Did Luffy Beat Kaido Fairly?


  • Total voters
    454
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
Attacks that hurt BM/kaido badly or KO them KO anyone alive

It is up to you to prive that those top tiers have endurance on rocks trio level
Never said they don't have impressive endurances and durability, but there is no need to find new ways to glorify them to be above the admirals after their defeat just because you love them better. They all have their own positives and negatives. Not everyone fights the same way that BM and Kaido do; even Luffy can't survive the damage they took but he beat Kaido and could beat Big Mom. So that's no reason to think the other characters are somehow incompetent.

I wouldnt consider WB normal body
Compared to Big Mom and Kaido, he sure does have a normal body. WB is better than normal but he doesn't have an absurdly durable body. Someone like Squard could never dream of stabbing Big Mom or Kaido even when they're sleeping.
 
He couldn't stop Ace's execution with basic CoC and didn't see the future when he needed to, despite being able to use FS asleep against Ace when not on his deathbed from sickness.
Should I have said 1% haki to help someone who can't read between the lines? Every living organism "has" haki.
You can't read at all so don't speak about "reading between the lines"

-He couldn't stop Ace's execution because Akainu blew a hole in his chest a minute before and his wound prevented him from doing so which is why he grabs it in pain when trying to.
-He was not using FS against Ace. Illiteracy strikes again. Haki RUNS OUT as confirmed by Luffy in WCI, WB isn't activating his CoO all night long, that's just basic reflexes and instincts.
-Even with HALF OF HIS FACE GONE he could still use CoA to strike Akainu

Cope harder, even his Marineford VC has all 3 haki types listed.
 
Big mom was still fine and mad after that attack, remember kidd did one attack and bombs finished her ? She also jumped from several meters so yeah it's not island lvl unless you think a hole of big mom's size (she is fat yeah) is island lvl :milaugh:
-Testament of her endurance, she was more fresh than Kaidou and even Law/Kidd going into the fight. It’s expected she’d tank more

We don’t know the exact size of the hole lol
Just because we see BM looking big at one point (Oda’s very inconsistent), we also see the crater dwarfing the mountain ranges around it
It’s also at least a 1/3 or Onigashima from Oda’s diagram
And sure, height doesn’t matter, only the diameter :saden:
Law can erase a town-sized diameter of landmass all the way to the other side of the planet, and “it’s stil‘s not island level” right?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top