Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes it's unironically the same thing. That's what Oden's log was




Again, Tama could just win fights through Gag Force. You're overcomplicating things


Again, Nami keeps a diary aside from her log as the navigator. That's exactly what Oden's log was. Yamato has no role
Post automatically merged:


But going by these sketches, Yamato clearly wasn't planned before Wano because she's in the Wano art style
:pepecopium::pepecopium::pepecopium:
 
Yes it's unironically the same thing. That's what Oden's log was




Again, Tama could just win fights through Gag Force. You're overcomplicating things


Again, Nami keeps a diary aside from her log as the navigator. That's exactly what Oden's log was. Yamato has no role
Post automatically merged:


But going by these sketches, Yamato clearly wasn't planned before Wano because she's in the Wano art style
this knocks out all the animals including tama making her ass freaking useless. Seems like that kid needs to stay her ass home with adopted her mother
 
Yes it's unironically the same thing. That's what Oden's log was




Again, Tama could just win fights through Gag Force. You're overcomplicating things


Again, Nami keeps a diary aside from her log as the navigator. That's exactly what Oden's log was. Yamato has no role
Post automatically merged:


But going by these sketches, Yamato clearly wasn't planned before Wano because she's in the Wano art style
Won't join

And automerge fail
 
Just a quick search

Just think of how much drama could've been avoided if Oda stuck with the original design he'd planned for Yamao.

An ugly little man, clearly intended as a gag reveal as Kaido's underwhelming son. But who knows...Perhaps after Oda saw the tumbling sales and how disliked Kin' eflop was, he decided he'd be better off hiding his shortcomings behind big tits and a Nami face?
It's from her vivre card. It was such a throwaway design that he later reused it for a samurai in the cave.

She was also originally called "Ninigi" after the deity who was sent by the sun goddess as an emissary to Japan to bring civilisation, justice and order to humans. https://mythopedia.com/japanese-mythology/gods/ninigi/


Not to mention her most prominent attack "Namuji Glacier", named after the Japanese god of nation-building and protective magic. Wonder what could be the meaning in all of that? :madmonk:

Real shame he didn't stick with the OG design though. Just imagine the Yamao cult attempting to enlighten us all on how humpty-dumpty over there is about to go on to become the sake brewer for the straw hats! Oh, right...without the Naminess n boobs, the cult would've never existed in the first place. Silly me.
Mentioned it a little while ago. Oda gave her original design to a one scene character.

But yeah. Pretty clearly based off that design she was supposed to have a different role. Seemed like the whole Ace stuff and being a strong adv CoC user is something that came up after Oda's initial plan. But she was always meant to be an Oden stan with the purpose of helping Wano's people.


Once they're in though, it's expected that they step it up a notch. Even more possessed screeching at strangers, hunting disbelievers and they better not be missing Wednesday night sake session. As they brew cups from each others tears and sweat.

Just look at the pathetic arguments from @dizzy2341

Also at the dummies like his stupid post all dumbass from @Topi Jerami @Rushwheel @SmokedOut @Blackbeard
 

SmokedOut

Life Is Good ✌️
Just a quick search







Just look at the pathetic arguments from @dizzy2341

Also at the dummies like his stupid post all dumbass from @Topi Jerami @Rushwheel @SmokedOut @Blackbeard
Ladies and gentlemen can we please congratulate this piece of human excrement for his riveting post?! I mean only a true douche such as this person is deserving of such an amazing award. You win! Well done!!! Nothing like berating people that liked a freakin post! Good job!!! You're a testament to all douchebags past, present, and future!! The douchery is strong with this one!




@dizzy2341 @Topi Jerami @Rushwheel @Blackbeard
 
Last edited:
Ladies and gentlemen can we please congratulate this piece of human excrement for his riveting post?! I mean only a true douche such as this person is deserving of such an amazing award. You win! Well done!!! Nothing like berating people that liked a freakin post! Good job!!! You're a testament to all douchebags past, present, and future!! The douchery is strong with this one!




@dizzy2341 @Topi Jerami @Rushwheel @Blackbeard
I mean I don't care people can be called out for the dumb shit they say, they do and all that.

At least admit it instead of sliding away.

Most of this post just shows you can't accept being called out.
 
That’s a huge stretch. It’s like saying that Spandam is Iceberg’s main enemy as well since Iceberg has attachment with Franky. Even if you say Big Mom is Pedro’s main enemy because Pedro has attachment to Big Mom, then it should be Big Mom whom Luffy defeats, not Katakuri. You’re really stretching that far. Carrot -> Pedro -> Big Mom -> Katakuri. See what I mean?

About the main antagonist defeated by Luffy, most of them Luffy takes care care of them. I previously have said that the main antagonist should be defeated by Luffy and/or any other Straw Hats prior joining. The only example is Morgan, who was defeated by Zoro; and also Robin who took out Spandam

Robin’s case is different. Crocodile was actually Robin’s main antagonist prior joining; Spandam is another one. At least Robin’s connection to Spandam is closer than what you stretch for Carrot & Big Mom since Spandam is Spandine’s son. Oda even gave Robin the extension of her past and a new antagonist (CP9 in general) that all of the Straw Hats (+Franky) took part in it. Nevertheless, although Franky didn’t defeat Spandam, he still had his role in defeating Fukuro as Luffy defeated Lucci and Robin defeated Spandam. Technically all of them are Straw Hats. Meanwhile in Carrot’s case not even a single Straw Hat helps her, or she helps Straw Hats dealing with the enemy. She lost big time, off screened, and both Carrot’s supposedly main antagonists are defeated by non Straw Hats.

The point still stands: those 3 requirements are needed before joining in the same arc

1. Terrible past usually during childhood
2. Acts as co-protagonist that helps in defeating the main antagonist
3. Main antagonist that is defeated by any Straw Hat; in this case mostly Luffy


All of Straw Hats have those 3. And again, Carrot doesn’t even have 1 of them. Even if Carrot has no 2 & 3, no 1 is the most important. Terrible past is what makes the crew is a family. That’s also the reason why Vivi didn’t join because she lacked terrible past. And that’s also why it’s number 1.
What about the 4ths thing. Nami talked about her navigation skills, Ussop sniped, sanji cooked, franky had gadgets, Robin read the poneglyph, Zoro had rumors as a good combatant, Jinbei didn't even officially join until his main highlight as the helmsmen was shown. Carrot has been shown being a look out. None of the strawhat joined without their core skill being shown. This mean we're 1/4 the way there.
 

KonyaruIchi

👑𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓟𝓲𝓻𝓪𝓽𝓮 𝓠𝓾𝓮𝓮𝓷👑
What about the 4ths thing. Nami talked about her navigation skills, Ussop sniped, sanji cooked, franky had gadgets, Robin read the poneglyph, Zoro had rumors as a good combatant, Jinbei didn't even officially join until his main highlight as the helmsmen was shown. Carrot has been shown being a look out. None of the strawhat joined without their core skill being shown. This mean we're 1/4 the way there.
"I invented a new requirement to cope about the fact Carrot absolutely does not fill the basic cores of the SHs prior to joining".

Also her "lookout" role is tenuous at best, this is just grasping at straws and even that's being generous.
 
What about the 4ths thing. Nami talked about her navigation skills, Ussop sniped, sanji cooked, franky had gadgets, Robin read the poneglyph, Zoro had rumors as a good combatant, Jinbei didn't even officially join until his main highlight as the helmsmen was shown. Carrot has been shown being a look out. None of the strawhat joined without their core skill being shown. This mean we're 1/4 the way there.
Join?

Won't








Join
 
What about the 4ths thing. Nami talked about her navigation skills, Ussop sniped, sanji cooked, franky had gadgets, Robin read the poneglyph, Zoro had rumors as a good combatant, Jinbei didn't even officially join until his main highlight as the helmsmen was shown. Carrot has been shown being a look out. None of the strawhat joined without their core skill being shown. This mean we're 1/4 the way there.
if Carrot was shown to be a good look out, she would have alarmed Zou citizens BEFORE Dressrosa SH walked pass through Zou gate. In fact, if she were a good lookout, she should’ve known when something went wrong with Bariete BEFORE Dressrosa SH passed. Even every slightest second is important. But she didn’t, even Luffy arrived to the Whale-thingy and she did her job terribly. She didn’t learn a thing especially that before Jack infiltrated Zou and almost killed Inu & Neko. That’s a “good look out” for you.


Seeing things afar, with binoculars, and you consider it “good look out”. Even Nami & Usopp did it before entering Onigashima. If she were a good look out, Oda would’ve shown her does her duty; not Nami nor Usopp




And role thing was never really that important. Luffy doesn’t give a shit about role, that’s why he invited Zombie tree and Zombie horse in Thriller Bark.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top