[FNZ] Role Madness Game 03: One Piece Dressrosa

Status
Not open for further replies.
You should stop judging people based on whether they play the way you want to or not and you will do great as Mafia player


Despite this mess I am still clear headed to see that no scum can be this stupid to open herself so much that too on day 1...but are you?
You know, I'm not a newbie and I have seen many situations in which players that played scummy played scummy because they were really scum. And I even gave you many opportunities to clarify things, yet you decided to stall when you could have just said "Sorry, I can't claim because I'm restricted." or actually tried to be helpful in any way. Also again, no, scum actually does such things often because many people think they wouldn't be that stupid, so it's actually a good way for scum to avoid suspicion.


That being said I am done with you because you are scum in my book and that probably won't change unless you flip anything else in the WU. Damn, this gives me Nessos flashbacks...
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Anyway let me get back to my game....


Me and flower are townie - why? Because we both didn't back out from arguing each other even after debating for hours...there was no distancing involved here and best part is it happened on day one itself when scums usually try to be less open but we both were open like hell...


So one particpant is clear from myside


Now, moving on to others...

Shura is townie....he is a newbie and doesn't know the game(first one or two post reflect so). If he was scum then he would have made some post based on guidance through his partners in chat but this doesn't seem to be the case


@Jew D. Boy also seem to be twonie based on his slip mistake which newbie often does...


So we four are townie for me.....


Now, let's see other players....

@playa4321 I like his game play...he is contributing... Infact what gives me feel that he is twonie is his post where he said that me vs flower is usually townie argument and anyone else who will vote on us would be worth taking note of implying that anyone capitalizing our argument to push vote on me or flower to Lynch us (rape at the end as it's majority Lynch) could be sus....so I am leaning toward him as twonie though he could be an sk or indie but as of now I am finding him Townie


Now, remaining particpants I have a quick questions for you all... please answer them honestly instead of dodging the question

@Rej @AL sama @Finalbeta @Pantheos @TheAncientCenturion @Bogard @Law @NeutralWatcher @Fujishiro @Sentinel

1) give me your reads on game

2) give me reasons to consider that you guys are townie?
 
give me your reads on game
As I said to @NeutralWatcher:
"It is the part in which @Reborn was accused of being a scum by @Flower whilst working with @Bogard based on an earlier dialogue between @TheAncientCenturion and him.
After that, it is one of these usual "You are suspicious!", "No, you are!" dialogues in the early game.

My personal guess is:

A) Reborn and Co simply try to sound like nothing about them is suspicious.
B) They are baiting reactions from every player to see which one shows some suspicious signs.
C) As scums, they either play very defensive (hence mostly being inactive or going with the majority to avoid being focused too much) or they are directly playing aggressive in order to prevent that people may think "Look, why is user x that silent?", "He/She just goes with the majority" and instead, they could come to a conclusion like that "I doubt scums would play that offensive during day 1! They would unnecessarily make themselves suspicious on the good players."

But as I said, it's day 1 and thus, it is still difficult to search the scum between these users based on this heated debate. I guess, they simply try to bait some suspicious reactions which itself is not really unreasonable.
Since point C) has high risks, I'd say point B) is more likely at this point."

Furthermore, imo the experienced players are quite suspicious by playing absolutely inactive. It seems like they are using this opportunity of your debate with Flower to stay silent.

give me reasons to consider that you guys are townie?
What do you think of my posts? I try to find the scums - and I don't really consider you and Flower as scums.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
@Reborn Reborn your thoughts on Al sama?
He is very experienced player but what makes him deadly is that he knows how all of us play through observations as he is also a Coach....so I am very cautious regarding him...

What struck me off is that I find him trying to control the game as the way he wants to....not a fan of such play.

I will be keeping my eye on him...

But the reason I am not finding him much of a sus as of now is that he is also among those who didn't try to capitalize our heated argument and tried to push sus on either of us.....
 
He is very experienced player but what makes him deadly is that he knows how all of us play through observations as he is also a Coach....so I am very cautious regarding him...

What struck me off is that I find him trying to control the game as the way he wants to....not a fan of such play.

I will be keeping my eye on him...

But the reason I am not finding him much of a sus as of now is that he is also among those who didn't try to capitalize our heated argument and tried to push sus on either of us.....
So...scenario:

Al is scum and knows our argument is Town vs Town, so he let's us go and deflects to a different player.


Likely scenario or not?
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
As I said to @NeutralWatcher:
"It is the part in which @Reborn was accused of being a scum by @Flower whilst working with @Bogard based on an earlier dialogue between @TheAncientCenturion and him.
After that, it is one of these usual "You are suspicious!", "No, you are!" dialogues in the early game.

My personal guess is:

A) Reborn and Co simply try to sound like nothing about them is suspicious.
B) They are baiting reactions from every player to see which one shows some suspicious signs.
C) As scums, they either play very defensive (hence mostly being inactive or going with the majority to avoid being focused too much) or they are directly playing aggressive in order to prevent that people may think "Look, why is user x that silent?", "He/She just goes with the majority" and instead, they could come to a conclusion like that "I doubt scums would play that offensive during day 1! They would unnecessarily make themselves suspicious on the good players."

But as I said, it's day 1 and thus, it is still difficult to search the scum between these users based on this heated debate. I guess, they simply try to bait some suspicious reactions which itself is not really unreasonable.
Since point C) has high risks, I'd say point B) is more likely at this point."

Furthermore, imo the experienced players are quite suspicious by playing absolutely inactive. It seems like they are using this opportunity of your debate with Flower to stay silent.



What do you think of my posts? I try to find the scums - and I don't really consider you and Flower as scums.
So can you share whom you find as sus?
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
read my posts you'll get my reads easily

I don't need to give you reasons as my play will say all
Yes you need to if you are townie


You can't leave us guessing your gameplay when you can legit help us catch scum by being more open if you are townie...so why not being open?
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
So...scenario:

Al is scum and knows our argument is Town vs Town, so he let's us go and deflects to a different player.


Likely scenario or not?
It could be....but he isn't deflecting to any other player as well...or did he and I overlooked?????

I will re read his post just to be sure of
 

Bogard

You can't win
Now, remaining particpants I have a quick questions for you all... please answer them honestly instead of dodging the question

@Rej @AL sama @Finalbeta @Pantheos @TheAncientCenturion @Bogard @Law @NeutralWatcher @Fujishiro @Sentinel

1) give me your reads on game
Already gave my reads before: https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/game-03-one-piece-dressrosa.3321/page-13#post-268699
i think there is a misunderstanding between Reborn and Flower. Reborn was just trying to figure out TAC's gameplay, if it was working for town or not, because his meta from previous game wasn't helping town even when he was town himself, but considering it's Flower's first game on this forum, she may not know this. AL is posting fairly ok, asking questions, so nothing much suspicious about him thus far

@Law 's inactivity as well as yours is questionable though, but Law posted this at the beginning

And it seems he didn't log in since few minutes after that, so either he is really busy this sunday or he is trying to play safe
To me, both Flower and you were just arguing based on a misunderstanding. I view both of you as town because you're arguing way too openly without hiding anything, which is very town-like

However i'm very suspicious of @Rej and @Law because
> Law you usually are reasonably active in these games, asking questions, don't see you doing it thus far
> Rej usually starts with his usual pressure play with votes, but is quiet thus far
So they're in my scum list at the moment.
2) give me reasons to consider that you guys are townie?
I think my reply to the first question is linked to this question
 
Yes you need to if you are townie


You can't leave us guessing your gameplay when you can legit help us catch scum by being more open if you are townie...so why not being open?
interesting so me telling you why you should consider me as town will help you catch scums??

be open with what exactly??
 
Also he voted for Bogard and was fine with me pressure voting you when apparently he was reading us both as Town which makes this pure nonsense.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
He tried some stuff with Beta. Who is a perfect lynch push because of his play style.
But beta definitely look sus with his game play - calculative, not so open, timing his post well....

And Al was also the first one along with playa to say that our argument is townie like...


Anyway, I am reading thread again to see if I missed something....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top