General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet

[Kishido]

Here we have a proof that mods only give a fuck about clicks and posts to have huge traffic.

Because there was no reason to unban that guy from this thread

 

[Logiko]

Here we have a proof that mods only give a fuck about clicks and posts to have huge traffic.

Because there was no reason to unban that guy from this thread

I was not unban, my ban was temporary. Plus there was not ethical reason to ban me either. It was done only because the mods were a little triggered by me saying that there is toxicity here that they don't want to delete. Making them systematically problematic :)

 

[Animangaboy]

being fascinated is a thing and actually knowing why a character must follow another with their life is another. Completely different things.

First, u say that Yamato doesn't know the importance of Luffy now u are changing it to have another reason to follow luffy 😭😭

 

[Monkey D Al]

Being fascinated is one thing, being convinced that Luffy is the man that will become the pirate King and help you fullfill your purpose and be you life long friend is another.

Yamato as yet to understand why she would follow Luffy with her life. Right now, she is FAR from that point, Carrot on the other hand, not so much.



No it's not.

1. Yamato didn't decided to follow Luffy, she is not following him, what she is following right now is her desire to free Wano.
2. The reason why she DECIDED that she had a place on the Sunny was because Luffy was Ace' brother. There is no other reason until now in the story. Don't invent stuff.


We don't know that. Don't invent stuff




No. She was a supporting ennemy character. Her importance only came to light during the very end of whole cake. Her status gave you the illusion of importance (and Oda was counting on that). But in the fact, what Robin did was very little until the very end of the arc.



That makes her a savior, not a foundamental character of the arc. By that logic I could say that carrot saved the strawhat at the end of whole cake and is therefore important in the arc. (and don't even TRY to debate that point, I won't reply to BS more than necessary) And it would not be fair. Carrot was not THAT important in the arc.

On the other hand, you couled argue that Brook was.


Only you finds way to spin your own argumentation to avoid the realization of being proven wrong.
[automerge]1650392773[/automerge]


Like I said, being fascinated is a thing and actually knowing why a character must follow another with their life is another. Completely different things.




No you can't replace Carrot. You would need to completely change the story to do that. Just like you would need to change the story to replace Robin.

Wrong lol

 

[Logiko]

First, u say that Yamato doesn't know the importance of Luffy now u are changing it to have another reason to follow luffy 😭😭

Knowing that Luffy will defeat Kaido is different that knowing the importance of Luffy regarding the world and the world of Pirates. I'm not changing anything, you are just not understanding the reasons Yamato must understand to follow Luffy ;)

Wrong lol

Nah, the story is factual my dear.

 

[thedarkdragon11]

Plus there was not ethical reason to ban me either. I

Actually, there are more reasons for that than reasons why Carrot will join...

 

[Logiko]

Actually, there are more reasons for that than reasons why Carrot will join...

Nah lol but good try

 

[Kishido]

I was not unban, my ban was temporary. Plus there was not ethical reason to ban me either. It was done only because the mods were a little triggered by me saying that there is toxicity here that they don't want to delete. Making them systematically problematic :)

Lol

 

[Monkey D Al]

Nah lol but good try

There facts. Just read the thread my dear. Lol

 

[Animangaboy]

you can't replace Carrot. You would need to completely change the story to do that. Just like you would need to change the story to replace Robin.

Show me what carrot does that makes her unreplaceable? Cause what is done in the story other minks can do too.
-Crying over Pedro's death Wanda can do that.
-Sneak on Sunny when no one is looking a other minks can do that
- Make sanji feel better A Female Mink can do that
So tell me what she does that makes it only for her? 🤔

 

[Logiko]

There facts. Just read the thread my dear. Lol

What thread ?

 

[VegaFunk]

Its evidently going to be the Gorosei.

 

[Logiko]

Show me what carrot does that makes her unreplaceable? Cause what is done in the story other minks can do too.
-Crying over Pedro's death Wanda can do that.
-Sneak on Sunny when no one is looking a other minks can do that
- Make sanji feel better A Female Mink can do that
So tell me what she does that makes it only for her? 🤔

We are not about the character here, we are talking about the actions. What you just said is irrelevant to the conversation. In term of character of course Robin has an advantage over Carrot as she can read poneglyph. But reading poneglyph doesn't make her more important that Carrot in the overall arc.

That's basic storytelling and you can't understand that.

 

[Animangaboy]

Knowing that Luffy will defeat Kaido is different that knowing the importance of Luffy regarding the world and the world of Pirates. I'm not changing anything, you are just not understanding the reasons Yamato must understand to follow Luffy

Hmmm, 🤔 “THE ONE ODEN WAS WAITING ON”
“ACE'S BROTHER”
“I WAS WAITING ON YOU FOR A LONG TIME”

 

[Logiko]

Hmmm, 🤔 “THE ONE ODEN WAS WAITING ON”
“ACE'S BROTHER”
“I WAS WAITING ON YOU FOR A LONG TIME”

This doesn't give us a reason why she would put her life on the line FOR Luffy. Those are just here to make you understand that Luffy is important for Wano's sake.

It's really not hard to understand.

 

[Animangaboy]

We are not about the character here, we are talking about the actions. What you just said is irrelevant to the conversation. In term of character of course Robin has an advantage over Carrot as she can read poneglyph. But reading poneglyph doesn't make her more important that Carrot in the overall arc.

That's basic storytelling and you can't understand that.

😭😭😭😂😂😂 So who is the WG after? Who bigmom tell kaido not to kill?
Who is the key to the One Piece?
Carrot doesn't even come close to robin important terms in the STORY ITSELF

 

[Logiko]

😭😭😭😂😂😂 So who is the WG after? Who bigmom tell kaido not to kill?
Who is the key to the One Piece?
Carrot doesn't even come close to robin important terms in the STORY ITSELF

The importance of Robin was only revealed at the VERY END of the arc. We are not talking about the importance of RObin in the story itself but in ONE arc.

Stop changing the goal post. I see you.

 

[Blizz532]

We are not about the character here, we are talking about the actions. What you just said is irrelevant to the conversation. In term of character of course Robin has an advantage over Carrot as she can read poneglyph. But reading poneglyph doesn't make her more important that Carrot in the overall arc.

That's basic storytelling and you can't understand that.

Nah, wth did I just read, Carrot is more important than Robin in the overall arc?

 

[Animangaboy]

The importance of Robin was only revealed at the VERY END of the arc. We are not talking about the importance of RObin in the story itself but in ONE arc.

Stop changing the goal post. I see you.

The fact that Robin knows about the Ancient Weapon Pluton but lies about it to crocodile goes over everything that carrot does in the ONE PIECES story 👀.

 

[Monkey D Al]

What thread ?

This thread. Read your comments and you’ll understand why you got banned.