General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
Dude she literally said that she was waiting on the day when someone will take kaido and will leave wano did you read the story? Also if her being abused does not stop her from wanting to be Oden and want to leave wano you think a little war that she has been waiting for going to change her ðŸ˜ðŸ˜ðŸ˜ Kaido literally said that Yamato tries to escape from the island in chapter 1026
And in a series as unashamedly goofy and silly as One Piece, comedy is a strong enough purpose in itself
That’s just you projecting onto her. Every point you could make for Carrot could just as easily be applied to dozens of other characters.
Making things more interesting is a perfectly valid purpose. Adding comedy is a perfectly valid purpose. A character’s purpose doesn’t need to be deep. That’s just part of writing a story. Even in legendary works of literature like Crime and Punishment, you have characters like Alyona who were only there to be an asshole, get killed, and then cause the plot to get rolling without any kind of meaningful development.
All Carrot had to do to justify her existence was to be entertaining, which she was. And she also showed off Sulong, so there’s even more justification for her treatment. She doesn’t really need anything more
Hawkins, Apoo, and X Drake didn’t (they could still be salvaged but it’s looking unlikely).
Oda’s done an impressive job with them overall considering he came up with them on the fly, but you could easily cut out a number of them without losing much
Except you responded to me talking about Carrot having gags with Chopper
That’s just you projecting onto her. Every point you could make for Carrot could just as easily be applied to dozens of other characters.
Making things more interesting is a perfectly valid purpose. Adding comedy is a perfectly valid purpose. A character’s purpose doesn’t need to be deep. That’s just part of writing a story. Even in legendary works of literature like Crime and Punishment, you have characters like Alyona who were only there to be an asshole, get killed, and then cause the plot to get rolling without any kind of meaningful development.
All Carrot had to do to justify her existence was to be entertaining, which she was. And she also showed off Sulong, so there’s even more justification for her treatment. She doesn’t really need anything more
Hawkins, Apoo, and X Drake didn’t (they could still be salvaged but it’s looking unlikely).
Oda’s done an impressive job with them overall considering he came up with them on the fly, but you could easily cut out a number of them without losing much
Except you responded to me talking about Carrot having gags with Chopper
Yeah no. Plus Carrot is not even the most goofy character there is.
Yes, strong characters. Main arc character and main characters.
"make thing more interesting" means nothing without a purpose in the story.
Not when it's a background character like Chimney or Gombey, when the characterization of a character is stronger than random background character, the purpose must follow the line.
The difference is, Oda has a very specific pattern with his character. You can almost put them in a box, that's how maniac he is with their role. By creating Carrot Oda pushed himself out of the box, out of his confort zone, and that NEEDS an explanation better than "it's just to had more goofyness", carrot is more than that. And if you don't notice it reread her story and reread it again just to be sure, because you are missing something.
Yes she does, her whole relationship with Pedro is enough to ask for a purpose for Carrot. Again.. because you are an author but can't understand that: There was NO NEED to create Carrot to show the Sulong.
Plus : The Sulong was not a simple show for the transformation of the mink, it was a full on characterization of Carrot, a full representation of what she can do . HER and noone but HER.
Yes they did. reread Wano again. They are not as important as other like Kid or Law but they have a purpose in the themes of the story and in it's development.
To show you that Chopper had most of his Gag in the beginning of the arc with Luffy, not with Carrot. So the presence of Carrot was not necessary like you said to create Gags with Chopper.
Where does it mention Wano here ? She wants to leave Onigashima, not Wano. And leaving out to sea does not mean she wants to flee off Wano.
Because there is reason to believe, that Momo changed her mind.
Not anymore.
This forum calling out my tunnel vision but unable to see a simple subversion dialogue....
Yes, strong characters. Main arc character and main characters.
"make thing more interesting" means nothing without a purpose in the story.
Not when it's a background character like Chimney or Gombey, when the characterization of a character is stronger than random background character, the purpose must follow the line.
The difference is, Oda has a very specific pattern with his character. You can almost put them in a box, that's how maniac he is with their role. By creating Carrot Oda pushed himself out of the box, out of his confort zone, and that NEEDS an explanation better than "it's just to had more goofyness", carrot is more than that. And if you don't notice it reread her story and reread it again just to be sure, because you are missing something.
Yes she does, her whole relationship with Pedro is enough to ask for a purpose for Carrot. Again.. because you are an author but can't understand that: There was NO NEED to create Carrot to show the Sulong.
Plus : The Sulong was not a simple show for the transformation of the mink, it was a full on characterization of Carrot, a full representation of what she can do . HER and noone but HER.
Yes they did. reread Wano again. They are not as important as other like Kid or Law but they have a purpose in the themes of the story and in it's development.
To show you that Chopper had most of his Gag in the beginning of the arc with Luffy, not with Carrot. So the presence of Carrot was not necessary like you said to create Gags with Chopper.
Where does it mention Wano here ? She wants to leave Onigashima, not Wano. And leaving out to sea does not mean she wants to flee off Wano.
Because there is reason to believe, that Momo changed her mind.
Not anymore.
This forum calling out my tunnel vision but unable to see a simple subversion dialogue....
- Status