Well whatever.
Yeah I wanted Monet, Reiju, Rebecca... I'm not going to shy away from that.
Those didn't pan out. Oh well.
They're still more interesting than Carrot.
 
In Water 7, Franky bonded with Straw Hats (mainly Usopp, he even witnessed Sogeking debut along with Sanji) instead of making bonds with Franky Family or babysitting Chimney and Gonbe.

In WCI, Jinbe spent time with Straw Hats. He was on Sunny ship instead in the sea with fellow Sun Pirates when Skinny Mom chased them.

Compare that to Yamao situation right now in Wano:
- babysitting Momo before Rooftop
- babysitting Momo again after Rooftop
- fighting Number and Fire Yokai with Fuuga instead of joining Brook and Robin (Oda purposefully make them go separate ways)
 
Shame will probably never get to see Sulong Pedro or Hybrid Sulong Pekoms..

Carrot is a simple straightforward character
She's also most of the time a background tree with a lot of useless one liners..

Mister sun stop attacking us nyaa..
Oh no its a big problem! What should we do Inuarashi-sama nyaa..
Me too Pudding, i love Sanji we are the same nyaa!..

Wow Chobro youre so cool..
Wow Nami youre so beautiful..
Wow Luffy, Brook and Chobro you are awesome in those samurai armors..
 
No I fully understand why you hate Carrot my friend.. She threatens you.

---

In fact not only you..

Carrot threaten ALL of you .. because.. while stayin in the shadow, she still has a better chance to join the crew than Yamato.. and

...Deep down..

You all know it!

I told you I hated her even before Yamato was introduced. Even before she snuck on to the Sunny.
The only one that feels threatened is you. Cuz once Yamato joins we are gonna go savage on you.
Post automatically merged:

Doubt that's the case, a lot of people genuinely find her funny and her story compelling, myself included.

Being sexy alone won't get you in the top 10 constantly
True! I hated her in the beginning but when she started to show her softer side and her inability to comprehend thinks like what marriage is and got exited over little thinks like Luffy calling her name correctly. Made me like her a lot.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top