[FNZ] Role Madness Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Elegy of Etheirys

[Xlaw]

That no lynch on D4 gonna cost us probably lol.

Yes..cost us 2 town

 

[Ultra]

Thats my concern too..we know he can kill . May b lying about odd even..if he is mafia then definatley purple one

If you think I'm lying about being able to kill every other phase...you mean to imply I can kill every phase but I set it up to look like I can't?

I don't see why I would do that. I mean, as scum there'd be a big opportunity cost of witholding shots. Also that would be even more insane. The accusation that I can fire 1.5 times should arguably be dismissed out of hand for breaking game balance, but this definitely would no question

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Where the fuck did Blue run away to lol.

 

[Ultra]

Yeah it would *but* here it is looking like a real possibility bc even if you aren’t converted you were probably a candidate.

I guess I'm not really seeing your point here.

1.5 kills is a pretty disparate advantage not just between town and mafia but between mafia and the other mafia. Town really doesn't have the distribution of protections to justify that, and there's an obvious abundance of protects amongst scum, so that would just create a shooting gallery.

 

[Ultra]

I figured since Flower implied she could hit a button and potentially turn into SK that I'm the default Vig and she's more of a swing mechanic. Probably almost any other player presses that button, but bless her soul.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I guess I'm not really seeing your point here.

1.5 kills is a pretty disparate advantage not just between town and mafia but between mafia and the other mafia. Town really doesn't have the distribution of protections to justify that, and there's an obvious abundance of protects amongst scum, so that would just create a shooting gallery.

If you’re a convert candidate then your kills can be pro town for multiple days before turning into scum kills potentially. Or even never turning.

 

[Ultra]

I'm like the old clunker that's got 200k+ miles on it but still gets you around town while Flower's a shiny corvette that you risk driving into a tree at 100mph

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Since rn we are under the assumption Purple starts with 2 people and can get a convert while Red starts with 3 and could get a convert (tho not by direct culting it seems), it isn’t crazy that Purple would get extra killing power potential due to the numbers disadvantage.

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Its time zone which make me less active..i besically r not available at last 6 hr. First 12hr..can play 2 or 3 hrs at night..
Even then...i guess Kagura and Emily right from DP2 ...

I'm not convinced unfortunately

 

[Mashiro Blue]

@Blue what do you think of Light?

Lynch after Ultra

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Lynch after Ultra

Then what about Xlaw?

Bc we may not have a single mislynch much less two.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Why do you like Light better than Ultra?

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Then what about Xlaw?

Bc we may not have a single mislynch much less two.

I'm not feeling that good about Xlaw but I could see a world where he was left alone because he's supposedly Town vanilla and it's not much active.

What do you make of his claim?

 

[Ultra]

Since rn we are under the assumption Purple starts with 2 people and can get a convert while Red starts with 3 and could get a convert (tho not by direct culting it seems), it isn’t crazy that Purple would get extra killing power potential due to the numbers disadvantage.

I think you're underestimating the disparate impact even a .5 bump to mafia kill power would have on a standard game. I haven't done the math but that sounds pretty dire. I already know this isn't the case, but I'm not sure how anyone else can looking at what town has going on. Even worse if the opposing mafia has a proportional advantage.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I'm not feeling that good about Xlaw but I could see a world where he was left alone because he's supposedly Town vanilla and it's not much active.

What do you make of his claim?

His character or his vanilla status? Drago was vanilla Town so it isn’t unreasonable for him to be vanilla.

His character seems on the “meh” end but someone who may could be in the game.

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Why do you like Light better than Ultra?

I think both should be lynched tbh.

As for why light is better is because Ultra made some questionable amount and qualities of posts this DP.

What do you think of them?

 

[Ultra]

I think both should be lynched tbh.

As for why light is better is because Ultra made some questionable amount and qualities of posts this DP.

What do you think of them?

???

 

[Mashiro Blue]

His character or his vanilla status? Drago was vanilla Town so it isn’t unreasonable for him to be vanilla.

His character seems on the “meh” end but someone who may could be in the game.

Any characger can be in the game.

My waifubro wouldn't make it that easy.

Thing about Xlaw is that he has almost ghosted his way until this DP

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I think both should be lynched tbh.

As for why light is better is because Ultra made some questionable amount and qualities of posts this DP.

What do you think of them?

Besides keeping you open ended (which I may should be doing also after I wrote you off in GOT) , I honestly feel like Light’s looked worse.

Which post of Ultra do you deem questionable?

 

[Mashiro Blue]

???

More specifically the amount of posts in the beginning of DP as explained in a precious post of mine and that Blue thing