Powers & Abilities Which one is more impressive, breaking bones or leaving a scar

Which one is more painful

  • Broken bones

    Votes: 115 61.8%
  • A scar

    Votes: 71 38.2%

  • Total voters
    186
Did you just compare weak spikes attack to a strong dragon bite from a dragon the same size as Kaido. Momo attack didn't damage Kaido.

It's simple. Big Mom damaged herself when she tripped and fell. Kaido couldn't hurt himself when he tried to kill himself by jumping off skypiea.
In zoro fan mind: "Monosuke is stronger than Kid confirmed"
 
Kid attack was not stronger than Momo dragon bite. That attack power was similar to Hawkins nail attack.

Screaming doesn't mean you are injured. It's a sign of pain there is a difference.

If Oda wanted Big Mom to be more durable than Kaido he would have had her take power ryu attacks from swordsman with no damage or take internal destruction haki attacks from Luffy with no damage. Instead, those types of attacks were never used against her. She used blackened haki to block WCI G4 attack.



Big Mom




Kaido

I like how you explicitly ignore the context here.

Big Mom’s durability is tied to her mental state, and when she’s unstable her defenses are down, hence the whole plan to assassinate her when she goes berserk. Hell even Bege says it in the example you showed lol.


Big Mom has had as much hype if not more than Kaido when it comes to durability, and also better feats like no selling Kid’s nails while Kaido was yelling from the top of his lungs from Momo’s bite.
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
Paper cut can leave a scar

Breaking bone is way more impressive
Paper cut can't scar a dragon
Post automatically merged:

I like how you explicitly ignore the context here.

Big Mom’s durability is tied to her mental state, and when she’s unstable her defenses are down, hence the whole plan to assassinate her when she goes berserk. Hell even Bege says it in the example you showed lol.


Big Mom has had as much hype if not more than Kaido when it comes to durability, and also better feats like no selling Kid’s nails while Kaido was yelling from the top of his lungs from Momo’s bite.
No she doesn't this is retarded
Meme was hurt by metal beams and needed to heal herself
And use her own life

Same attack wouldn't even hurt kaido
 
In zoro fan mind: "Monosuke is stronger than Kid confirmed"
Stop coping. I didn't say anything about Momo being stronger than Kid. I was comparing Kid's harpoon attack to a bit from a dragon equal in size to Kaido.

Kid's harpoon attack wasn't strong or powerful. Being used against Big Mom doesn't make it powerful or stronger than Momo's dragon bite. There was nothing impressive about that attack. Look at the situation it was used in against Big Mom. It was just used as a distraction.

The flaw in your argument is you believe Kid attacks must be stronger than Momo's attack because Kid is stronger. That's not how things work. An attack from the stronger character is not automatically stronger than an attack from a weaker character. You have to look at each individual attacks.

I like how you explicitly ignore the context here.

Big Mom’s durability is tied to her mental state, and when she’s unstable her defenses are down, hence the whole plan to assassinate her when she goes berserk. Hell even Bege says it in the example you showed lol.


Big Mom has had as much hype if not more than Kaido when it comes to durability, and also better feats like no selling Kid’s nails while Kaido was yelling from the top of his lungs from Momo’s bite.
It doesn't matter if her durability is tied to her mental state it still doesn't have more hype than Kaido's. Her body was never hyped up to be invincible. It was described as an iron balloon or steel blimp. Zoro cut through a character (Das Bones) with a steel body pre TS. Then cut and damage a character with a more durable steel body during Thiller Bark. Zoro would easily cut and damage Big Mom.

We have seen big mom hurt and injured by non-haki physical attacks. Kid hurt her with his giant metal bull and by attracting steel beams to her body.

Kaido's body was said to be invincible. Excluding internal attacks, the only type of attack shown to hurt Kaido are attacks with powerful Ryu (CoA haki) or CoC haki. When I say hurt I mean cause Kaido ti bleed. Not just made him yell in pain. Kaido wasn't hurt when he jumped off Skypiea.

If Oda wanted Big Mom to be more durable than Kaido he would have had her take power ryu attacks from swordsman with no damage or take haki attacks from Luffy with no damage. She used haki to block WCI Luffy G4 attack.

The characters with powerful ryu (haki) faced Kaido. Zoro later fought a character with greater durability and defense than Kaido and Big Mom. While Kid, the character without powerful haki, faced Big Mom. Kid hurt Big Mom without powerful haki.

It doesn't matter how you look at it, Oda has made it very clear Kaido is much more durable than Big Mom.
 
Breaking ribs is not the same as breaking a limb to the point of it flacidly hanging uselessly.

The scar that went deep enough and nerfed Zoro for an arc after he got it is not the same as a scar that didn't even knock Kaido down and instantly recovered with no impact on his combat ability.
lol now breaking hand > breaking ribs now ? literally in the same chapter sanji was screaming from the pain while he tried to kick gin cause of his broken ribs .
the fact that people still take the ' knocking down ' literally just shows the lack of braincells they have , zoro got fucked up cause he wasnt a mythical zoan and didnt had toptier regen
Post automatically merged:

Big Mom was in no condition to fight to her fullest capabilities with her arm hanging like that, can’t say the same for Kaido tho
well i mean if u remove kaido's devil fruit which gives him toptier durab and endurance then he will basically have wb durability and will prob die from ashura lol and the durab part cant be said the same for law considering law bypasses all durab
 
Last edited:
Stop coping. I didn't say anything about Momo being stronger than Kid. I was comparing Kid's harpoon attack to a bit from a dragon equal in size to Kaido.

Kid's harpoon attack wasn't strong or powerful. Being used against Big Mom doesn't make it powerful or stronger than Momo's dragon bite. There was nothing impressive about that attack. Look at the situation it was used in against Big Mom. It was just used as a distraction.

The flaw in your argument is you believe Kid attacks must be stronger than Momo's attack because Kid is stronger. That's not how things work. An attack from the stronger character is not automatically stronger than an attack from a weaker character. You have to look at each individual attacks.



It doesn't matter if her durability is tied to her mental state it still doesn't have more hype than Kaido's. Her body was never hyped up to be invincible. It was described as an iron balloon or steel blimp. Zoro cut through a character (Das Bones) with a steel body pre TS. Then cut and damage a character with a more durable steel body during Thiller Bark. Zoro would easily cut and damage Big Mom.

We have seen big mom hurt and injured by non-haki physical attacks. Kid hurt her with his giant metal bull and by attracting steel beams to her body.

Kaido's body was said to be invincible. Excluding internal attacks, the only type of attack shown to hurt Kaido are attacks with powerful Ryu (CoA haki) or CoC haki. When I say hurt I mean cause Kaido ti bleed. Not just made him yell in pain. Kaido wasn't hurt when he jumped off Skypiea.

If Oda wanted Big Mom to be more durable than Kaido he would have had her take power ryu attacks from swordsman with no damage or take haki attacks from Luffy with no damage. She used haki to block WCI Luffy G4 attack.

The characters with powerful ryu (haki) faced Kaido. Zoro later fought a character with greater durability and defense than Kaido and Big Mom. While Kid, the character without powerful haki, faced Big Mom. Kid hurt Big Mom without powerful haki.

It doesn't matter how you look at it, Oda has made it very clear Kaido is much more durable than Big Mom.
It does matter that her durability is tied to her mental state because you purposely took it out of context to downplay Big Mom’s durability.

And you’re clearly bias because it is clear as day that Kid, someone who purely relies on physical force was able to hurt Kaido just the same as Big Mom. He even complimented the three captains being able to hurt him.

And yes, Big Mom’s body is hyped up to be invincible just like Kaido’s.



The portrayal is clear as day in this panel. It is constantly shown that both of their durability are relative.
Post automatically merged:

lol now breaking hand > breaking ribs now ? literally in the same chapter sanji was screaming from the pain while he tried to kick gin cause of his broken ribs .
the fact that people still take the ' knocking down ' literally just shows the lack of braincells they have , zoro got fucked up cause he wasnt a mythical zoan and didnt had toptier regen
Post automatically merged:


well i mean if u remove kaido's devil fruit which gives him toptier durab and endurance then he will basically have wb durability and will prob die from ashura lol and the durab part cant be said the same for law considering law bypasses all durab
You said a whole lot of nothing my guy, just what if scenarios
 
i got scars from acne.
And? You are not Kaido who can jump off a building and sustain zero damage.

It's pathetic how so many want to compare a real person's body, who can easily be cut and scarred with paper, to Kaido who requires steel+ cutting attacks to damage him.
Post automatically merged:

Surface level scars are obviously nothing serious
You can get scarred from an impact that broke your bones too lol and it’s a lot more painful
Scar=skin damage
Breaking bones is far more impressive
Here's another one. Kaido doesn't have a real life human body.

Both Kaido and Big Mom are hard to damage because of their durable body/skin, not bones.
 
And? You are not Kaido who can jump off a building and sustain zero damage.

It's pathetic how so many want to compare a real person's body, who can easily be cut and scarred with paper, to Kaido who requires steel+ cutting attacks to damage him.
Post automatically merged:


Here's another one. Kaido doesn't have a real life human body.

Both Kaido and Big Mom are hard to damage because of their durable body/skin, not bones.
its ok many famous people in the past also missed the point sometimes.
 
its ok many famous people in the past also missed the point sometimes.
There's nothing to miss. You're comparing a real person's body to a fictional characters body who has a near invincible body. Doesn't matter how you look at it that's dumb. You have to look at the world Oda created.

The fact you are using that as your argument tells me you have no argument.
 

Finalbeta

Ging Freecss stan
When it comes to deal damage Zoro is usually a grandious being but sometimes characters get unfairly heavily nerfed and they don't perform as well as at their best, not even remotely :josad:
 
There's nothing to miss. You're comparing a real person's body to a fictional characters body who has a near invincible body. Doesn't matter how you look at it that's dumb. You have to look at the world Oda created.

The fact you are using that as your argument tells me you have no argument.
Scars by definition are less damaging then broken bones. literally the only way a scar could defeat Kaidou is if it got infected. you can actually die of broken bones.
 
Top