Break Week Yamato joining is a win-win for Sanji fans

So we are repeating the Jinbe arguments as well.

BTW we had originally 4 commanders for BM. 12 commanders if WBs and know jackshit about Redhairs.

But hey let us use our 3 commanders head canon for Yonkous for everyone.
First of all, I don't respond for other people and I'm not part of a hive mind. Therefore, there's no "we" here.

Second, this is merely a conjecture.

Third, I'm not talking about the story of the formation of YCs. I only care about the current ones. BM having 4 in the past is irrelevant.
 
didn't sanji have an easier time fighting jabra than zoro did kaku?
Kaku had swords on top of Rokushiki, but even if you'd argue the gap between them I'd say no
Not a lot of difference but Sanji had to take Jabura's attack to get closer, while Zoro just shredded that shit. Makes sense as to why Sanji was breathing harder when all was said and done.

But in fairness neither looked bad
 
First of all, I don't respond for other people and I'm not part of a hive mind. Therefore, there's no "we" here.

Second, this is merely a conjecture.

Third, I'm not talking about the story of the formation of YCs. I only care about the current ones. BM having 4 in the past is irrelevant.
How many has Shanks? Maybe Yamato will fight Yasopp
 
You're assuming? I thought I was pretty clear in saying Yamato could wash #4 and Sanji could edge out #3. I'm sure the same for Jinbe going forward, even out of his element.

No, the "rank" doesn't matter. Mohji is ranked higher than Kabaji. Magellan is now vice warden. Luffy could eat a punch from Sengoku when Akainu could murder him with one hit.

What matters is what we see. Yamato trades with Kaido even at a disadvantage, without knowing how to mutate Sanji gets low diffed by someone like Queen.

People who go by numbers, like who joined first, are blind. Oda made fun of it at the Sabaody reunion and you probably didn't notice.

"You're assuming? I thought I was pretty clear in saying Yamato could wash #4 and Sanji could edge out #3. I'm sure the same for Jinbe going forward, even out of his element."
Surely if Yamato is "washing" her opponents there would be no need for her to actually get stronger, you're arguing for Yamatos power stagnation here. Characters get stronger by fighting real competition and getting power ups, the fact you're ready to accept Oda just handing Yamato significant power boosts while fighting more or less "fodder"(relative to her) but can't accept Oda just bumping Sanji up above Yamato already is nonsensical.

You're further ignoring the fact that Oda always matches the crews strength hierarchy with the opponents they face off against, it's no mystery why Zoro continues to fight the second strongest.....since he's the second strongest.

"What matters is what we see. Yamato trades with Kaido even at a disadvantage, without knowing how to mutate Sanji gets low diffed by someone like Queen."
You mean like Zoro being bested by a far inferior opponent in King even after the events of the rooftop. Funny that the same arguments could be applied to Robin, Franky and Jinbei who all looked superior to Zoro and Sanji at one point in time, so much so the audience was convinced they had changed the dynamic; only for Oda to reaffirm it in the next arc.

What Yamato did is ultimately unquantifiable, furthermore we have no idea how current Sanji could hold up against Kaido, it's all headcanonn until Oda shows us the hierarchy as he always has; through the fights.

"No, the "rank" doesn't matter. Mohji is ranked higher than Kabaji. Magellan is now vice warden. Luffy could eat a punch from Sengoku when Akainu could murder him with one hit."
I'm not going by "rank", the strawhat crew is not a meritocracy, I'm talking about the fundamental and unchanged dynamic of Luffy taking on the strongest , Zoro the second and Sanji the third. You are also incorrect about Mohji and Cabaji. After the supposed "death" of Buggy, they had dueled in hopes of determining who would take over as captain, if Mohiji ranked higher they would have no need for such an event. They also fought to a draw.


"People who go by numbers, like who joined first, are blind. Oda made fun of it at the Sabaody reunion and you probably didn't notice."
I'm referring to the dynamic of the M3 and The Wings; the dynamic of Sanji always fighting the 3rd strongest, I'm unsure as to when Oda made fun of this concept he has held on to for over 20 years.
 
- Power stagnation, uh... well, Zoro had like two hits landed on him in a fight between Sabaody and Ringo. This late in the series, no, I don't expect tremendous growth for most characters especially a newer one.

Funny enough, until Enies Lobby Robin was arguably the second strongest because of the way her powers work. I think the introduction of long range attacks in Skypiea made Zoro seem very formidable but it was a long time before they could leave her behind.

- The hierarchy again. Zoro took out Morgan. Sanji was ravaged by Krieg's goons while Zoro fought a guy leagues beyond anyone else present, including himself. Hatchan the second strongest? Lol, I guess. Nothing to really think hard about. In Jaya Zoro had nothing to do with a Sarquiss rematch. Skypiea Zoro took on the second strongest but Luffy, Usopp, and Sanji all teamed up for like the 4th strongest. No one who fought Zoro in Thriller Bark really had that distinction. Vergo was clearly tougher than Monet. Sabo, Law, and Luffy took on Burgess, Fujitora, and Doflamingo... Pica wasn't second strongest when you look at that group. Basically you're saying, "it happens all the time except when it doesn't."

- Zoro being bested by King... are you high? Whenever I see a longer response and come across something that is this biased, I don't really have the interest in reading further, no offense. I'll just at least try to get myself back on topic, and I guess this is basically Sanji vs Yamato, with saying that Sanji vs Kaido is no mystery without his upgrades. Queen crushed him and the only reason he got out of that is because Queen's fighting ability doesn't match his physical strength or maniacal genius. The recovery and physical strength he gained from there though... not even Gear 4 could hurt Kaido without very advanced Haki.
 
Any feats or portrayal from scopper?o yeah nothing
He s irrelevant
We have filler feats, sweating bullets while clashing with casual no ryuo/CoC rookie Oden and the grenade thing that portrayed him as a joke, his haki wouldn't be strong enough to take a blast that Oden tanked with no haki.
Another thing is that 25 years ago Roger and Ray where in their 50's, it's very likely that Gaban is a good deal older than Oden, no CoA coating, no Ryuo or CoC, definitely not protrayed as someone that has FS, not even Roger or Ray are confirmed to have it

And apparently he was the helmsman but that's a different story. :myman:
 
- Power stagnation, uh... well, Zoro had like two hits landed on him in a fight between Sabaody and Ringo. This late in the series, no, I don't expect tremendous growth for most characters especially a newer one.

Funny enough, until Enies Lobby Robin was arguably the second strongest because of the way her powers work. I think the introduction of long range attacks in Skypiea made Zoro seem very formidable but it was a long time before they could leave her behind.

- The hierarchy again. Zoro took out Morgan. Sanji was ravaged by Krieg's goons while Zoro fought a guy leagues beyond anyone else present, including himself. Hatchan the second strongest? Lol, I guess. Nothing to really think hard about. In Jaya Zoro had nothing to do with a Sarquiss rematch. Skypiea Zoro took on the second strongest but Luffy, Usopp, and Sanji all teamed up for like the 4th strongest. No one who fought Zoro in Thriller Bark really had that distinction. Vergo was clearly tougher than Monet. Sabo, Law, and Luffy took on Burgess, Fujitora, and Doflamingo... Pica wasn't second strongest when you look at that group. Basically you're saying, "it happens all the time except when it doesn't."

- Zoro being bested by King... are you high? Whenever I see a longer response and come across something that is this biased, I don't really have the interest in reading further, no offense. I'll just at least try to get myself back on topic, and I guess this is basically Sanji vs Yamato, with saying that Sanji vs Kaido is no mystery without his upgrades. Queen crushed him and the only reason he got out of that is because Queen's fighting ability doesn't match his physical strength or maniacal genius. The recovery and physical strength he gained from there though... not even Gear 4 could hurt Kaido without very advanced Haki.
Yes, If Yamato is going to face opponents she can "wash" she is incapable of progressing power wise. If Zoro fought Page one in Wano he would not progress power wise would he?. You're argument is that Yamato will keep up with Sanjis progression, which has been shown to be significant, while not fighting anyone that would even push her to becoming more powerful. Unless you actually think Yamato is THAT much more powerful than Sanji to where she doesn't even need to get stronger to stay ahead of Sanji at the end of next arc who will be significantly stronger than he is now.

Yes, the hierarchy. I have no idea what the you're even referring to; a bunch of nebulous references to Zoro beating people who you assume Sanji couldn't defeat, while also ignoring the moments of explicit representation. Surely Zoro and Sanji fighting opponents of the same caliber in major arcs (where both are participating in fights) who push them to get stronger is clearer evidence than Zoro defeating someone who doesn't even push him to gain a power up.

Was Zoro not being bested by King until he gained CoCcoating?......did you skip past 90 percent of the fight?. Yamato clashed her Coc against a hybrid Kaido 1v1, Zoro defeating King with it is not as impressive; if we use your line of argumentation of course.
 
Kaku had swords on top of Rokushiki, but even if you'd argue the gap between them I'd say no
Not a lot of difference but Sanji had to take Jabura's attack to get closer, while Zoro just shredded that shit. Makes sense as to why Sanji was breathing harder when all was said and done.

But in fairness neither looked bad
This again? :kobeha:
Zoro no diffed Kaku's strongest attack and then oneshotted him.
Lanji's opponent had to carry Zoro's. 1 hit from Zoro >>>>>>>>> , this will never change, that's why Zoro doesn't need 12 cheapshots against someone with no super defense and instead oneshots his opponents strongest moves, weapons, mom, grandma, anything. :vistalaugh:
 
sanji beat a 2nd commander high-mid diff.
and i'm pretty sure both king and queen would be able to hold off kaido for a few minutes(aka Yamatos biggest feat)
Queen isn’t hold Kaido off Queen thought King was unbeatable? Sanji isn’t holding off Kaido. King isn’t holding off Kaido the only thing he can do is try to stay in his durable mode. Marco held Queen + King off at the same time. It’s no way they can hold Kaido off.
 
Queen isn’t hold Kaido off Queen thought King was unbeatable? Sanji isn’t holding off Kaido. King isn’t holding off Kaido the only thing he can do is try to stay in his durable mode. Marco held Queen + King off at the same time. It’s no way they can hold Kaido off.
it was already stated that kaido would have a hard time with King
 
Zoro fan boys getting desperate. There will never be a point where Yamato is stronger than Sanji.

Sanji's blue fames are WAYYYY more potent than Yamato's CoC coating. That's basic facts.





Yamato's level of CoC coating is still very basic. There are always levels to haki.

Luffy's ACoC >>> Zoro's ACoC >= Sanji's blue flames > Yamato's ACoC
 
Zoro fan boys getting desperate. There will never be a point where Yamato is stronger than Sanji.

Sanji's blue fames are WAYYYY more potent than Yamato's CoC coating. That's basic facts.





Yamato's level of CoC coating is still very basic. There are always levels to haki.

Luffy's ACoC >>> Zoro's ACoC >= Sanji's blue flames > Yamato's ACoC
Yamato > beginning of part 2 Zoro's CoA > EoS Judge's son, these are facts.
 
Zoro fan boys getting desperate. There will never be a point where Yamato is stronger than Sanji.

Sanji's blue fames are WAYYYY more potent than Yamato's CoC coating. That's basic facts.





Yamato's level of CoC coating is still very basic. There are always levels to haki.

Luffy's ACoC >>> Zoro's ACoC >= Sanji's blue flames > Yamato's ACoC
Says the desperate Lanji fan.
 
Top