Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Theories need to be proven, buddy.
Not disproven.

What Is a Theory?
A scientific theory is an explanation for a natural phenomenon that is widely accepted among the scientific community and supported by data.
On the contrary. A theory needs to be disproven. This is the principle of refutability.

The CarrotForNakama theory, is the best way to explain all the weird occurence and weird treatment of Carrot in whole cake. It CAN be disproven, but not until a very specific moment.

Until then you will just have to wait or come with a better explanation for Carrot's weird treatment. Because "she is just a background or Oda did that by pure whim" doesn't make sence on a narrative basis.
 
Carrot is not only friend with them, Oda created a STRONG bond between her and some of the strawhats, it's beyond "friend".
Bonds??? I guess Otama has that bond too cause just because she is with them doesn't mean that she bonds with them she can be friends with them but I just you over-read once again like you always do where was her reaction to luffy winning to kaido?
 
On the contrary. A theory needs to be disproven. This is the principle of refutability.

The CarrotForNakama theory, is the best way to explain all the weird occurence and weird treatment of Carrot in whole cake. It CAN be disproven, but not until a very specific moment.

Until then you will just have to wait or come with a better explanation for Carrot's weird treatment. Because "she is just a background or Oda did that by pure whim" doesn't make sence on a narrative basis.
Carrot chance to joining died after SH leaved WCI, on Wano she is only one of the minks in the country.
 
On the contrary. A theory needs to be disproven. This is the principle of refutability.

The CarrotForNakama theory, is the best way to explain all the weird occurence and weird treatment of Carrot in whole cake. It CAN be disproven, but not until a very specific moment.

Until then you will just have to wait or come with a better explanation for Carrot's weird treatment. Because "she is just a background or Oda did that by pure whim" doesn't make sence on a narrative basis.
Scientific theories are testable and make falsifiable predictions.[7]
 
Carrot chance to joining died after SH leaved WCI, on Wano she is only one of the minks in the country.
No. Even in Wano her treatment in different from normal minks.


Scientific theories are testable and make falsifiable predictions.
In fact, a lot of scientific theories are not testable. That's why some scientists are searching for the best theories. That's why Einstein's general relativity theory is better than Newton's gravity theory to explain gravitation.

But that's also why you can't disprove my theory. Right now, only the Carrot for Nakama theory can explain the weird treatment of Carrot in wholecake and Wano. Nothing else. So by saying "your theory is false" you are just saying "I don't believe you, but I have nothing to say that could explain what we are seeing".. so logically, you are all failling against me and despite being alone against 10.. I still come up on top.
Post automatically merged:

Look, your ways of hypothesizing things may have worked on another literary work or two, but it won't always work on other works, especially One Piece...

Enough with your copium...
:kuzanshut:
 
No. Even in Wano her treatment in different from normal minks.




In fact, a lot of scientific theories are not testable. That's why some scientists are searching for the best theories. That's why Einstein's general relativity theory is better than Newton's gravity theory to explain gravitation.

But that's also why you can't disprove my theory. Right now, only the Carrot for Nakama theory can explain the weird treatment of Carrot in wholecake and Wano. Nothing else. So by saying "your theory is false" you are just saying "I don't believe you, but I have nothing to say that could explain what we are seeing".. so logically, you are all failling against me and despite being alone against 10.. I still come up on top.
Post automatically merged:


:kuzanshut:
Einstein gravitation has been proven by the curvature of light.
Another lie, spoken without any knowledge about anything. Ignorant is what better describes you.
 
No. Even in Wano her treatment in different from normal minks.




In fact, a lot of scientific theories are not testable. That's why some scientists are searching for the best theories. That's why Einstein's general relativity theory is better than Newton's gravity theory to explain gravitation.

But that's also why you can't disprove my theory. Right now, only the Carrot for Nakama theory can explain the weird treatment of Carrot in wholecake and Wano. Nothing else. So by saying "your theory is false" you are just saying "I don't believe you, but I have nothing to say that could explain what we are seeing".. so logically, you are all failling against me and despite being alone against 10.. I still come up on top.
Post automatically merged:


:kuzanshut:
what youve said here in no way qualifies as a theory. :okay:
what u claim as evidence is nothing more than confirmation bias
 
@Animangaboy
He is right It is only matter time until Yamato ends up meeting the other members of the strawhat crew and get wanted poster alongside with them as well just like Franky did in enis lobby. You cannot tell me Kaido's flashback did not answer these following questions. For example, why did he choose wano, why does kaido refer Yamato's as his son, what happened to Yamato's mother, his and her race about the ogres. What classifies them as such? What is Yamato and kaido relationship before they met oden. Where was Yamato's even born when Kaido state Yamato is not native to wano despite fighting for them.


Carrot is not going to join the crew she does not add anything new to the story. Her problem has been resolved by non strawhats. Saying she does not need past just means you do not care for her reason for set dream/goal or past trauma that the strawhats need to resolve for her. Saying she does not need to take part in this current arc and is not about her it does further our notion she will not be part of them. Saying Carrot needs to come understand to try proving her worthiness member crew it just like you dreaming just like how fans wanted Bartolomeo to join main team.

"A strong bond with ha"!
Yes, a bond with half of the strawhats. The strawhats were not worried or concern about carrot whereabouts when they were in wano and throughout the raid. Big bro Chopper did not show any concern for his little sister being hurt, being defeat by perospero and during the fire throughout the battlefield. So how does strong bond if they never came to her defense or show concern for her as a character..
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top